Zemmour Back to 1930s Hate Politics
Denis MacShane
Writer, consultant on European Policy and Politics at Represented by Specialist Speakers
?Suddenly, the French election is coming to life – but not in the way anyone imagined only two months ago.
At that point in time, the French and European commentariat assumed, the world would see a re-run of the 2017 election between Emmanuel Macron and Marine Le Pen, resulting in an easy win for President Macron, the incumbent.
A very different race now
There was also an expectation that the French left and the country’s Greens would make good showing at the polls.
After all, that is what has happened in other European countries of late, including in Germany, Spain or the Nordic states.
However, none of the left or Green party candidates have made any breakthrough.
As things stand, France’s once-great Socialist Party that in 2012 won the Elysée and the National Assembly will be lucky to get five per cent in the presidential contest.
Enter the far-right loudmouth
Instead, a loud-mouth far right polemicist, Eric Zemmour, is dominating all the airwaves and newspaper columns.
Monsieur Zemmour has never been elected to anything. He is sometimes compared to Donald Trump as he is a white supremacist. But Zemmour makes Trump look like a moderate centrist.
The elite/lower classes nexus
In an interview on French public radio on November 22nd, Zemmour spent time mocking and denouncing Marine Le Pen as a sell-out.
While that was predictable enough, he also proclaimed “I am a member of the elite. Only an alliance of the patriotic elite and the lower classes can save France.”
A revisionist and extremist
Only he, a 63-year-old journalist, with a penchant for eccentric historical comparisons could stop French civilization “being replaced by another civilization.”
Some months ago, Zemmour has praised Marshall Pétain, the war-time collaborationist leader of France, who cooperated with the Nazis to send many thousands of French Jews to extermination camps.
He said it was a national tragedy that the Allies lost WWI. As he wrote in a book, it would have been better if a “Pax Germanica” (a German peace) had been established in Europe after 1918.
The anti-Anglo spirit
That would have stopped, Zemmour argues, the dominance of the United States of America and Britain.
It is not unusual in France to complain about “les Anglo-Saxons” but no one running for high office has said it would have better if the Kaiser and Prussian Junkers had won World War 1 or singled out the anti-Jewish collaborator Pétain for praise.
A misogynist and macho as well
Zemmour told listeners to the major French radio news station FranceInfo that the “feminization” of judges was bad for France.
Moreover, the arrest of Dominique Strauss Kahn for sexual crimes in New York in 2012 represented “the castration” of France. “French presidents like Mitterrand or Chirac who seduced women magnified their power.”
It is true that Mitterrand and Chirac put Bill Clinton and even Boris Johnson to shame with the number of women they used their power and prestige to sleep with.
But can this be considered serious language from a man who wants to run France?
The re-industrialization of France
Zemmour calls for re-industrialization of France. To that end, he argues that all foreigners working and living in France should lose rights to social transfer payments. These should be reserved only for French citizens.
According to official statistics, about 10% of the French population are immigrants or foreign-born.
It is not clear how denying them rights to hospital care, family benefits (if they have children), or unemployment pay (if they lose jobs and paid into social security funds) will help realize his supposed goal – which is to have the manufacturing jobs that have gone to China returning to France.
Anti-vaxxer to boot
Unsurprisingly, Zemmour is against vaccinations. He says they are not very effective against polio and flu. He adds: “If I am president, I will get rid of Covid pass.”
That document is currently obligatory and must be shown in France to enter cafés, public transport, cinemas or football matches.
Booster jabs should only be for people over 65. Zemmour says the pandemic has allowed President Macron “to change the agenda from immigration.”
The immigration obsession
Fighting immigration remains his Number One obsession.
He is an advocate of the “Great Replacement” theory, according to which the white Christian race is being replaced by non-white non-Christian people. Zemmour himself is Jewish.
Putin’s boy
He has been endorsed by Vladimir Putin as Zemmour is clear he will have nothing to do with the European Union.
Weakening the EU after Brexit is Putin’s Number One foreign policy objective.
For now, Zemmour has got more publicity for his new book and for his views than any other candidate.
Watch the video
Zemmour’s campaign launch video is worth finding and watching. Even without knowing the French language, the visual images of today’s France are clear enough in their nastz messaging.
In his own perverted way, Zemmour essentially celebrates a France full of shantytowns, street drug dealers, riots and cars burned, police being attacked. His rendition of “Muslims taking” over is like something out of a 1930s Goebbels Nazi promotion film against Jews.
To many, it will appear deranged. But it is the same style of designer-crafted fake news hate aimed for social media viewing voters who never read a paper that won Brexit and put Trump in the White House.
Conclusion
Even Zemmour fails to get to the second round, he is now established as the go-to commentator for the anti-Macron populist, racists and vax-deniers. They see him as their champion.
France, the nation of Descartes and Pasteur, of reason and science, has fallen prey to a man who babbles endless noxious nonsense.
But, in the world of Donald Trump, Boris Johnson and Joao Bolsonaro, should we be surprised?
Look how it has pulled Les Republicains rightwards, with Ciotti topping the poll & how Barnier (who always struck me as a decent, sensible, intelligent man) has sounded Farage-like. Until we work with the UN to try to stop wars rather than providing the arms, return to our previous overseas aid funding and genuinely tackle climate change, the pressures are only going to grow and the outcomes potentially horrendous.
BPO - Indirect Procurement Services
2 年This is someone who wishes to defend the white Christian race from being replaced by non-white non-Christian people. The irony is certainly not lost that Eric Zemmour is not only Jewish but Algerian (ok, Pieds Noirs) to boot (sorry about the pun). Unlike Le Pen, he is not only a polemicist but a lot smarter intellectually, which makes him more Goebbels than Trump or Bolsonaro. If he gets through to the second round, Macron will have a harder time in 2022 than he had against Le Pen in 2017 but he should still be able to renew his tenancy for another 5 years on the Elysée. It's a great pity that DSK's personal foibles robbed France of not only of its first Jewish president but one who could have made a difference unlike the hapless Fran?ois Hollande in 2012.