Why Plant-Based Milk May Not Be the Best Alternative to Dairy

In recent years, plant-based milk alternatives like almond, soy and oat milk have gained popularity as dairy-free options. This rise can be attributed to increasing concerns about lactose intolerance, dietary preferences like veganism, and misconceptions about the health benefits of plant-based products. While these alternatives are marketed as healthier and environmentally friendly, they may not always be the best option when compared to traditional dairy in terms of nutrition, sustainability, and health impact.

Nutritional Deficiencies

Most plant-based milks fall short in replicating the complete nutritional profile of dairy milk. While some are fortified with vitamins and minerals, they often miss out on essential nutrients naturally present in dairy.

• Protein Content: Cow's milk contains around 8 grams of high-quality, complete protein per cup, providing all nine essential amino acids. Most plant-based milks, except for soy milk, contain significantly less protein, typically between 1-3 grams per cup. Even though soy milk contains comparable protein, it lacks the digestibility and quality of dairy protein like casein and whey.
• Calcium Bioavailability: While many plant-based milks are fortified with calcium, the bioavailability is lower compared to dairy. The calcium in dairy is more easily absorbed by the body due to the presence of other co-factors like vitamin D and magnesium, naturally found in milk.
• Vitamin D: Dairy milk is often fortified with vitamin D, which plays a vital role in bone health and immune function. While some plant-based milks are fortified with vitamin D, the amounts vary widely, and they may not provide the same benefits due to differences in absorption.
• Other Nutrients: Dairy provides a range of essential nutrients, including vitamin B12, iodine, potassium, and phosphorus, which are crucial for various bodily functions, including thyroid health, energy production, and maintaining electrolyte balance. These nutrients are either absent or found in negligible amounts in most plant-based milks.

Processing and Additives

Plant-based milks undergo significant processing to mimic the texture and taste of dairy, often requiring additives and preservatives that may not be ideal for health.

• Emulsifiers and Thickeners: To achieve the creamy texture of dairy, plant-based milks frequently use emulsifiers like carrageenan, guar gum, or xanthan gum. While generally regarded as safe, some studies suggest that these additives may irritate the gut lining, potentially contributing to digestive issues and inflammation.
• Added Sugars: Many plant-based milks, especially flavored varieties, contain added sugars to improve taste. Excess sugar consumption can lead to a range of health problems, including obesity, insulin resistance, and metabolic syndrome. Even unsweetened versions may contain natural sugars that elevate blood sugar levels more rapidly than dairy milk, especially in the case of oat milk.
• Artificial Fortification: Fortifying plant-based milks with vitamins and minerals is a common practice to make up for their natural deficiencies. However, these synthetic vitamins are often not absorbed as efficiently as those naturally occurring in dairy products. Additionally, not all brands fortify their products consistently, leading to potential nutrient gaps.

Impact on Metabolic Health

From a metabolic health perspective, dairy may offer some advantages that plant-based alternatives fail to match.

• Insulin Response: Oat milk, one of the fastest-growing dairy alternatives, has a high glycemic index (GI) compared to cow's milk. This can lead to rapid spikes in blood sugar levels, which are particularly concerning for individuals with insulin resistance or diabetes. Almond milk has a lower GI but provides little nutritional value outside of its calcium fortification. Cow’s milk, due to its balanced carbohydrate, protein, and fat content, typically has a lower impact on blood sugar.
• Fat Composition: Dairy fats, particularly from grass-fed cows, contain beneficial fatty acids like conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) and omega-3 fatty acids, which support metabolic health, reduce inflammation, and may help in weight management. Plant-based milks, especially low-fat varieties, often lack these beneficial fats, and their fat profile tends to be dominated by omega-6 fatty acids, which in excess can contribute to inflammation.

Allergies and Sensitivities

While some individuals are lactose intolerant or allergic to dairy, switching to plant-based milk is not always the ideal solution for everyone. Many plant-based milks can trigger allergies or sensitivities of their own.

• Soy Allergies: Soy is a common allergen, and individuals with soy allergies cannot consume soy milk. Moreover, concerns about the estrogenic effects of phytoestrogens in soy have led some people to avoid it, particularly men and those with hormone-sensitive conditions.
• Nut Allergies: Almond, cashew, and other nut-based milks are unsuitable for individuals with tree nut allergies, limiting their options for safe dairy alternatives.
• Digestive Issues: Some people experience digestive discomfort when consuming plant-based milks with added thickeners, emulsifiers, or stabilizers. Additionally, plant-based milks made from legumes (like soy) or grains (like oats) contain anti-nutrients such as phytates and lectins, which may hinder nutrient absorption and contribute to digestive discomfort in sensitive individuals.

Environmental Considerations

One of the selling points for plant-based milks is their purported environmental benefits. While it is true that producing dairy has a higher carbon and water footprint, not all plant-based options are as sustainable as they seem.

• Almond Milk: Almond milk is one of the most popular dairy alternatives, but almond farming requires significant amounts of water. It takes approximately 1.1 gallons of water to grow a single almond, leading to concerns about water usage, particularly in drought-prone regions like California, where much of the world's almonds are grown.
• Soy Milk: While soy milk is relatively more sustainable in terms of water use, soy farming is often associated with deforestation and large-scale monoculture practices, leading to soil depletion, loss of biodiversity, and ecosystem imbalance.
• Oat Milk: Oat milk has a lower environmental impact compared to almonds, but oats are often treated with glyphosate, a controversial herbicide linked to potential health risks. Moreover, processing oats into milk consumes energy and involves various chemical treatments.

Conclusion

Milk has been a dietary staple for thousands of years, especially in regions like India, where dairy is a part of traditional food practices. Fermented dairy products such as yogurt and kefir are known for promoting gut health and strengthening the immune system. Milk from grass-fed cows, particularly in traditional farming, tends to be more nutrient-rich.

In contrast, plant-based milks are relatively new, often heavily processed, and designed to mimic dairy rather than serve as a natural alternative. For those focusing on metabolic health, natural dairy remains a more nutrient-dense and less processed option, whereas plant-based alternatives might introduce nutritional challenges.

References

• Dairy products: why they are good for health. Nestle Nutrition Institute Workshop Series, 76, 45-57. doi:10.1159/000354115
• Plant-based alternatives to milk. Journal of Food Science & Technology, 57(1), 135–147. doi:10.1007/s13197-019-04049-2
• Changes in intestinal tight junction permeability associated with industrial food additives explain the rising incidence of autoimmune disease. Autoimmunity Reviews, 14(6), 479-489. doi:10.1016/j.autrev.2015.01.009
• Effects of dairy products on glycemic control and insulin sensitivity: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled studies. Nutrients, 10(6), 714. doi:10.3390/nu10060714
• Food allergy: a review and update on epidemiology, pathogenesis, diagnosis, prevention, and management. Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, 141(1), 41-58. doi:10.1016/j.jaci.2017.11.003
• Conjugated linoleic acids as functional food: an insight into their health benefits. Nutrition & Metabolism, 6, 36. doi:10.1186/1743-7075-6-36
• Milk and meat in our diet: good or bad for health? Animal Frontiers, 1(2), 26-32. doi:10.2527/af.2011-0015

#health #nutrition #dairy #milk