YOU+AI : Part XXI: Traditional VS AI Based Management

A significant transformation is underway in software project/program management. This shift primarily due to AI ,is bringing about higher levels of efficiency, accuracy, and innovation, fundamentally changing how projects are planned, executed, and monitored.

In this article, I’ll? explore the impact of AI on IT project management, using simple language, real-life examples, practical tools to measure success, and a comparison between traditional project management and AI-based project management.

?

Traditional project management relies on manual analysis and subjective judgment.

Templates and frameworks such as SWOT analysis (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) or PESTLE analysis (Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Legal, Environmental) are commonly used to assess project risks qualitatively

AI has become a powerful tool for automating tasks and optimizing resource use. Instead of relying solely on manual planning and coordination, project managers now have access to AI tools that offer data-driven insights, predictive analytics, and automated workflows. These tools help them make better decisions throughout the project lifecycle.?

Traditional vs AI-Based Project Management: Key Areas Comparison

Following are the 4 major areas of project management that can leverage the power of AI to achieve more productivity and quality

Risk Management:

Resource Allocation

Scheduling

Decision-making

?

Comparison of Risk Management in Traditional vs AI-Based Project Management

Traditional Project Management:

In traditional project management, project managers primarily rely on their experience, intuition, and manual analysis to identify and mitigate risks. They may use spreadsheets, risk registers, and qualitative assessments to manage risks, but the process is often subjective and time-consuming. Some common tools used in traditional project risk management include:

Excel Spreadsheets: Project managers often use Excel spreadsheets to create risk registers and track identified risks. However, these spreadsheets can be limited in their ability to analyze complex data and predict future risks.

Risk Assessment Templates: Templates and frameworks such as SWOT analysis (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) or PESTLE analysis (Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Legal, Environmental) are commonly used to assess project risks qualitatively. While these tools provide a structured approach to risk assessment, they may not capture all potential risks or their likelihood of occurrence accurately.

?AI-Based Project Management:

In AI-based project management, project managers leverage AI-powered predictive analytics tools to analyze historical project data and forecast potential risks. These tools use advanced algorithms and machine learning techniques to identify patterns, trends, and correlations in project data, enabling proactive risk management. Some examples of AI-powered predictive analytics tools for project risk management include:

IBM Watson Analytics: Watson Analytics offers AI-powered predictive analytics capabilities that can analyze large datasets from various sources to identify patterns and trends. It can be used to forecast project risks based on historical data and provide recommendations for risk mitigation strategies.

Microsoft Azure Machine Learning: Azure Machine Learning is a cloud-based platform that enables project managers to build, train, and deploy machine learning models. It can be used to develop predictive models for project risk management, leveraging historical project data to predict future risks and optimize risk mitigation efforts.

Risk Management Software: There are various AI-based risk management software solutions available in the market, such as RiskIQ, RiskSense, and RiskWatch, which leverage machine learning algorithms to analyze project data and identify potential risks. These tools offer advanced risk scoring, risk prioritization, and automated risk mitigation recommendations.

?Natural Language Processing (NLP) Tools: NLP tools, such as Google Cloud Natural Language API or Amazon Comprehend, can analyze unstructured data from project documents, emails, and communication channels to extract insights and identify potential risks. These tools can help project managers gain a deeper understanding of project risks and take proactive measures to address them.

?

Comparison of Resource Allocation in Traditional vs AI-Based Project Management:

Traditional Project Management:

In traditional project management, resource allocation is typically done manually based on estimates, project timelines, and the judgment of project managers. This process often involves spreadsheets, resource calendars, and communication with team members to assign tasks and allocate resources. However, manual resource allocation can be time-consuming, prone to errors, and may not optimize resource utilization efficiently. Some common tools used in traditional resource allocation include:

Resource Calendars: Project managers use resource calendars to track the availability of team members and allocate tasks accordingly. However, managing resource calendars manually can be challenging, especially in large projects with multiple resources and dependencies.

?Excel Spreadsheets: Spreadsheets are commonly used to create resource allocation plans, where project managers list tasks, assign resources, and track resource utilization. While spreadsheets offer flexibility and customization, they lack the ability to optimize resource allocation dynamically based on real-time data.

?AI-Based Project Management:

In AI-based project management, AI algorithms are used to optimize resource allocation based on real-time data, task dependencies, and project priorities. These algorithms analyze project data, identify resource requirements, and allocate resources dynamically to maximize efficiency and productivity. Some examples of AI-based resource allocation tools and techniques include:

Project Management Software with AI Capabilities: Modern project management software, such as Wrike, Monday.com and Asana, leverage AI algorithms to optimize resource allocation. These platforms analyze project data, identify resource dependencies, and recommend optimal resource allocation strategies to project managers.

Resource Management Modules: Some project management software solutions offer dedicated resource management modules that use AI algorithms to optimize resource allocation. For example, LiquidPlanner's resource management module uses predictive analytics to forecast resource demand, identify potential resource conflicts, and recommend resource allocation adjustments to project managers.

Workforce Management Software: Workforce management software solutions, such as Workday and SAP SuccessFactors, use AI algorithms to optimize resource allocation across projects and departments. These platforms analyze employee skills, availability, and project requirements to ensure efficient resource utilization and allocation.

Comparison of Scheduling in Traditional vs AI-Based Project Management:

Traditional Project Management:

In traditional project management, project schedules are typically static and may require frequent manual adjustments as project requirements change or unforeseen events occur. Project managers often create schedules using tools like Microsoft Project or Excel, outlining tasks, durations, and dependencies. However, maintaining and updating these schedules manually can be time-consuming and may lead to inefficiencies. Some common tools used in traditional scheduling include:

Microsoft Project: Microsoft Project is a widely used project management software that allows project managers to create and manage project schedules. While it offers robust scheduling features, schedules created in Microsoft Project are often static and may require manual adjustments to accommodate changes in resource availability or project priorities.

?Excel Spreadsheets: Excel spreadsheets are often used to create project schedules, especially in smaller projects or organizations with limited resources. However, scheduling in Excel can be cumbersome and error-prone, as it lacks the automation and optimization capabilities of dedicated project management software.

AI-Based Project Management:

In AI-based project management, AI-enabled scheduling tools use advanced algorithms to dynamically adjust project timelines based on real-time data, resource availability, and project priorities. These tools analyze project data, identify dependencies, and optimize schedules to facilitate timely project delivery. Some examples of AI-based scheduling tools and techniques include:

LiquidPlanner: LiquidPlanner is a project management software that uses AI algorithms to dynamically adjust project schedules based on resource availability and project priorities. It automatically updates schedules as new tasks are added, completed, or delayed, ensuring that project timelines remain accurate and up-to-date.

?Asana: Asana is a popular project management tool that offers AI-powered scheduling features. It uses machine learning algorithms to predict project timelines, identify potential bottlenecks, and recommend scheduling adjustments to optimize project delivery.

Dynamic Gantt Charts: AI-enabled project management platforms may offer dynamic Gantt charts that automatically adjust project timelines based on real-time data and project changes. These charts provide project managers with a visual representation of project schedules, allowing them to quickly identify and address scheduling issues.

Comparison of Decision-Making in Traditional vs AI-Based Project Management

Traditional Project Management:

In traditional project management, project managers make decisions based on their experience, intuition, and subjective judgment. They rely on limited data sources and qualitative assessments to evaluate project progress, identify issues, and make decisions. While this approach may work in some cases, it can lead to suboptimal outcomes and missed opportunities for improvement. Some common tools and techniques used in traditional decision-making include:

Expert Judgment: Project managers rely on their expertise and experience to make decisions about project planning, resource allocation, and risk management. While expert judgment can be valuable, it is inherently subjective and may not always lead to the best outcomes.

?Stakeholder Input: Project managers gather input from stakeholders, team members, and other project participants to inform decision-making. While stakeholder input is important for ensuring buy-in and alignment, it may be influenced by personal biases and preferences.

AI-Based Project Management:

In AI-based project management, AI provides data-driven insights and recommendations that enable project managers to make informed decisions and optimize project outcomes. AI algorithms analyze large volumes of project data, identify patterns, and generate actionable insights that can inform decision-making. Some examples of AI-based decision-making tools and techniques include:

?Predictive Analytics: AI-powered predictive analytics tools, such as IBM Watson Analytics and Microsoft Azure Machine Learning, analyze historical project data to identify trends, forecast future outcomes, and recommend actions to optimize project performance. These tools can help project managers anticipate risks, identify opportunities, and make proactive decisions to improve project outcomes.

Decision Support Systems: AI-powered decision support systems, such as Adaptive Insights and SAP Analytics Cloud, provide project managers with interactive dashboards, reports, and visualizations that help them analyse project data, identify trends, and make data-driven decisions. These systems can help project managers quickly identify areas of concern, prioritize actions, and optimize project performance.

?In summary, while traditional project management relies on subjective judgment and limited data sources for risk management, resource allocation, scheduling and ?decision-making, AI-based project management leverages advanced algorithms and data analytics to provide project managers with data-driven insights and recommendations. By embracing AI-powered tools and techniques, project managers can improve decision-making accuracy, optimize project outcomes, and drive continuous improvement in project performance.

?

?