Why You Need a Strong Shareholder Agreement

Selling your middle-market business is a significant endeavor, requiring meticulous planning, negotiation, and execution. Yet, amid all the intricacies, there's one crucial element that is often underestimated or overlooked: the shareholder agreement. A robust shareholder agreement can become the linchpin of a seamless and lucrative transaction, offering you, the shareholder, clarity, protection, and alignment with fellow stakeholders.

In this blog, we'll delve into the pivotal role of a strong shareholder agreement when it comes to selling your business and how it can elevate the value and smoothness of your sale process.

What is a Shareholder Agreement?

A shareholder agreement, often referred to as a stockholders' agreement, is a legal document entered into by all the shareholders of a corporation. It delineates the rights, privileges, protections, and obligations of the shareholders, both among themselves and in relation to the company. The agreement provides a framework for how the company is to be operated and offers guidelines on how specific situations should be handled. In essence, it supplements the bylaws and articles of incorporation of the company, providing additional clarity and specificity.

Defining Roles and Responsibilities

A well-constructed shareholder agreement outlines the roles and responsibilities of each shareholder within the company. This document is your shield against disputes and misunderstandings among shareholders during the sale process. When potential buyers assess your business, they scrutinize the stability and cohesion of your shareholder group. A clear shareholder agreement demonstrates that you and your fellow shareholders share a common understanding of your roles and responsibilities, instilling confidence in prospective buyers.

Furthermore, the agreement can lay down the rights and obligations of shareholders in case of a sale, including decision-making powers, voting rights, and exit strategies. This clarity can simplify negotiations and ensure that all shareholders are on the same page when it comes to the sale terms and conditions.

Valuation and Pricing

Valuing a business can be a complex and contentious process, often posing a significant hurdle during a sale transaction. A robust shareholder agreement can incorporate provisions for valuing the company and establishing the sale price. This streamlined approach can facilitate negotiations with potential buyers and ensure that all shareholders share a mutual understanding of the company's value.

Moreover, the agreement can institute mechanisms for resolving valuation disputes, such as appointing an independent appraiser or employing predefined valuation methods. By addressing these issues beforehand, your shareholder agreement can save you time and reduce the risk of protracted and heated negotiations during the sale process.

Preempting Minority Shareholder Rights

In many middle-market businesses, there may be minority shareholders who lack a controlling interest in the company. A strong shareholder agreement can act as a shield, protecting the rights and interests of minority shareholders when a sale opportunity arises. It can specify the rights of minority shareholders, including their role in the decision-making process and their entitlement to a fair share of the sale proceeds.

Additionally, the agreement can delineate drag-along rights, enabling majority shareholders to compel minority shareholders to participate in a sale transaction. This provision is vital to ensure that a potential buyer acquires the entire business, avoiding fragmented ownership structures.

Maintaining Confidentiality

Confidentiality is paramount throughout the sale process, as leaks of sensitive information can erode the business's value and reputation. A meticulously crafted shareholder agreement can encompass strict confidentiality provisions that prevent shareholders from divulging confidential information to external parties, especially during negotiations with potential buyers.

These provisions can also outline the consequences of breaching confidentiality, such as monetary penalties or legal actions. By maintaining a tight grip on confidentiality, your strong shareholder agreement can safeguard the business's competitive edge and protect its value throughout the sale process.

Managing Competing Offers

When selling a business, it's not uncommon to receive multiple offers from different buyers. A robust shareholder agreement can establish a clear process for evaluating and managing these competing offers. It can define criteria for assessing offers, including price, terms, and the qualifications of potential buyers.

Furthermore, the agreement can lay out a protocol for communication and negotiation with potential buyers, ensuring that all shareholders are aligned in their approach. This harmonization can help maximize the value of the sale while minimizing the risk of disputes or misunderstandings among shareholders.

Ensuring a Smooth Transition

The transition from one ownership group to another can be a challenging period for a business. A strong shareholder agreement can feature provisions that facilitate a smooth transition, such as requirements for the buyer to assume certain liabilities, honor existing contracts, or retain key employees.

Additionally, the agreement can specify the timeline for the transition and the roles and responsibilities of shareholders during this period. By addressing these issues in advance, your shareholder agreement can ensure that the business continues to operate effectively during the ownership transfer.

Protecting Minority Shareholders from Squeeze-Outs

In some instances, majority shareholders may attempt to squeeze out minority shareholders or coerce them into selling their shares at an unfavorable price. A well-crafted shareholder agreement can shield minority shareholders from such scenarios by incorporating provisions that mandate majority shareholders to act in good faith and offer fair prices when purchasing minority shares.

These provisions are instrumental in preserving the interests of minority shareholders and thwarting coercive tactics during the sale process.

In preparing for collaboration, consider the following key players:

You and Your Fellow Shareholders: First and foremost, your involvement as current and potential shareholders is crucial. Your shared interest in the company's success, along with your respective rights and responsibilities, makes your input invaluable.

Trusted Legal Counsel: Expertise in corporate law is paramount. An experienced attorney can ensure that the agreement is comprehensive, complies with relevant regulations, and safeguards the rights of all parties involved.

Proficient Accountants and Financial Advisors: Financial professionals possess valuable insights into valuation methods, dividend policies, and other fiscal considerations. Their guidance can significantly contribute to the strength of your shareholder agreement.

Experienced Investment Bankers: In the context of a sale, these experts can provide invaluable guidance on the provisions that might pique the interest of potential buyers or raise concerns. Their expertise can be a game-changer in crafting a robust shareholder agreement.

***

In the realm of middle-market mergers and acquisitions, a strong shareholder agreement transcends being merely a legal document; it transforms into a strategic asset. It offers you, the shareholder, clarity, protection, and alignment with fellow shareholders, rendering the sale process smoother and more lucrative. By delineating roles and responsibilities, addressing valuation and pricing, safeguarding minority shareholder rights, preserving confidentiality, managing competing offers, facilitating a smooth transition, and guarding against squeeze-outs, a robust shareholder agreement serves as the bedrock of a triumphant business sale.

When you contemplate the sale of your middle-market business, investing time and effort to create or update a shareholder agreement is a judicious choice that can yield manifold benefits during the sale process. It empowers you to navigate the intricacies of M&A transactions with confidence, ensuring the best possible outcome for you and all stakeholders involved.