Winning On and Off the Pitch

Winning On and Off the Pitch

An Idea for Consideration

This week, ESPN ran a fascinating article on the Manchester United football club. After winning 13 Premier League championships between 1993 and 2013 and never placing outside the top three teams in the league, the club has been on a decade-long decline that has seen no championships and eight managers.???

The decline is even more stark when you consider that the economics of professional football are such that the rich should get richer. Because the financial regulations require clubs to break even, those with massive brands have a systemic advantage over rivals because higher commercial revenue gives them more to spend on better (and more expensive) players and infrastructure.

This didn’t happen at United because they were bought in a leveraged buyout in 2005, and the new owners chose to receive dividends rather than reinvest in the team's success. The article quotes a staff member as saying the aspiration was only to be good enough to get into the most lucrative competitions. “Being in the Champions League was what mattered, rather than actually winning it.”

When club leaders focused on winning, they made tons of money. When the focus shifted to making lots of money, the club stopped winning.

That is a lesson on its own, but what sparked my interest was this line from the article: “The football team is the visible face that Manchester United projects to the world and what happens on the pitch — good, bad or indifferent — dictates the mood within Old Trafford [the organization as a whole].”

That line reminded me of conversations with two nonprofit leaders earlier in the week about why it is so important for teams to have robust conversations about goals and results. The main point: People want to be on a winning team, and results conversations help them know whether that is happening.?

If you work at a sports franchise, whether or not you’re on a winning team is obvious. The results are loud and accessible to everyone.?

But in most other organizations, that’s not the case. Businesses usually have a clear and measurable definition of success, but very few people in the organization regularly look at or even have access to the profit or sales data.? They only know if the team is winning when leaders provide that information and shape its meaning.

In the social sector, the need to show people they’re on a winning team is even more acute because employees are more likely to work on intractable problems, take on big systems, and come face-to-face with heartbreaking situations of poverty, hunger, violence, illness, and injustice. Employees are there for the mission, but if they don’t get a regular dose of “we’re making an impact” and “my effort matters,” they can easily lose motivation.

Regardless of sector, teams whose impact isn't easily captured in simple, quantifiable metrics face an additional challenge. On Monday, a nonprofit CEO told me that a few of her direct reports start conversations about results with “It’s complicated.” And when she tries to pin them down on specific commitments, they squirm like a 3-year-old who doesn’t want his parents to put on his shoes.

In this case, the “it’s complicated” response to measuring results is valid. However, when the difficulty of measuring success results in not defining success, it’s hard to hold others accountable to that standard and generate the emotional experience of winning. And it’s often the experience of winning that both binds us to the team and makes the effort worth it.


Leadership Wisdom

Michael Gregoire, former CEO of CA Technologies, in the New York Times: “If you’ve ever felt that, in sports or in business, to really work hard and be pushed up against your maximum and win, it’s addictive. You’ll do everything you can to get back in that ring, as ridiculous as it sounds. Why would you want to put yourself through that kind of pain, suffering and agony? But that, to me, is where the game is played, and you want to be in that game as much as you possibly can.”

Dolf van den Brink, CEO of Heineken, in the New York Times: “We were losing so much market share every month, and the problem seemed so big, but we started small. We focused on one neighborhood and tried to conquer 20 outlets rather than worrying about 20,000. We were able to do that, and that started to build our confidence. You have to make people believe that they can win again.”


Something Fun

Akram Afif had one of the greatest goal celebrations of all time after scoring for Qatar in the Asian Cup final:


Thanks for reading!

Charles



Get Monday Musings in Your Inbox

I publish this blog series each Monday. Like this one, it’ll contain something useful and something fun to start your week. If you want to receive Monday Musings in your inbox, subscribe here!

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Charles Moore的更多文章

  • Is It an Asteroid or Meteor?

    Is It an Asteroid or Meteor?

    An Idea for Consideration What’s the difference between an asteroid and a meteor? I asked myself that question this…

  • Normalizing (the Right Kind of) Experimentation

    Normalizing (the Right Kind of) Experimentation

    An Idea for Consideration Last week, I wrote about the power of resets. At the end of the post, I mentioned that a…

    1 条评论
  • The Power of a Reset

    The Power of a Reset

    An Idea for Consideration Last week, I talked about how I had been preparing for the move and staging our new house for…

    1 条评论
  • Moving & Experimentation

    Moving & Experimentation

    On Friday, my wife and I bought a new house. In many ways, this was accidental.

    1 条评论
  • Creating Dissatisfaction with the Status Quo

    Creating Dissatisfaction with the Status Quo

    An Idea for Consideration I co-lead a course on leading change at Georgetown’s Center for Nonprofit Leadership. I…

  • Competitive Child Rearing and the Exhausting Life

    Competitive Child Rearing and the Exhausting Life

    For the past couple of months, I’ve made it a habit to ask friends with adult children for their reflections on…

    2 条评论
  • Experimenting with the Sabbath

    Experimenting with the Sabbath

    “Remember to observe the Sabbath day by keeping it holy. Six days a week are set apart for your daily duties and…

    1 条评论
  • The Get-To : Have-To Ratio

    The Get-To : Have-To Ratio

    An Idea for Consideration In last week’s post, I argued that work-life balance challenges result from a lopsided ratio…

  • Are My Belongings Serving Me, or Vice Versa?

    Are My Belongings Serving Me, or Vice Versa?

    An Idea for Consideration After this week’s snowstorm, I was walking with my wife to a restaurant when she asked, “You…

  • Are We Talking about Process or Needs?

    Are We Talking about Process or Needs?

    An Idea for Consideration Happy New Year! When reading about or talking to people about managing demands across their…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了