The world has progressed beyond the need for Russian power
Meme by Fred Wellman

The world has progressed beyond the need for Russian power

Big news seems to be coming fast and furious these days. We’re still waiting on the midterm results, and?I already wrote about the crypto crash, so today I think I’ll write about the Ukraine war. In the last few days, Ukraine has taken the key city of Kherson in the south of the country, in a battle that?started as a planned Russian withdrawal?and is turning into a catastrophic rout.

First, the basic military situation. Kherson city is the provincial capital of one of the four Ukrainian provinces that Vladimir Putin recently claimed ownership of. The city was conquered by the Russians early in the war, but it’s on the opposite side of the very wide Dnipro river from Russian supply lines, so there was always a good chance that Ukraine would take it back. For months now, Ukraine has been hammering at Russian positions around Kherson, using the famous HIMARS rocket launchers and other artillery donated by the West. Finally,?taking huge losses, the Russians decided to withdraw to the opposite bank of the river. Here’s a picture of how fast the Ukrainians are recovering territory:

No alt text provided for this image

But as happens all too often with Putin’s Russia, the withdrawal was executed chaotically and poorly, allowing the Ukrainians to?inflict tremendous casualties?on the Russian forces as they try to escape across the Dnipro.?Panicked testimonials?are now appearing on social media as Russians sit trapped under a hail of Ukrainian artillery. If you want to follow these fast-moving developments, you can?follow my Ukraine War list on Twitter.

Anyway, the war is far from over. Russia is still wreaking havoc on Ukrainian infrastructure with missile strikes, other territories might be harder to retake, and Russia can always try more nuclear threats. But at this point one conclusion seems clear — other than the nuclear arsenal it inherited from its Soviet predecessors, Putin’s Russia has?nothing that makes it worthy of being called a “superpower”, or even a “great power” at all.

The failure of Russia’s war effort is the clearest proof of how far the country has fallen since Soviet days. Russia has about 3.5 times Ukraine’s population, a far higher per capita GDP, and truly massive stores of equipment and ammo. Before the war, its military was believed to be the world’s third most powerful, and had seemingly proven its mettle by crushing Chechnya, quickly subduing Georgia, and largely pacifying Syria.

No alt text provided for this image


要查看或添加评论,请登录

Noah Smith的更多文章

  • Indiamerica

    Indiamerica

    Incredibly, Antony Blinken’s trip to Beijing was the second most important event in U.S.

  • Price controls: Too early for a victory lap

    Price controls: Too early for a victory lap

    Here’s a story we all love: For many years, a theoretical consensus has held firm among the learned scholars of…

  • Why aren't we taking every Chinese refugee we can?

    Why aren't we taking every Chinese refugee we can?

    “She's still a beacon, still a magnet for all who must have freedom, for all the pilgrims from all the lost places who…

    1 条评论
  • How technology has changed the world since I was young

    How technology has changed the world since I was young

    In 1970, Alvin Toffler published Future Shock, a book claiming that modern people feel overwhelmed by the pace of…

  • Generative AI and the finance industry

    Generative AI and the finance industry

    Generative AI is going to transform a lot of industries in ways that we probably can’t fully anticipate right now. One…

  • How Pakistan can join the South Asia growth boom

    How Pakistan can join the South Asia growth boom

    I’ve written very upbeat and optimistic posts about the growth of two giant South Asian countries — India and…

  • Where China is beating the world

    Where China is beating the world

    I think interviewing Dan Wang has made me want to write more about China’s economy, so here’s the first in a short…

  • Three more books about the technology wars

    Three more books about the technology wars

    Since I’ve been writing a lot about industrial competition between China and the developed democracies, I decided to…

    1 条评论
  • Biden declares economic war on the Chinese semiconductor industry

    Biden declares economic war on the Chinese semiconductor industry

    “You come at the king, you best not miss.” — Omar Little In a post back in August, I offered some thoughts on whether…

    1 条评论
  • Time for a little global financial chaos

    Time for a little global financial chaos

    An economist friend asked me to write about the possibility of a global financial crisis. He told me that he’s hearing…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了