Why You Shouldn’t “Honk” at Someone in Crisis: Lessons from Deer in Headlights

We’ve all heard the phrase “like a deer in headlights,” describing someone who freezes in a moment of panic, stress, or confusion.

The image of a deer caught motionless in front of a car’s bright headlights is a powerful metaphor for how people sometimes react when overwhelmed by stress or trauma. And just like honking at the deer won’t make it move, overwhelming a stressed or traumatized person with questions or demands can often do more harm than good.

What if the way we react to others in moments of stress is as crucial as the way we respond to a deer in our path?

Explore this idea and how it relates to being helpful when someone you know is deeply stressed or traumatized.

The Instinct to “Honk” – And Why It Backfires

Imagine driving late at night when a deer suddenly appears in front of your car, frozen in the glow of your headlights. Your first instinct might be to honk your horn to get the deer to move. However, honking at the deer doesn’t help; it often startles the animal further, causing it to panic or make sudden, dangerous movements.

In a similar way, when we encounter a person overwhelmed by stress or trauma, our instinct might be to ask a lot of questions or push them to “snap out of it.” We might believe that offering immediate solutions, demanding answers, or pushing them to talk will help. Yet, just like with the deer, this can make the situation worse. The person may feel more overwhelmed, freeze up even more, or respond unpredictably.

Why Pushing Isn’t Productive

People who are in a highly stressed or traumatized state are often unable to process information in the same way they might under normal conditions. The brain’s response to trauma—commonly known as "fight, flight, or freeze"—can leave them stuck in a mental fog, much like the deer’s reaction to the headlights.

Bombarding them with questions or pushing them to act can cause them to shut down further. Just as the deer can't comprehend the honking of a horn as a signal to move, a person in crisis may struggle to process questions or advice in the moment.

Instead of honking, what the deer needs—and what a stressed person may also need—is a different kind of help: calm, gentle guidance and a sense of safety.

The Gentle Approach: Creating a Safe Space

Much like turning down the headlights to reduce the deer’s fear, we can create a safe and calm environment for someone in distress. Here are a few key ways to offer helpful support:

1. Lower the Intensity

When someone is overwhelmed, reducing the intensity of your interaction can help them feel less threatened. Rather than asking rapid-fire questions or pushing them to talk, try offering simple, soothing reassurances. Let them know you’re there for them and that it’s okay for them to take their time. Quiet presence can be incredibly powerful.

2. Offer Gentle Guidance, Not Pressure

Instead of demanding answers or actions, offer suggestions in a way that gives the person control over how they respond. For instance, instead of saying, “You need to talk about what happened,” try, “I’m here if you’d like to talk or just sit quietly.” This gives them the space to choose what feels most comfortable, which can reduce feelings of helplessness or panic.

3. Give Them Time to Move at Their Own Pace

Just as the deer needs time to assess the situation before moving, people in stress or trauma need time to process their emotions and thoughts. Rushing them can make them feel more trapped, whereas allowing them to move forward at their own pace can foster healing. Respect their timing and show patience as they navigate through their feelings.

4. Be a Safe Presence

Sometimes, simply being present without saying much can be more helpful than trying to fix the problem. A calm, steady presence provides a sense of stability, which can be comforting to someone whose inner world feels chaotic. Much like standing by while the deer finds its way, being there for someone in a non-pressuring way shows support without overwhelming them.

Compassion Rather Than Confrontation

In times of stress or trauma, we can often do more harm than good by pushing for immediate responses or quick fixes. Just as honking at a deer in headlights won’t move it to safety, overwhelming someone in crisis with questions or demands will not bring them out of their state of distress. Instead, offer patience, gentle guidance, and the space they need to move forward at their own pace.

If you find yourself supporting someone who’s frozen in stress, remember: slow down, turn down the intensity, and let them know you're there. Often, the quietest, most compassionate approach is the one that makes the most difference.

Creating a Better World Together as Happier Healthier Humans! ????????????

You can enjoy less stiffness, more energy, and have practical tools to use every day so that you feel fabulous—without overwhelming routines or gym workouts!

Get a free training on the 3 simple steps of WISE ?Revitalize? and receive a bonus Quick Relief 1:1 Session with personalized strategies that provide fast acting and lasting results.

Access at https://skool.com/pain-free