It would be irresponsible for the RBA to  ‘Let Inflation Run’

It would be irresponsible for the RBA to ‘Let Inflation Run’

I’ve seen an increasing number of articles and commentary in recent days arguing that the RBA needs to slow down with interest rate rises or risk ‘making a huge mistake’ and triggering a recession. The argument generally goes, “our current inflation woes are all caused by international supply problems and rate rises won’t do anything to help, so the RBA should just stop raising rates”.?

This whole idea is both wrong and irresponsible for a whole range of reasons, let’s go through the big ones.?

First, our current inflation is not only supply-driven, supply issues certainly kicked it off, but we now are definitely seeing significant demand-driven inflation (for example underlying inflation in the June quarter was 4.9%). Wage growth is also heating up, and I expect that with real wages falling rapidly and unemployment very low, employees will be seeking to play catch up over the next year, pushing wages higher. We are also nowhere near peak inflation, with Treasury predicting peak inflation won’t arrive until the end of this year somewhere north of 7.75%.

Second, inflation has a devastating impact on individuals and the fabric of society. It erodes people's savings and wages and eats away at people’s quality of life, and the longer inflation goes on, the worse these impacts are. Inflation also has a tendency to become entrenched. People and businesses start expecting prices to rise and pre-empt those increases by increasing prices or pursuing higher wages. While the impact from a potential recession is not great, they are usually short and have minimal long-term impact on an economy. On the flip side, entrenched inflation is much more damaging to an economy, and can require devastating long-term adjustments to tame. Just look at the devastation of the 1970s or the disaster currently unfolding in Turkey. A short recession if the RBA overshoots on rate rises a bad, but it's a much better outcome than letting inflation become entrenched.

Third, the cost of raining in inflation gets higher the longer and more entrenched inflation gets. The rate rises and demand destruction required to reduce inflation from 6% are exponentially less than if inflation is at say 10%. By pushing up rates and taking aggressive steps now, the RBA is taking the low-risk approach. If they pause and wait, and inflation runs away again, it will require a considerably higher peak interest rate and higher rates for longer to bring inflation back down.?

Finally, there are some important, but less central reasons that the RBA should be raising rates:

  • First, the RBA needs to start de-risking the economy. Low rates and initiatives like Quantitative Easing and the Term Funding Facility flood the lending market with almost free money. This pushes down yields on less risky investments (like bonds) and forces lenders out along the yield curve to find returns. Lenders are forces to write more risky loans in pursuit of yield. As a result, some of this lending will be terrible and the RBA needs to gradually weed that bad lending out of the system, reducing systematic risk across the whole economy.?
  • Second, the RBA need to get rates back to a reasonable level, so they have some ammunition the next time they have to stimulate the economy. A neutral level for interest rates in Australia, if inflation is within the RBA’s target band, is likely to be around 2.5% to 3.0% (a real rate that is very slightly positive). We need rates to get back up to this range so that we both have non-stimulative rates at target inflation and the RBA has the captaincy to cut rates in the next crisis.?
  • Third, the RBA needs to continue to increase rates to protect the dollar. With other major economies, and in particular the USA, increasing rates, the AUD will fall under further pressure if the RBA does not keep up. The AUD has been supported over the last 12 months by demand from China for our resource exports and near record high resource prices. However, the Chinese economy is slowing down and so the AUS will need more support from the RBA. Letting the AUD fall is not an option, that will lead to even more imported inflation and just make our current problems worse.

Richard Fullarton

Commodity Derivatives Fund Manager

2 年

Green imitative led inflation has just started in Australia. Interest rates do not stop this, they just stop other consumption in an attempt to reduce headline inflation

回复
Gilbert Boffa

EndoBloodTest.au launching soon for Women to help spread the word for 1 in 9 with a debilitating illness treated years ahead of current methods of diagnosis. Ask your doctors. Seeking sponsors to spread the word.

2 年

Read this Peter C. Fennell to better understand why higher unemployment is what many economists in the #PrivateSector are urging without actually saying it. The Private Sector gets smashed every time.

回复

While I don’t disagree with some of the points, realistically the RBA is raising rates apparently because the USA is. The rate of increase is concerning as there is no attempt to gauge whether previous rises are having any affect on slowing the economy. It’s also interesting that Philip Lowe says households can afford the increases - what is the basis for this assumption? Especially as the people making these decisions are earning substantial sums as compared to the general public. Seems to be an attitude of as it doesn’t affect us, everyone else can afford the increases. Let’s see how many businesses go to the wall, how many people go bankrupt or lose their houses and how quickly inflation abates. Logically it won’t abate until the affects of the Ukrainian conflict disappear and commodity prices revert to more normal levels.

Neale Muston

Former Managing Director Merrill Lynch Asia (2006-2008) Former Managing Director Morgan Stanley Co (1995-2006)

2 年

That's a very good read Brendan. You are absolutely right about the heinous effects of inflation on households and real incomes. Note that many commentators think we are approaching recession and as such the RBA should back off and not risk overshoot. This logic is ludicrous. At just 1.85%, the game has barely started and neutral is still several hikes away. The latecomers to the free money sandpit in 2021 cannot dictate policy for the entire economy, notwithstanding Lowe's 2024 "promise" that should see this term be his final. Small property market retracement in Sydney and Melbourne is catching the headlines after a Covid-led gain of 50%. Indeed, several major cities are still recording gains. There is little risk to the property market with full employment and a weak AUD that is again attracting foreign interest. Australia's employment strength, supreme trade balance and well-buffered consumer all offer the RBA the opportunity to correct its mistakes by the start of 2023 and place us in a world-leading position of managed inflation and underlying growth. Those gibbering on about recessions in Australia are simply talking book.

Brendan Giles

Here to help businesses and individuals facing financial difficulty ??Insolvency ??Business Restructuring ??Bankruptcy ??Business Advice

2 年

What fortuitous timing! The Daily Telegraphs cover story today is exactly the kind of misguided opinion I was thinking of when I drafted this.

  • 该图片无替代文字
回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Brendan Giles的更多文章

  • Key SME Challenges in 2024

    Key SME Challenges in 2024

    2024 is likely to be a more difficult year for SME's than 2023, with a number of challenges evolving from last year…

    4 条评论
  • Where is the Insolvency Market Going in 2023?

    Where is the Insolvency Market Going in 2023?

    2023 is promising to be a volatile and interesting year, with a lot of uncertainty, especially as we look forward to…

    3 条评论
  • My Best Books of 2022

    My Best Books of 2022

    With 2022 over, its a good time to look back at the seven best books I read in 2022. I love reading, it's one of my…

    5 条评论
  • Insolvency Appointments Remain Low

    Insolvency Appointments Remain Low

    However, we’re headed for recession and more insolvency appointments. Another quarter has flown by and it’s time to…

  • Rates Will Need to Go Higher to Tame Inflation

    Rates Will Need to Go Higher to Tame Inflation

    The RBA will all but certainly be raising interest rates again this afternoon (by 50 basis points to 2.35%) and there…

    15 条评论
  • Director Penalty Notices Explained

    Director Penalty Notices Explained

    With the ATO issuing an ever-increasing number of Director Penalty Notices (“DPN”) as they ramp up their post-COIVID…

  • A Quick Update on the Economy

    A Quick Update on the Economy

    There's been a bunch of interesting economic information out over the the last few days that gives us an interesting…

    10 条评论
  • The Saga of Elon Musk and Twitter

    The Saga of Elon Musk and Twitter

    As has been widely reported, Elon has unilaterally terminated his agreement to buy Twitter. Almost since the minute…

    2 条评论
  • Court Vests Disclaimed Property in Trustee

    Court Vests Disclaimed Property in Trustee

    It’s not often you get to be involved in setting a new legal precedent. Personally, in my almost 20 years working in…

    5 条评论
  • Predictions for insolvency appointments for FY2023

    Predictions for insolvency appointments for FY2023

    The last quarter has been a wild one for the Australian economy, with mounting headwinds from a range of international…

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了