Why Servant Leadership is More Relevant Than Ever (Despite What Critics Say)

Welcome to "Staying Relevant with Mitchell Levy," your weekly newsletter dedicated to helping you navigate the ever-changing landscape of the modern world. Every week, we'll delve into the strategies, practices, and insights that empower you to adapt, evolve, and thrive amidst disruption.?

Servant leadership is a concept often dismissed in today’s fast-paced, cutthroat world. Critics argue that it’s too soft, too idealistic, and impractical in our competitive environments. But here’s the thing: servant leadership is not only relevant—it’s desperately needed.

The Myth of Traditional Leadership

For years, traditional leadership has been the gold standard. We’re taught that strong leaders are those who command, control, and assert their power. The idea is that to be effective, a leader needs to be tough, focused on results, and willing to do whatever it takes to win. But where has this gotten us?

We’re living in a world where trust in leaders is at an all-time low, workplaces are plagued by burnout, and the gap between the rich and the poor continues to widen. If traditional leadership is so great, why are so many people unhappy, stressed, and disengaged?

Servant Leadership: Soft or Strong?

Let’s tackle the main criticism head-on: servant leadership is seen as weak. It’s often portrayed as too soft-hearted for the real world, where competition is fierce and the stakes are high. But this view completely misses the point.

Servant leadership isn’t about being soft. It’s about being strong enough to put others first. It’s about having the courage to listen, to empathize, and to make decisions that benefit everyone, not just those at the top. Servant leaders build trust, foster collaboration, and create environments where people actually want to work. And in the long run, these “soft” qualities lead to stronger, more resilient organizations.

The Hard Truth: The World Needs Servant Leaders

Here’s the reality: the world is changing, and the problems we face today are complex and interconnected. Climate change, social injustice, and economic inequality aren’t issues that can be solved by traditional, top-down leadership. They require leaders who are willing to listen, to bring people together, and to put the common good ahead of their own interests.

Here’s why servant leadership matters more than ever:

• Trust in Leadership: Traditional leaders may command respect, but they often fail to build trust. Servant leaders, on the other hand, earn trust by being transparent, fair, and genuinely caring about their team’s well-being.
• Long-Term Success: Quick wins and immediate results are often the focus of traditional leaders. But servant leaders understand that long-term success comes from investing in people, fostering a positive culture, and building sustainable relationships.
• Innovation Through Empathy: It’s easy to overlook the connection between empathy and innovation. But when leaders truly understand the needs and challenges of their team, they can create an environment where new ideas flourish.

The Double Standard: Why Are We Afraid of Servant Leadership?

If servant leadership is so effective, why is it still met with skepticism? The truth is, many people are afraid of change. They’re comfortable with the status quo, even if it’s not working. There’s a double standard at play: we criticize servant leaders for being too soft, but we also complain about traditional leaders being too harsh.

This contradiction reveals a deeper issue—many of us are afraid to admit that the way we’ve been doing things isn’t working. It’s easier to dismiss servant leadership as unrealistic than to confront the possibility that our current leadership models are flawed.

Servant Leadership in Action: Real-World Examples

Still not convinced? Let’s look at some real-world examples of servant leadership in action.

• Satya Nadella, CEO of Microsoft: Under Nadella’s leadership, Microsoft has become more inclusive, innovative, and successful. He’s done this not by commanding and controlling, but by listening, learning, and putting his people first.
• Jacinda Ardern, Former Prime Minister of New Zealand: Ardern’s leadership during crises like the Christchurch mosque shootings and the COVID-19 pandemic showed the power of leading with empathy and compassion. She made tough decisions, but always with the well-being of her people in mind.

The Final Word: Servant Leadership is the Future

It’s time to stop dismissing servant leadership as unrealistic or too soft for the real world. The truth is, servant leaders are exactly what we need right now. They’re the ones who will help us navigate the complex challenges we face, build trust in our institutions, and create a more inclusive, sustainable future.

So, the next time someone tells you that servant leadership is dead, ask them this: is it servant leadership that’s unrealistic, or is it our outdated ideas about what leadership should be? The world is changing, and our leaders need to change with it. Servant leadership isn’t just relevant—it’s the only way forward.