You Don’t Want to Hear What Psalm 23 Really Says

Psalm 23 is the psalm of comfort. It’s the passage whispered in hospital rooms, read at gravesides, and clung to in the darkest nights of the soul.

We love the image of a gentle Shepherd leading us to still waters, the peace of lying down in green pastures, the assurance of walking through the valley without fear.

But there’s a part of this psalm we have failed to see.

We think of God as leading us, but the Hebrew word used in verse three does not mean ‘lead’ at all. It means something far more forceful. It means to drive.

The Shepherd Who Drives His Sheep

“The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not want. He makes me lie down in green pastures. He leads me beside still waters. He restores my soul.” – He drives me in paths of righteousness for his name’s sake.(Psalm 23:1-3).

Western shepherds drive their sheep. Eastern shepherds lead them. But here, in this Psalm, the image is jarring—our Shepherd, who gently leads, also pushes, prods, and forces us onto certain paths.

These are paths we do not want to walk.

Paths we would never choose. And yet, they are the only paths that will make us holy. They are the right paths, and they are chosen for one reason: God’s glory is at stake.

When God Pushes Us Where We Don’t Want to Go

We resist. We pray for a different road, an easier way. We want the green pastures, but we do not want the steep climbs.

Yet, sometimes, God does not answer those prayers the way we expect. Instead of gentleness, He uses force.

David understood this. His life was a testament to disruption. He had been driven into caves, into exile, into war, into grief. He knew what it was to be propelled into circumstances beyond his control. And yet, he saw the invisible hand of the Shepherd in it all.

God does not always display His love with gentleness. Sometimes, love looks like a hard shove.

We have tamed Psalm 23. We have domesticated it into a feel-good passage when, in reality, it speaks of a God who will drive us into holiness—even if we go kicking and screaming.

The Valley That’s Worse Than Death

“Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil, for you are with me; your rod and your staff, they comfort me,” (Psalm 23:4).

We hear this verse at funerals, and rightly so. But David wasn’t just talking about dying. There are things in life worse than death.

Betrayal. Suffering. Prolonged grief. The slow unraveling of everything we thought was secure. These are the valleys where we question if God is even still with us.

The valley is dark. It is suffocating. And it is terrifying. But David does not say, “I will run through it.” He does not say, “I will find a way around it.” He walks through it. Step by step. Day by day.

Why? Because the Shepherd is still there.

A Club, Not a Crook

“Your rod and your staff, they comfort me.”

We have misunderstood this verse. We picture a shepherd’s crook—a gentle tool to guide and rescue. But that’s not what David is talking about.

The “rod” was a club. A weapon. A heavy, brutal instrument of war. And God has one—not for you, but for your enemies.

God is not passive in your suffering. He does not sit back while the wolves circle. He stands ready to strike. He will defend you with force. He will fight for you.

And what about the staff? It’s not a crook—it’s a walking stick. Something to lean on when you are too weak to stand. When your strength fails, when your legs tremble, when your heart is too weary to take another step—He holds you up.

This is the care of the Shepherd. Not just guiding, but defending. Not just leading, but sustaining.

The Feast in Enemy Territory

“You prepare a table before me in the presence of my enemies; you anoint my head with oil; my cup overflows.” (Psalm 23:5)

Picture it. The battle rages outside, the enemy stands at the door, and yet God invites you to sit and eat.

This is not survival. This is victory.

God does not merely keep you alive. He does not merely get you through. He blesses you in the middle of the fight. He anoints your head with oil—marking you as welcome, as honored, as beloved. He fills your cup to overflowing—not just enough to get by, but abundance.

And the enemy? They are forced to watch. Powerless. Defeated.

The presence of Christ is your victory.

What Follows You Home

“Surely goodness and mercy shall follow me all the days of my life, and I shall dwell in the house of the Lord forever.” (Psalm 23:6)

Goodness and mercy do not lead you; they follow. They chase you. They hunt you down.

Even when you run, even when you doubt, even when you fight the path He is driving you down—His goodness does not let you go.

And when the road finally ends, when all the valleys have been walked, when all the battles have been fought, when all the suffering has been endured—you will not be left wandering.

You will go home.

The Uncomfortable, Unshakable Truth

Psalm 23 is not a soft psalm. It is not a lullaby for the weak. It is a battle cry. It is the anthem of those who have been driven into the fire and have found that the Shepherd was with them all along.

You may not like the path. You may not understand the valley. You may fight against the road you have been forced to walk.

But the Shepherd knows where He is taking you. And it will be worth it.

So walk. Keep going.

Even when He drives you.

Even when the valley is dark.

Even when the table is surrounded by enemies.

You are not alone. You are not forgotten. And in the end, you will dwell in the house of the Lord forever.

Recommended Resource:?If you’re studying the Psalms, you won’t want to miss my in-depth review of?The Treasury of David?by Charles Spurgeon. This timeless masterpiece unpacks the Psalms with rich theological insight, making it essential for devotion, sermon prep, or deep Bible study. Read the full review?here.

Enjoying this content??If you’d like to support my work and help me create more Bible-centered resources, consider buying me a coffee! Your support means the world and helps keep this ministry going.

https://buymeacoffee.com/pastorrich