Why You Should Worry About Deflation

Reviewed by Michael Landsberg, CIO, Landsberg Bennett Private Wealth Management.

Deflation, characterized by falling prices, often initially seems favorable. Many associate it with lower costs for goods and services, suggesting that consumers benefit from greater purchasing power during such periods. However, this perspective, while partially valid, oversimplifies the reality of deflation. Its broader implications are far more complex and concerning. Deflation, though historically rare, can profoundly impact the economy, affecting individuals, businesses, and policymakers.

This article aims to shed light on the intricate nature of deflation. We will explore how it influences both the macroeconomy and personal finances, providing a nuanced view. By delving into this topic, we intend to balance the apparent short-term advantages with the long-term economic challenges and risks that deflation can introduce.

Understanding Deflation

Deflation occurs when there is a general decline in prices, often due to reduced money supply or credit availability. It contrasts with inflation, where prices increase. Deflation has been historically associated with challenging economic periods, such as the Great Depression in the 1930s.

Let's explore the reasons behind deflation:

• Increased Productivity: Efficiency improvements in businesses can lead to lower product costs. For example, during the pandemic, some industries optimized production, using fewer resources. A car manufacturer that develops more efficient manufacturing processes might offer lower-priced vehicles.

• Reduced Consumer Demand: Economic uncertainty or financial concerns can lead consumers to spend less. In response, businesses might lower prices to attract buyers. Imagine retailers offering discounts on clothing as shoppers reduce their expenditures.

• Money Supply Shrinks: A decrease in money circulation, possibly due to reduced lending by banks or changes in central bank policies, can lead to deflation. With less money to spend, there is a downward pressure on prices.

• Tech Advances: Innovations often reduce costs. Consider the evolution of smartphones, which are now more affordable despite increased capabilities. The price reduction of older technologies illustrates how innovation can contribute to deflation.

• Global Trade: Importing cost-effective components or products can lower prices. Companies might import parts to assemble products more affordably.

• Debt Troubles: High debt levels can exacerbate deflation. To manage or settle debts, individuals and businesses might sell assets at reduced prices, increasing the supply of goods on the market and further driving down prices.

By examining these factors, we can better understand the causes of deflation and its implications for the economy and everyday life.

Read: How to Protect Your Investments During Volatile Markets

Comparative Analysis: Deflation vs. Inflation

Inflation is often highlighted as a primary economic concern, yet it's vital to recognize that deflation can be just as problematic. Where inflation drives people to purchase swiftly before prices escalate, deflation can have a contrasting effect, decelerating the economy and leading to a decline in both demand and prices.

It's common to focus on inflation as a key economic challenge. Still, the potential harm of deflation warrants equal attention. With inflation, there's a tendency for hasty buying in anticipation of rising costs. However, deflation flips this scenario, cooling off economic activities and pulling down both demand and prices.

Although inflation tends to dominate economic discussions, it's important not to overlook the adverse effects of deflation. Unlike inflation, which can create a rush in purchases, deflation tends to put the brakes on spending and economic growth, causing a dip in demand and a general price decline.

Read: How to Deal With 'Dead Cat Bounce'

Why You Should Worry About Deflation: The Economic Impact

Deflation, characterized by falling prices, can initially seem like a welcome change for consumers, who often anticipate lower costs for goods and services. However, the impacts of deflation are multifaceted and extend beyond the immediate perception of savings. Here are the reasons why you should be cautious about deflation:

Delayed Consumer Spending

As prices fall, it's common for consumers to postpone purchases, betting on even lower prices in the future. This hesitation can significantly reduce overall spending, impacting the economy. Consider someone contemplating the purchase of a new smartphone. They might delay their decision, hoping for a more favorable deal later on. Such collective postponement in spending can have substantial effects on economic dynamics.

For instance, a family might hold off on buying a new car, anticipating further price reductions. A business could similarly delay upgrading its technology, expecting lower costs ahead. These cumulative delays in spending can contribute to economic stagnation.

This pattern can create a cascading effect: reduced consumer spending leads businesses to scale back production and potentially reduce their workforce. This cycle of declining consumption and production can perpetuate broader economic challenges.

While waiting for prices to drop further might seem prudent, widespread deferral of spending can negatively impact the economy. It highlights the importance of finding a balance between individual savings and sustaining economic momentum.

Decreased Business Profitability

Deflation, characterized by its downward pressure on prices, places businesses in a challenging position. Consider an electronics store: as prices fall, their purchasing costs might remain constant or even rise. This situation squeezes their profit margins, akin to trying to fit into a shoe that's just a bit too tight.

Take a restaurant during times of deflation as another example. While they might be charging less for their dishes, the expenses for ingredients and staff wages could stay the same or increase. This discrepancy between income and expenditures can significantly eat into their profitability.

Businesses under such strain often scale back their investments. The electronics store might hold off on renovations or expansion plans, while the restaurant could postpone introducing new menu items or enhancing services. Such cutbacks can impede economic growth, as businesses are pivotal in fostering innovation and employment.

This scenario is similar to a seesaw effect. When deflation lowers prices, it can upset the balance for businesses, making it more difficult for them to expand and invest in future growth. This hesitancy can stifle long-term economic progress, impacting the entire community. Therefore, while lower prices might initially seem beneficial, they can lead to broader, unintended economic consequences.

Diminished Job Opportunities

Faced with lower profits and declining demand, businesses in a deflationary environment often need to reduce costs to stay afloat, which frequently involves downsizing their workforce.

For instance, envision a factory producing electronic devices. With falling prices, their revenue may decline while the costs of materials and labor remain. To adjust, they might have to lay off employees to reduce expenses. Similarly, a retail chain experiencing a downturn in sales might close some locations and reduce staff to cut operational costs.

These measures, though critical for the survival of a business, can trigger a ripple effect in the economy. Rising unemployment rates can follow as more companies reduce their workforce. People who lose their jobs tend to spend less, exacerbating the decline in demand and contributing to the economic slowdown.

It's like a domino effect; one move affects the whole setup. The decrease in available jobs not only places financial pressure on individuals and families but also accelerates the economic slowdown, making recovery more challenging for the entire economy.

Although deflation may initially seem like a respite from increasing prices, it can initiate a cycle of reduced business profitability, layoffs, and economic slowdown, affecting individuals and the community at large.

Negative Impact on Debtors

Deflation can make debts more burdensome. When prices fall, the amount of debt stays the same, but its real cost increases as the value of money goes up.

Imagine having a fixed-rate mortgage when deflation hits. Even though your monthly payment doesn’t change, the actual value of what you owe grows because the worth of your house may be decreasing. So, you end up paying more in the long run than you expected when you first borrowed the money.

Businesses with loans face a similar situation. A company that borrowed funds to grow might find repaying the loan tougher during deflation since the money they make is now worth more, but their debt amount doesn’t change.

This scenario can strain finances for both individuals and companies. The rising real value of debts can make repayments tougher, leading to possible defaults or bankruptcies, which ripple through the economy.

So, while it might seem like deflation would make it easier to pay off debts, it often does the opposite, creating financial hurdles for borrowers and sparking broader economic issues.

Challenges in Monetary Policy Effectiveness

In a deflationary setting, central banks face a tricky situation when interest rates are already low. Traditional methods like cutting rates don’t work as well, making it tough for them to stimulate the economy.

Typically, central banks lower interest rates to encourage people and businesses to spend and invest. This works well when there’s inflation, as it prompts actions like buying homes or expanding business operations. But deflation changes the game.

During deflation, people and businesses might wait out, hoping prices will drop even more. This can weaken the effectiveness of reduced interest rates since there’s less incentive to borrow and spend.

Say a central bank reduces rates to boost the housing market. If potential buyers think house prices will fall further, they may hold off on buying, making the rate cut less effective.

With deflation, central banks have to think outside the box, since their usual go-to strategies have less impact. They might need to try different tactics to encourage economic growth and manage deflation’s challenges.

Impact on Investment

The uncertainty about future prices can make both businesses and individual investors think twice before making financial commitments. This caution can slow down the creation of capital, impacting economic growth and progress in areas like technology and innovation.

For example, a tech company might hesitate to invest in a new product during deflation. They're unsure if the future selling price will cover the costs of development, leading them to postpone or scrap the project.

Individual investors may also be wary. Someone thinking about buying stocks might wait, unsure how deflation could affect the company's profits and the investment's value.

Read: 9 Tax-Exempted Investments You Should Consider

This cautious approach to investment can ripple through the economy, leading to fewer startups, slower innovation, and limited job growth. The hesitation to fund research and development can also dampen technological advancements.

Deflation's effect on investment reaches beyond financial markets, influencing the broader economic landscape and affecting everyone from large companies to everyday individuals. It shows just how closely linked prices and investment decisions are in shaping the economy's direction.

Strain on Government Finances

Deflation can tighten the purse strings of government budgets. Falling prices and weaker economic activity often mean reduced tax revenues, limiting government spending on essential services and infrastructure projects. This can adversely affect public well-being and economic growth prospects.

Consider a government that relies on consumer spending for tax income, like sales taxes. When consumers pull back on spending in a deflationary climate, tax income drops. This leaves the government with fewer resources for public services such as healthcare, education, or transportation.

Additionally, if businesses face declining profits or need to reduce their workforce due to deflation, their tax contributions decrease as well.

Imagine a country facing deflation, leading to lower corporate profits. This scenario not only impacts the government's ability to fund social programs but also constrains investments in vital infrastructure, like roads or energy-efficient facilities.

This financial pressure on governments can ripple out, affecting citizens' quality of life and the broader economic outlook. It highlights the close relationship between price levels, government revenue, and the capacity to provide key services and invest in the future. In short, deflation's impact goes beyond mere price changes, touching the core of government finances and influencing public welfare and long-term economic progress.

Difficulty in Adjusting Wages

In a deflationary environment, businesses often struggle to reduce nominal wages, constrained by legal factors and social norms. This leads to a scenario where real wages (wages adjusted for deflation) effectively increase, putting companies in a tough spot regarding workforce sustainability, which could elevate unemployment levels.

Consider a business in a deflation-hit industry. While their costs for materials might drop, lowering employees' wages can be complex due to labor laws or collective agreements. So, employees' real wages might rise, despite the business facing deflationary pressures.

Take a clothing factory as an example. If the cost of fabric drops but wages stay the same due to contractual obligations, employees effectively gain more purchasing power. While beneficial for workers, this can challenge the business's financial health.

Businesses in such situations may need to make hard choices, like workforce reductions or investment cutbacks, to manage these deflation-related complexities. This can lead to higher unemployment rates and dampened economic activity.

Thus, deflation introduces complexities in wage adjustments, affecting both businesses and workers in significant ways.

Distortion of Market Signals

Deflation can confuse the critical signals that prices send in a market economy, complicating decision-making for businesses around production, investment, and resource allocation.

Normally, prices in a healthy market reflect supply and demand. For instance, rising demand typically leads to higher prices, signaling businesses to increase production. Conversely, falling demand leads to lower prices and a production decrease.

However, in a deflationary climate, this signal system gets muddled. Imagine a smartphone company unsure whether to adjust prices following market trends or demand.

For instance, even if demand for their products stays steady, they might feel pressured to lower prices due to overall deflation. This can affect their profitability and make it harder to make informed decisions about resources and investments.

Deflation's disruption of market signals can have wide-reaching impacts, affecting businesses, consumers, and the entire economy. It shows how deflation can complicate the traditional dynamics of supply and demand, adding uncertainty to economic decision-making.

Reduced Consumer Confidence

Extended periods of deflation can undermine consumer confidence, leading to concerns about job security and future income, further decreasing consumption and hindering economic recovery.

When deflation lingers, people often become more cautious with their spending. They might delay big purchases or cut back on extras, similar to saving for an uncertain future.

For example, a family might put off buying a new car, thinking their money might stretch further later. Or someone might hesitate to renovate their home, betting on getting more for their money down the road.

These individual decisions to spend less have a collective impact, leading to reduced consumption across the board. Businesses then face lower demand, possibly leading to job cuts or decreased production, which in turn feeds into the cycle of economic stagnation.

In summary, deflation's reach goes beyond just prices—it influences consumer behavior and confidence, shaping the entire economic landscape. Restoring consumer confidence is key to overcoming the economic hurdles posed by deflation.

Impact on Pension Funds and Retirement Savings

Deflation can negatively affect pension funds and retirement savings. In a deflationary period, returns on investments typically decrease, which can leave retirees with less income than they need for their living expenses.

For a closer look, consider pension funds that invest in a mix of assets for retirees' returns. In deflation, these assets might lose value, much like a tree struggling to bear fruit in poor soil.

Take a pension fund invested in bonds as an example. While bond prices might rise during deflation due to falling interest rates, the actual returns could be lower than expected, making it hard for the fund to meet retirees' income needs.

Read: Charting Your Retirement: Key Retirement Milestones You Need to Know

Similarly, individuals saving for retirement might see their investment values drop. Like pension funds, they could struggle to generate enough returns, impacting their financial security in retirement.

The effects of deflation on retirement funds can be significant. Retirees might need to cut back on expenses, use up their savings quicker, or delay retirement, affecting both their personal lives and broader social systems.

Read: Retiring Early? Here's What You Need to Consider

Increased Real Interest Rates

Deflation can lead to higher real interest rates, even when nominal rates are low. Real interest rates are nominal rates adjusted for deflation's effects and can discourage borrowing for both consumption and investment.

To understand this, consider nominal interest rates as the advertised rates by banks. Real interest rates factor in the currency's purchasing power. For instance, if a bank offers a 2% nominal rate on savings and there's 1% inflation, the real rate is 1%. With 1% deflation, the real rate rises to 3%.

Higher real rates can affect borrowing and investment. A business might hesitate to take a loan for expansion, finding the higher real rate less appealing. Consumers may also rethink loans for major purchases.

In short, deflation can make borrowing more expensive in real terms, reducing spending and investment and contributing to economic slowdown. It shows how deflation can impact financial decision-making at different levels.

Conclusion

Understanding deflation is crucial for both individuals and businesses, as it prepares them to effectively handle its diverse effects. While deflation might initially seem beneficial due to lower prices, its deeper impact can significantly hinder economic growth and stability. In a constantly changing economy, staying informed and adaptable is key to managing the challenges of deflation.

Consider the broader picture: deflation brings lower prices, which might look good at first. But this benefit masks more complex economic issues. As discussed, deflation can cause consumer spending to slow down, decrease business profits, increase job losses, create financial pressures for borrowers, complicate monetary policy, and even risk a deflationary spiral.

These effects highlight the need to be well-informed and flexible. Businesses should adjust their strategies to cope with economic changes, while individuals need to be careful with their finances, especially regarding debts and retirement planning. Policymakers and central banks also have a crucial role in developing policies that lessen deflation's negative impact and support economic stability.

In essence, understanding deflation is more than just an academic pursuit; it's a vital part of navigating economic realities. By grasping its complexities, everyone from individuals to governments can better prepare to face deflation's challenges and strive for continued economic health and growth.

Work with Landsberg Bennett Private Wealth Management

At Landsberg Bennett Private Wealth Management, our focus is on your financial well-being. We build our services on trust and are committed to offering tailored financial guidance.

Client-Centered Approach

Our fee-only structure is designed to align our advice with your financial objectives, eliminating the influence of commissions. This method reinforces our commitment to strategies that align with your goals.

Fiduciary Responsibility

As fiduciaries, our duty is to prioritize your financial interests. This duty shapes every decision we make, ensuring that your financial objectives are the central focus of our wealth management services.

Clear Communication

Open and honest communication is key to our approach. By encouraging transparent discussions, we aim to deepen your understanding of your financial choices, strengthening the trust and confidence in our relationship.

Tailored Investment Strategies

We customize our investment recommendations to suit your personal situation, taking into account your risk preferences and financial objectives. Our fee-only model means our success is directly linked to yours.

Dedication to Ethical Practices

Integrity is fundamental to our practice. We manage your assets with top shelf standards of ethical conduct, ensuring responsible stewardship of your portfolio.

Choosing Landsberg Bennett Private Wealth Management means entrusting us with more than just your finances; it means entrusting us with your financial future. Our team is committed to providing diligent and ethical wealth management as your fee-only, fiduciary partner.

Contact Us

Address:

252 West Marion Avenue Suite 200,

Punta Gorda, FL 33950

Email:

[email protected]

Phone:

941.391.8000

Disclaimer:

Landsberg Bennett is a group comprised of investment professionals registered with Hightower Advisors, LLC, an SEC registered investment adviser. Registration as an investment adviser does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Advisory services are offered through Hightower Advisors, LLC. All information referenced herein is from sources believed to be reliable. Landsberg Bennett and Hightower Advisors, LLC have not independently verified the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this document. Landsberg Bennett and Hightower Advisors, LLC or any of its affiliates make no representations or warranties, express or implied, as to the accuracy or completeness of the information or for statements or errors or omissions, or results obtained from the use of this information. Landsberg Bennett and Hightower Advisors, LLC or any of its affiliates assume no liability for any action made or taken in reliance on or relating in any way to the information. This document and the materials contained herein were created for informational purposes only; the opinions expressed are solely those of the author(s), and do not represent those of Hightower Advisors, LLC or any of its affiliates. Landsberg Bennett and Hightower Advisors, LLC or any of its affiliates do not provide tax or legal advice. This material was not intended or written to be used or presented to any entity as tax or legal advice. Clients are urged to consult their tax and/or legal advisor for related questions.

Hightower Advisors, LLC is an SEC registered investment adviser. Securities are offered through Hightower Securities, LLC member FINRA and SIPC. Hightower Advisors, LLC or any of its affiliates do not provide tax or legal advice. This material is not intended or written to provide and should not be relied upon or used as a substitute for tax or legal advice. Information contained herein does not consider an individual’s or entity’s specific circumstances or applicable governing law, which may vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction and be subject to change. Clients are urged to consult their tax or legal advisor for related questions.