Is your Chair doing well enough? Most dont.

Introduction

Is your Chair doing their job well enough? Most dont. Let me explain.

The role of the Chair in corporate governance is pivotal. As the leader of the board, the Chair is responsible for ensuring that the board functions effectively, makes sound decisions, and supports the organization in achieving its strategic objectives. The Chair sets the tone for boardroom dynamics, fosters a culture of accountability, and ensures that the board remains focused on its governance role, rather than delving too deeply into operational matters.

In this article, we will explore the Chair’s responsibilities in leading the board to success, the challenges that Chairs often face, and practical strategies for fulfilling this critical role with excellence.

The Strategic Importance of the Chair’s Role

The Chair's role is multifaceted, encompassing leadership, facilitation, and oversight. A successful Chair must strike a balance between guiding the board's discussions and allowing for diverse viewpoints to emerge. According to the UK Corporate Governance Code, the Chair is responsible for promoting high standards of governance and ensuring that the board operates effectively, both as a team and in its interactions with management (Ref. 1).

A well-led board, under the guidance of an effective Chair, can significantly enhance the company’s performance by providing strategic oversight, ensuring accountability, and fostering a culture of continuous improvement. McKinsey & Company highlights that boards led by strong Chairs are more likely to focus on strategic issues, challenge assumptions, and support the CEO in achieving the company’s goals (Ref. 2).

Key Responsibilities of the Chair

1. Setting the Agenda: One of the Chair’s primary responsibilities is to set the board’s agenda, ensuring that it is focused on the company’s long-term strategic objectives. The agenda should prioritize strategic discussions over routine matters, allowing the board to concentrate on issues that will drive the company’s success (Ref. 3).
2. Facilitating Effective Discussions: The Chair must facilitate board discussions in a way that encourages open, honest dialogue while ensuring that debates remain focused and productive. This involves managing conflicts, ensuring that all voices are heard, and guiding the board towards consensus (Ref. 4).
3. Ensuring Accountability: The Chair plays a key role in holding both the board and the executive management accountable. This includes ensuring that board members fulfill their responsibilities, that evaluations are conducted regularly, and that the CEO and other executives are held accountable for their performance (Ref. 5).
4. Building and Maintaining Board Dynamics: The Chair is responsible for fostering a positive board culture, where members feel valued, respected, and able to contribute effectively. This involves addressing any issues that arise within the board, such as conflicts or lack of engagement, and ensuring that the board operates as a cohesive team (Ref. 6).
5. Supporting the CEO: While the board provides oversight, the Chair must also support the CEO in their role, acting as a sounding board and providing guidance when necessary. This partnership is crucial for ensuring that the company’s strategic goals are met while maintaining a clear separation between governance and management (Ref. 7).

Challenges Chairs Face

Despite the critical nature of the Chair’s role, it is not without challenges. Some of the common issues Chairs face include:

1. Balancing Leadership and Facilitation: Striking the right balance between leading the board and facilitating discussions can be challenging. Chairs must guide the board without dominating discussions or stifling diverse viewpoints (Ref. 8).
2. Managing Board Dynamics: Keeping the board cohesive and focused, especially when dealing with strong personalities or conflicting opinions, requires skillful management. The Chair must ensure that disagreements are resolved constructively and that the board remains united in its strategic objectives (Ref. 9).
3. Maintaining Independence: The Chair must maintain independence, particularly when dealing with the CEO and other executives. This requires a careful balance of support and oversight, ensuring that the Chair can provide objective guidance while also holding management accountable (Ref. 10).

Strategies for Leading the Board to Success

To effectively lead the board, Chairs should consider the following strategies:

1. Develop a Clear Vision for the Board: The Chair should articulate a clear vision for the board’s role in supporting the company’s strategic objectives. This vision should guide the board’s activities and ensure that all members are aligned with the company’s goals (Ref. 11).
2. Enhance Board Engagement: Encourage active participation from all board members by creating an inclusive environment where diverse perspectives are valued. Regularly engage with board members outside of formal meetings to build relationships and enhance trust (Ref. 12).
3. Provide Continuous Development Opportunities: Ensure that board members have access to continuous development opportunities, such as training sessions, seminars, and industry conferences. This helps keep the board informed and equipped to deal with emerging challenges (Ref. 13).
4. Establish Clear Lines of Communication: Maintain open and transparent communication channels between the board and management. Regular updates from the CEO and other executives, combined with clear communication from the Chair, ensure that the board is well-informed and able to provide effective oversight (Ref. 14).
5. Regularly Review Board Performance: Conduct regular evaluations of the board’s performance to identify areas for improvement. Use these evaluations to make necessary adjustments to the board’s composition, dynamics, and focus (Ref. 15).

Conclusion

The Chair’s responsibility in leading the board to success is critical to the overall effectiveness of corporate governance. By setting a clear agenda, facilitating effective discussions, and maintaining a positive board culture, the Chair can ensure that the board remains focused on its strategic objectives and provides robust oversight.

If you are looking for a new Chair or NED, and/or guidance on enhancing your extant board’s effectiveness or need support in fulfilling your role as Chair, I am available.

Sources and References

1. UK Corporate Governance Code 2018 - Financial Reporting Council, https://www.frc.org.uk/library/standards-codes-policy/corporate-governance/uk-corporate-governance-code
2. McKinsey & Company - "The Role of the Chair in Corporate Governance", https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/organization/our-insights/the-role-of-the-chair-in-corporate-governance
3. EY Board Matters - "Setting the Board Agenda", https://www.ey.com/en_us/board-matters/setting-the-board-agenda
4. FT Board Directors Programme - "Facilitating Effective Board Discussions", https://professional.ft.com/en-gb/blog/facilitating-effective-board-discussions/
5. Corporate Governance Institute - "Ensuring Accountability in the Boardroom", https://www.thecorporategovernanceinstitute.com/courses-diploma/ensuring-accountability-in-the-boardroom/
6. Harvard Business Review - "Building and Maintaining Board Dynamics", https://hbr.org/2023/11/building-and-maintaining-board-dynamics
7. NED on Board - "Supporting the CEO: The Chair’s Role", https://www.nedonboard.com/supporting-the-ceo-the-chairs-role/
8. Kaufman Rossin - "Balancing Leadership and Facilitation", https://kaufmanrossin.com/news/balancing-leadership-and-facilitation-in-the-boardroom/
9. Halex Consulting - "Managing Board Dynamics Effectively", https://halex.uk.com/managing-board-dynamics-effectively/
10. Corporate Governance Institute - "Maintaining Independence as Chair", https://www.thecorporategovernanceinstitute.com/courses-diploma/maintaining-independence-as-chair/
11. McKinsey & Company - "Developing a Vision for the Board", https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/organization/our-insights/developing-a-vision-for-the-board
12. NED on Board - "Enhancing Board Engagement", https://www.nedonboard.com/enhancing-board-engagement/
13. FT Board Directors Programme - "Continuous Development for Board Members", https://professional.ft.com/en-gb/blog/continuous-development-for-board-members/
14. EY Board Matters - "Establishing Clear Lines of Communication", https://www.ey.com/en_us/board-matters/establishing-clear-lines-of-communication
15. Harvard Business Review - "Reviewing Board Performance Regularly", https://hbr.org/2023/11/reviewing-board-performance-regularly

Relevant Hashtags

• #CorporateGovernance
• #BoardLeadership
• #ChairmanRole
• #BoardEffectiveness
• #Leadership
• #ChairmanLeadership
• #CEOLeadership
• #StrategicGovernance