Why We Make Irrational Decisions: The Science of Risk and Reward

Imagine you're at a casino. You've just lost $50 at the blackjack table, and you're faced with a choice: walk away now, or bet another $50 for a chance to break even. Despite knowing the odds aren't in your favour, something pulls you to place that next bet. This urge to recover losses, even at the risk of losing more, isn't just poor judgment—it's a fundamental aspect of human psychology that scientists have carefully mapped out.

Welcome to prospect theory, one of the most influential insights into human decision-making. It explains not just gambling behavior, but everything from how we invest in stocks to why we struggle to stick to diets.

The Revolutionary Idea That Changed Economics Forever

In 1979, two psychologists, Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, published a paper that would eventually win a Nobel Prize in Economics. Their radical idea? As economists had long assumed, humans don't make decisions by carefully calculating expected values. Instead, we evaluate options based on gains and losses relative to our current situation and handle these gains and losses in surprisingly asymmetric ways.

"Traditional economics treated humans like hyper-rational calculators," explains behavioural economist Dan Ariely. "Kahneman and Tversky showed we're more like emotional beings with some capacity for reason—and very predictable irrationalities."

The Pain of Loss is Twice as Strong

Here's the core insight of prospect theory: losing something hurts about twice as much as gaining the same thing feels good. Lose $50, and the psychological pain is roughly twice as intense as the pleasure of finding $50 on the street.

This "loss aversion" shapes countless decisions in our daily lives. It's why we:

- Hold onto losing stocks too long, hoping they'll bounce back

- Stay in unsatisfying jobs because leaving feels like a loss

- Keep unused items cluttering our homes because giving them up feels like a loss

## Risk-Seeking in Losses, Risk-Averse in Gains

But prospect theory revealed something even more fascinating about human nature. When facing potential gains, we tend to play it safe. Given the choice between a guaranteed $500 or a 50% chance at $1,000, most people take the sure thing. But when facing losses, we become risk-seekers. When choosing between losing $500 for sure or a 50% chance of losing $1,000, most people gamble.

This explains why investors often "double down" on losing investments but quickly sell winning ones. It's the same psychology that drives gambling addiction—losses trigger risk-seeking behaviour in an attempt to break even.

The Reference Point: It's All Relative

Perhaps most importantly, prospect theory showed that we don't evaluate things in absolute terms, but relative to a reference point—usually our current situation. A $5,000 raise feels like a win if you were expecting $3,000, but a loss if you were expecting $7,000.

This "framing effect" has profound implications. A doctor saying a treatment has an "80% survival rate" versus a "20% mortality rate" is presenting identical information, but patients react very differently to each framing.

From Theory to Practice

Today, prospect theory influences fields far beyond economics:

- Public Health: Framing exercise as a way to "avoid losing health" rather than "gaining fitness" can be more motivating

- Marketing: "Don't miss out!" appeals work better than "Get this deal!" because they trigger loss aversion

- Environmental Conservation: Messaging about "preventing losses" to nature often resonates more than "securing gains"

The Power of Understanding Our Biases

Knowing about prospect theory won't automatically make you rational—these biases are deeply wired into our psychology. But awareness can help us make better decisions:

- When investing, set rules in advance to avoid emotional decisions during losses

- When making big life choices, try reframing the situation to see how it affects your preferences

- When evaluating risks, remember your natural tendency to be risk-averse with gains and risk-seeking with losses

As Kahneman himself noted, "The goal is not to eliminate these biases—they're part of who we are. The goal is to understand them well enough to work around them when it matters most."

In a world of increasing complexity and constant choices, understanding the quirks of our decision-making machinery isn't just fascinating—it's essential. Prospect theory gives us a map of our mental terrain, helping us navigate the challenging landscape of modern decision-making with greater awareness and wisdom.

---

While the rational calculator envisioned by classical economics never existed, the emotional decision-maker revealed by prospect theory is very real. It's you, it's me, it's everyone we know. By understanding this aspect of our nature, we can make better choices while accepting and even appreciating the wonderfully irrational creatures we sometimes are.

A Note on Creation: This article was crafted with the assistance of AI technology, specifically using Claude from Anthropic. I believe in transparency and embracing the tools that help us create better content. While the insights and analysis are grounded in real business experiences, AI helped organize and articulate these ideas more effectively. Let me know what you think about this collaboration between human insight and AI assistance!