Why Your Team Won’t Tell You They’ve Lost Confidence

At one point, everything with your team might have felt like it was running smoothly. The energy was high, ideas were flowing, and challenges were tackled head-on. But then, without warning, things started to change. The team became quieter. People who once jumped at the chance to take on new projects now sat on the sidelines. Deadlines slipped. And, at some point, you realized—maybe you didn’t want to admit it at first—you were losing your team’s trust.

It’s easy to blame external factors: market pressures, heavy workloads. But deep down, you probably sensed it wasn’t just that. Perhaps, after one meeting, you looked around and noticed that no one was sticking around to chat. Everyone packed up and left without making eye contact or offering any casual feedback. That’s when it hits: somehow, without realizing it, you’ve lost their confidence.

The key is to recognize the signs early!

Here’s how to know if you’re in the same situation:

1. Decline in Communication At first, it’s subtle. People stop engaging in casual conversations. Then, they stop sharing ideas or giving feedback altogether. If your team is holding back, you need to act quickly before communication breaks down completely.

2. Reduced Engagement and Productivity The excitement that once drove projects forward has vanished. If you notice people missing deadlines and showing less enthusiasm, it’s a sign that they’re disengaged, and that disengagement often stems from leadership.

3. Increased Turnover and Absenteeism You might dismiss one resignation as someone moving on to new opportunities. But when more people start leaving, or you see an uptick in sick days, it’s time to face reality: your team might not feel valued or supported, and they’re looking for the door.

4. Avoidance of Leadership One-on-one meetings used to feel like productive check-ins. Now, they seem to be something your team avoids. If they’re hesitant to talk to you or even avoid eye contact, they might be losing trust in your leadership.

5. Resistance to Change You roll out a new initiative, and you’re met with pushback. It’s not just resistance to the change itself—it’s resistance to you. If your team doesn’t trust your vision, they’re unlikely to support the direction you’re trying to take.

How to Turn It Around

When you recognize that you’ve lost your team’s confidence, it’s tough to admit, but it’s also the first step in turning things around. Here’s how you can get back on track:

Self-Reflection: Take an honest look at your leadership style. Ask yourself, “How am I contributing to the problem?” It’s not an easy question, but it’s essential for growth.

Transparent Communication: Be open about the challenges you’re facing and involve your team in finding solutions. When they feel heard and included, trust starts to rebuild.

Consistency: Show up consistently and follow through on your promises. Trust is rebuilt through actions, not just words.

Leadership isn’t a straight line—it’s full of twists, turns, ups and downs. If you notice the signs that your team is losing confidence in you, don’t panic. Take a step back, reassess, and make the changes needed to rebuild trust. If you’re willing to adapt, you can restore your team’s faith and get things back on track.

Ready to regain your team's confidence and improve your leadership effectiveness?

Start by identifying your blind spots. Take the first step—schedule a free leadership assessment today and uncover actionable insights to strengthen your team dynamics.

Don’t let unnoticed issues hinder your success.