Why Real Estate Agents Are Missing the Mark in Sales

Why Real Estate Agents Are Missing the Mark in Sales

Real estate agents make up one of the largest groups of "salespeople" in any industry. Yet, ironically, a shocking number of them have never truly been trained in the art of selling. Yes, they’ve been handed scripts—oops, I mean “dialogues”—and shown how to handle objections, present statistics, and complete comparative market analyses. But let’s be real: none of that means they’ve actually learned how to sell.

What’s missing? The basics. How to start a conversation with a perfect stranger. How to gain trust at that very first encounter. How to uncover the truth behind the words they’re hearing from prospects. And let’s not forget: how to make the prospect want to hire them, rather than feel pressured into an agreement.

The Independent Contractor Conundrum

One of the biggest challenges is that most real estate agents operate as independent contractors. This setup allows them to set their own schedules, which often means starting their day after watching The Today Show and choosing tasks based on what seems urgent or easy, not necessarily what is in the best interest of a long term sustainable business. Unfortunately, this often translates into avoidance of the uncomfortable work of selling—the calls, the door-knocking, and the honest, raw conversations with potential clients.

The problem? They don’t know what they don’t know. And because they’ve never been taught how to properly engage with prospects, they lean heavily on those canned dialogues and predictable role plays, convincing themselves that they’ve mastered the art of sales. Spoiler alert: they haven’t.

The Role-Playing Illusion

When agents role-play dialogues, the words and responses are so rehearsed and specific that they become robotic with only some getting to the point of making it sound natural. They think they’re learning to sell, but in reality, they’re learning to regurgitate. Sure, this tactic works for a select few who do it exceptionally well. But for the vast majority? It’s a crutch that leaves them floundering in real-life scenarios where authenticity and adaptability are required.

The Guru Problem

Another issue plaguing the industry is the overabundance of “real estate sales gurus.” Every week, there’s a new training, a new system, or a new “proven” method promising to turn agents into top producers. The result? Analysis paralysis. Agents bounce from one guru to another, never committing to mastering any one technique. They become jacks of all trades, masters of none—all while struggling to close deals and build sustainable businesses.

The Brokerage Bottleneck

Compounding the problem is the fact that most brokerages operate with limited resources. Many rely on their high-producing agents to lead training sessions, assuming that success in sales automatically translates to an ability to teach. Spoiler alert: it doesn’t. The result? A room full of agents nodding along, taking notes, and asking questions they already know the answers to—only to leave the training room no better equipped than when they walked in.

Let’s Get Back to Basics

The solution? Get back to the fundamentals of sales. Real estate agents need to be trained and coached on how to:

1. Engage with people in an authentic way. Forget the scripts. Teach agents how to start genuine conversations that build trust from the first hello.
2. Identify and navigate smoke screens. Consumers are masters of misdirection, throwing up objections and half-truths to keep agents at arm’s length. Train agents to dig deeper, uncovering the real needs and motivations behind the words.
3. Position themselves as problem solvers. Selling isn’t about pushing products or services; it’s about providing solutions. Agents need to focus on bringing value to the table and guiding clients toward what they truly want and need.

The Truth Behind the Words

Here’s the hard truth: most consumers don’t trust real estate agents. They’ve been burned by pushy sales tactics and empty promises, so they approach every interaction with skepticism. The sooner an agent can cut through the smoke screens and uncover the truth, the sooner they can guide the conversation in a direction that builds trust and inspires the consumer to want to work with them.

This is where the magic happens. Real estate agents who understand the basics of sales—engaging authentically, listening actively, and solving problems—will stand out in an industry drowning in mediocrity. And guess what? They won’t need a script to do it.

Final Thoughts

Sales is sales. It’s time for the real estate industry to stop overcomplicating it with endless systems, scripts, and gurus. Instead, let’s focus on equipping agents with the foundational skills they need to connect, build trust, and close deals. Because at the end of the day, people don’t hire scripts. They hire humans they trust.

If you want to set up a free consultation to discuss custom training and coaching for your firm.

Interested in your Real Estate Strengths - Take this 5 minute assessment

If you are an agent or a leader and want one-on-one coaching.

For more from Joe Arnao and others, follow:

The Real Joe Show - Where real estate agents come to meet and share their experiences and strategies.