You want Simon not Paula...
Who's making your talent acquisition assessments?

You want Simon not Paula...

What is a talent acquisition professional's job?

Talent acquisition specialists (aka Recruiters, Headhunters etc.) are the art critics, wine critics, sports scouts and movie critics of the business world. Their job is to be able to distinguish good from great in order for their clients to make the best decisions possible. Those decisions make or break a company because your people will always dictate your success or your failure. Their value to their clients is in having a critical eye. Too often in my past life as a VP of Sales & Marketing I was presented with "perfect" candidates who, in reality, were way off the mark.

There were typically 3 reasons:

  1. The recruiter was blinded by the fee and ignored red flags that were obvious in hopes of just getting paid. I chalk this up to being short sighted and stupid and not understanding the value of always thinking long term.
  2. The recruiter had not developed a critical eye. They focused on the good and didn't see the reasons why the candidate wasn't a fit. I chalk this up to inexperience and poor coaching.
  3. The recruiter didn't do their homework. They didn't interview them in depth, didn't google them, check their social media, talk to references etc. Vetting is not "pitching" a company and a job opening, vetting is diving deep and interviewing a candidate harder sometimes then a client might. I chalk this up to the most common issue that plagues so many people, they are sloppy, lazy and take shortcuts. I could try to sanitize it but that's really what it is.

Eli Manning is not an elite quarterback and that's ok...

Here in New York, it's a common debate on sports talk radio whether or not Eli Manning is an elite quarterback. Some people lose their minds when others say he isn't elite. Not everyone can be "elite". By definition elite means that you are in a very small exclusive group. It's not an insult to say someone isn't elite it just means you know the difference between good, very good and great. In an era of 8th place trophies people can lose sight that evaluating, judging and stack ranking people is ok. In recruiting, thinking everyone is "great" is a disservice to the client and a waste of their time and money.

As a hiring manager you want your talent acquisition partner to be way more Simon Cowell than Paula Abdul.

SomethingNew is the 2017 and 2016 American Business Award winner for "innovation" and finds top talent for some of the best organizations throughout North America. If we can ever be a resource to you please feel free to give me a shout @ 888-223-9420 or [email protected]


Joanne Berkow Schwartz

Enterprise Account Director

7 年

Very true! Well said Scott MacGregor!

Phillip Boeding

Finance Professional

7 年

Great analogy Scott MacGregor. Participation trophies don't work in business.

Brandon Gracey

Head of Global Accounts Shopify

7 年

Completely agree - particularly on Eli :)

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Scott MacGregor的更多文章

  • National "TrySomethingNew Week"

    National "TrySomethingNew Week"

    July 9-15 is National TrySomethingNew Week! So who proclaimed this week as a national holiday? We did. Yes, it's true…

    11 条评论
  • SomethingNew Adds CAPT Todd Seniff to Advisory Board

    SomethingNew Adds CAPT Todd Seniff to Advisory Board

    SomethingNew is extremely pleased to announce that Captain Todd Seniff has joined SomethingNew's Advisory Board. The…

    4 条评论
  • Our why...

    Our why...

    Simon Sinek in his book Start with Why begins with a very basic question: Why are some people and organizations more…

    8 条评论
  • SOMETHINGNEW NAMED AS FINALIST FOR INNOVATION (Again) IN 2017 STEVIE? AWARDS!

    SOMETHINGNEW NAMED AS FINALIST FOR INNOVATION (Again) IN 2017 STEVIE? AWARDS!

    11th annual awards will be presented on February 24 in Las Vegas New York, NY – January 20, 2017 – SomethingNew LLC was…

    44 条评论
  • Coolest incentive ever...

    Coolest incentive ever...

    If you could travel anywhere you wanted to in the world where would you go? At SomethingNew we love to have fun and we…

    9 条评论
  • The Importance of Next Man Up in Sports & Business

    The Importance of Next Man Up in Sports & Business

    As a life long Minnesota Vikings fan every fall I vacillate between convincing myself my Vikes will finally win a Super…

    19 条评论
  • 3 Simple Steps To Network Your Way To Success

    3 Simple Steps To Network Your Way To Success

    Networking has a bad rap because done the wrong way it's stressful, tedious and doesn't produce great results. Going…

    12 条评论
  • A Quick Story About Integrity

    A Quick Story About Integrity

    As many people may know SomethingNew was created in response to over a decade of less than stellar experiences that I…

    15 条评论
  • Why we started SomethingNew

    Why we started SomethingNew

    20 years of being a hiring manager, 17 as a VP of Sales & Marketing, left me with a pretty good sample of the…

    3 条评论
  • Three Business Lessons I Learned From My Dad

    Three Business Lessons I Learned From My Dad

    My dad owned his own business, a gas station, when I was growing up long before I had ever heard the word entrepreneur.…

    17 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了