Why perfect is the enemy of the (very) good in the energy transition

Why perfect is the enemy of the (very) good in the energy transition


I’ve always said that when it comes to innovation, perfect is the enemy of the (very) good.

At the recent World Economic Forum meeting at Davos, decarbonization technologies and the need to accelerate them was on the agenda. Given that I have been talking about this subject at APPEA and the World Gas Conference recently, I thought it apt to add my views.

In a nutshell, the Paris goals are achievable with the technologies that exist today, but we need to acknowledge that none of us can do it alone.

If we wait for silver bullet solutions we can miss the opportunities to make progress with what we already have. And as we sit and wait around for game-changing solutions to solve everything, it will ultimately lead to ‘game over’.

Take nuclear fusion for example. Some see this as something of a holy grail in energy. But it is unlikely to be deployed at scale before 2050, and we can’t afford to wait that long.

That’s why CCUS is so important. It offers an opportunity to make a difference now, in our transition to a low carbon system.

From 40 MTPA today, the IEA’s net zero emissions by 2050 pathway assesses that the world needs to capture 4 GT of CO2 by 2030 and 7.6 GT CO2 by 2050.

Put simply, by 2030, which is only 8 years away, we need to store 100 times more CO2 globally than we have already! Put this into the context of the recent IPCC report that frames this as ‘now or never’, achieving that goal is a very tall order.

But, the real change that needs to occur to deliver on its potential is not in the technology itself, but in the ecosystem that supports it.

And that’s where IOGP comes in. Working with a global Membership that develops good practice that can be instantly deployed, we believe we provide the shortest and fastest route to the adoption of tech innovation and recommended practice on the energy frontline.

To help CCUS (and hydrogen, another key technology) deliver on its promise we’re following three principles.

The first is collaboration, which is a prerequisite for innovation in our industry due to the complexity of the energy transition, and the fact that no one has all the answers.

Collaboration must go beyond the industry too. It requires policy makers and organisations working very closely together to define any remaining hurdles, identify the best technological solutions, and establish the most efficient financial supports.

Second is maintaining a multidisciplinary, portfolio approach given that the most attractive new solutions may be found at the interface of several different disciplines, such as between the energy and digital sectors.

As innovation can be an uncertain process, we also need to ensure that innovation policy frameworks are balanced between potentially competing sectors and approaches, and are accompanied by investment in basic research and robust intellectual property rules.

And finally we have flexibility.

Because the portfolio of low-carbon technologies may change as technology progresses and transition pathways evolve, and we need to continuously monitor and adapt to them.

That means we should never take a narrow view or place all our bets on only a few technologies, and risk losing out on other ideas that could really make a change.

The transition remains a challenging task, but I’m confident that if we stick to our principles and focus on delivering the already very good solutions available to us, rather than waiting for the perfect ideals of the future, we’ll get there much quicker.

Pierre Girard

Technical Director at Eni CCUS Holding | MD of Tellus CCS | MD of Bacton CCS | CCSA Board Member

2 年

Thanks for your blog. Interesting to find value adding collaborative approach whilst operating in a competitive environment and moving at the required pace … as it highly competitive as a result of scarce resources such as people (your recent blog), subsidies (still required in many case) or approach taken by the regulatory bodies. I would be keen to hear your thoughts, Iman Hill, on that point

回复

Wise words! If we can get past the politics and focus on solutions the world would be a better place.

The wisdom of experince Iman Hill is seen, within the three principles. Your leadership is creating a positive push, well done.

回复
Mike Chapplow

Mentor, Coach, Consultant, Energy Trading

2 年

One tragedy in this area is the market failures around Carbon Offsets, so much money flowing (enormous amounts) but not nearly enough directed at CCUS - it could have been scaled up and deployed by now if the flows were better focussed.

回复
Rob Colmer

International Communications | Corporate Affairs | Sustainability | Government Relations (Views posted are my own)

2 年

Very clear message Iman Hill. We need progress now and collaboration is key.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Iman Hill的更多文章

  • Reflecting on 2022

    Reflecting on 2022

    From the energy security challenge caused by the Russia-Ukraine conflict to the necessary battle against climate change…

    12 条评论
  • Another cause of the energy crisis and how it must be addressed

    Another cause of the energy crisis and how it must be addressed

    The energy crises we’ve witnessed during these last few months have generated more debate on the energy sector than at…

    29 条评论
  • Why failing to prioritize diversity, equity, and inclusion is scaring away talent

    Why failing to prioritize diversity, equity, and inclusion is scaring away talent

    It is no secret that the oil and gas industry has historically struggled with diversity issues. And while we’ve made…

    26 条评论
  • A clear direction in unclear times…

    A clear direction in unclear times…

    Like you, I have been gripped by the crisis in Ukraine. The invasion is a crime, the humanitarian situation a tragedy…

    2 条评论
  • Enough tunnel vision: time for policymakers to take the blinders off

    Enough tunnel vision: time for policymakers to take the blinders off

    When I joined IOGP last year, one of the biggest asks of our Association Members was to advocate more on their behalf…

    12 条评论
  • Trust is vital, but it’s worth nothing without action

    Trust is vital, but it’s worth nothing without action

    I was recently reading an article by the formidable Christiana Figueres on trust and couldn't agree more about her…

    1 条评论
  • A Brave New World for Oil and Gas

    A Brave New World for Oil and Gas

    When I think back to my first assignment on a North Sea platform, I remember being impressed by the incredible…

    9 条评论
  • To the Moon and Back!

    To the Moon and Back!

    Did you know that the sun’s mass is estimated to be 1.9885 x 1030 kilograms? Or that one “googol” is 10100, i.

    20 条评论
  • Part of the Solution...

    Part of the Solution...

    When the oil and gas industry says that we’re part of the solution to the global need to transition to lower carbon…

    42 条评论
  • Diversity, Equality and Inclusion is not a woman vs man thing....

    Diversity, Equality and Inclusion is not a woman vs man thing....

    Pleased to see a rise in the number of posts about women in business and industry. But I have a small personal…

    22 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了