Not counting iFarmer, Bangladeshi agriculture startups have raised less than US$250,000… ever. In contrast, Indian agriculture startups have raised over US$2.5 billion.
Considering the difference in the two countries' value-added agricultural output ($41 billion for Bangladesh vs. India's $480 billion) is 11.7x, the gulf in startup fundraising is absurd.
Across the 200 plus startups we actively track at Anchorless Bangladesh, agriculture has arguably the single most disappointing sector. Why? Because we know the talent to solve many of the industry's issues are within our borders, and we know the capital to support them is out there—yet we're not finding companies that are ready to put up a fight.
- Bangladesh has a lot of brilliant academic talent that studies in fields relevant to agriculture. However, instead of staying local and founding/working at a startup, they often opt to leave the country. Those who do want to stay aren't guided or given access to resources and mentorship that allow them to turn their agri-friendly ideas into a venture investment-friendly startup. For example, a Singaporean startup raised US$12.6 million to produce cell-based shrimp, a product that likely could be created by Bangladeshi talent were they given the right resources and capital.
- An excess of developmental capital in the agriculture space creates inefficient markets where capital isn't always held accountable. This includes grants and other methods of funding often given to "feel good" stories that do not have scalable, structural impact. This is a trend across the country, though agriculture is one of the sectors where we see it more visibly.
- Of the few agriculture startups we've seen, many have an issue where they try to do too much. This stems from a misunderstanding of how startups work, and how investors look at such companies. Instead of solving one core problem, doing it well and scaling it fast so that the company can raise another round to take on the next step of the solution, they try to do all at once and most of it not well. This is another issue across all industries in Bangladesh, and especially rings true in agriculture: Focus on one product-based solution that scales before trying to solve for everything.
- A common excuse in agriculture bottlenecks is "lack of infrastructure"—though just like healthcare, logistics or other large-scale industries in need of widescale disruption, every problem must start with a solution in order to bring forth other solutions. If there is a bottleneck directly ahead of a proposed solution, why not solve for the bottleneck?
- Another common excuse is farmer illiteracy—but then explain how other countries (including India where there is a lower literacy rate at that level) are making it work just fine? That usually indicates that the founder hasn't built a product for their market. For the right founder, it's not a problem—it's an opportunity.
- "This solution won't fix much." Sure, but everyone has to start somewhere. If 10 different startups tackle 10 different solutions, all of them can come together and collaborate to solve even larger problems afterward. Ecosystems aren't developed overnight, and nobody changes a multi-billion dollar industry by thinking about short-term results. The beauty of startups is the ability to try, fail and pivot when presented with new information.
- The biggest problem with agriculture founders that we've met with so far, however, is that they lack a sense of urgency. As venture investors, we need to get the feeling that founders are itching to fly, that they want to take the capital and build at a global standard and pace that'll change the way we all live. As of now, we don't get that sense from local agriculture founders. For most, these solutions come across a "nice to have" or a lifestyle business they run on the side. What we need to see are founders who wake up in the morning with a mission to have structural, scalable impact in agriculture. We don't care about your awards or business competitions. We care that you have a goal in mind, and you will deploy global capital in an intelligent and aggressive manner to solve large-scale problems. We need to sense that desire from the moment we meet you.
The truth is that we don't always have to go about reinventing the wheel via metaverses, blockchain or AI to have significant, positive impact in Bangladesh. It can start small as long as the mindset to think big is always present. Agriculture is too important to Bangladesh for it to be ignored from the venture investment side—so, who's going to step up and build something venture-fundable?
Before proposing a pathway to building such startups, it’s important to acknowledge that those already working in the field are often essential to these solutions. High quality startups should, in fact, make their work more efficient and effective.
I challenge universities, foreign embassies and relevant developmental organizations to set up a nationwide incubation program to identify key agricultural issues, guide and mentor the founders and incubate their ideas so they can become venture-fundable. The overarching goal of such an incubator would be to get founders to think practically and value execution at scale over "feel good" stories or awards.
The most important result of such a program would be to prepare founders to be able to walk into any meeting with a VC, whether in Singapore or New York, and raise funding.
Why does venture funding matter? It will allow founders to test new solutions using capital that's willing to take risk. And those who show results will get funded further to innovate more aggressively, thereby positively changing the agricultural and socioeconomic landscape of Bangladesh. Solutions must be both scalable and structural.
Remember: It's not about what percentage of the pie you own—it's about doubling and tripling the size of the pie itself.
After all, there is no #UnstoppableBangladesh without agriculture.
Director of Engineering | Product Design | Lean Manufacturing | Med Devices | Consumer Packaging | BioTech | Finite Element | Intellectual Property | AI/ML in Smart Manufacturing | Contextual Robotics
3 年What are your thoughts on a platform similar to Stellapps Technologies Private Limited- but in the Bangladeshi narrative? Is that what iFarmer.asia is already doing or are there tangents still unexplored? Secondary thoughts- I was born in the campus of Bangladesh Agricultural University in Mymensingh where my dad was a professor in Farm Power and Machinery department. That where I grew up as well and saw the successful execution of some of the most seminal innovations and discoveries crucial to Bangladesh's independence in food and agri products. These include (but not limited to) the hybrid poultry/cattle breeds and also the hybrid crops that has made famine and hunger a thing of the past in the rural areas. It's not that success stories don't exist. There are just not weaved in the strict definition of an independently held "startup culture". That is where we need bolder strides from entrepreneurs to adopt both new and existing academic research and DOEs into scalable solutions en masse. I think we are missing out on a lot of existing research thinking all of that is buried under a mountain of red tape and bureaucracy somewhere in Digharkanda, Mymensingh :)
Climate Tech | Renewables | Sustainable Solutions | Decarbonizing | Founder | Advisor | Entrepreneur | Mentor
3 年A very detailed review full of constructive criticism! You nailed several weaknesses and I hope those in positions of power take those up to change things for the better! We must support farmers, agricultural projects, and startups who are uplifting the face of agriculture!
Multiple Unit Food Franchisee
3 年What an observation - much needed!
Future of Education & Skills Advocate + 4x Founder + Google WomenTechMaker Ambassador + FounderTalk Webcast Hostess on SkillVill
3 年Mariam Ispahani is a leader in the space and has exciting opportunities to check out. https://youtu.be/cYNj1t5yKxY
Managing Director at Petrochem (Bangladesh) Limited
3 年What we need is proper mindset. Traditional way of thinking puts us two step back. Plus for funding everyone looks at export. But the current market is huge. With proper planning it is possible but there are lots of obstacles that needs to be looked at. Especially the VC does not look deep in to the market they have to be open minded to invest in Agro Tech in Bangladesh. They need to have patience, which they lack and most of the time they get misguided. I run an Agro company amd the potential for improvement is great. If I say we are technological very advanced compared to all Agro companies in Bangladesh. We are working in a new technology that will help our farmers change their lives and be more efficient in their produce. Looking forward to connect to VCs to discuss further.