Why Most YouTube Titles Fail (And How to Avoid It) | Jake Thomas

Jake Thomas, founder of Creator Hooks, a YouTube growth newsletter, shares his insights into why many YouTube titles fail and how to create more effective ones.

Jake, who almost lost his job due to his initial struggles with writing compelling titles, turned his experiences into a valuable resource for creators.

We are covering the key points from Jake’s discussion on the podcast, covering psychological principles, AB testing, and the importance of creativity and consistency in YouTube title creation.

Watch the full episode here

The Importance of Psychology in Title Writing

Jake emphasizes that understanding human psychology is at the core of creating successful YouTube titles. He points out that the most effective titles tap into three primary emotional triggers:

1. Curiosity: Titles that provoke curiosity by leaving viewers with unanswered questions or "open loops" can significantly increase click-through rates.
2. Fear: Titles that play on viewers' fears or anxieties, such as missing out on important information, also tend to perform well.
3. Desire: Titles that appeal to viewers' desires or aspirations can be powerful motivators for clicks.

He explains that while the specific wording of successful titles may change over time, the underlying psychological triggers remain consistent.

Mastering these principles can help creators not only with YouTube titles but also with other forms of content like thumbnails, emails, and social media posts.

Common Mistakes in YouTube Titles

According to Jake, many new YouTubers make similar mistakes when creating titles, which can lead to poor performance. These include:

• Being too vague or generic: Titles that are too broad or fail to convey a clear benefit or hook often fail to attract clicks.
• Overusing clickbait tactics: While clickbait can initially draw attention, it can backfire if the content doesn’t deliver on the promise, leading to viewer frustration and lower engagement.
• Ignoring the value of curiosity: Not creating a curiosity gap—leaving viewers with a sense of wanting to know more—can result in a title that doesn’t entice clicks.

Jake emphasizes that a deep understanding of these pitfalls, combined with the strategic use of psychological triggers, can help creators avoid these common issues and improve their titles' effectiveness.

The Role of AB Testing in Improving Titles

AB testing is a critical tool in the title-creation process. AB testing allows creators to compare different versions of titles and thumbnails to see which ones perform better. This data-driven approach can provide valuable insights into what resonates with a specific audience.

Jake shares his method for AB testing:

• Start with proven strategies: Begin by using titles and thumbnails that have been successful in the past, either within your niche or in other areas.
• Experiment with emotions: Test titles that emphasize different emotional triggers, such as curiosity, fear, or desire, to see which ones drive the most engagement.
• Analyze and iterate: Use the results of your AB tests to refine your understanding of what works and continuously improve your title-writing skills.

He notes that AB testing is not just about optimizing individual videos but also about gaining a deeper understanding of your audience's preferences, which can inform future content strategies.

The Power of Evergreen Strategies

Trends in title creation may evolve, certain strategies remain effective over time.

Jake refers to these as "evergreen strategies"—approaches that consistently work across different contexts and niches. For example, titles that focus on specific time frames or those that hint at unexpected results tend to perform well, regardless of the niche.

Jake advises creators to look at successful titles from other niches and adapt them to their own content. This approach, which Jake calls the "DJ Khaled method," involves remixing proven titles to fit your niche, thereby leveraging successful formulas in a new context.

The Art of Creating Curiosity Gaps

One of the most effective strategies is the creation of curiosity gaps.

This technique involves crafting titles that leave viewers with unanswered questions or a sense of mystery, compelling them to click to satisfy their curiosity.

This can be done subtly, without resorting to overtly clickbaity tactics. For instance, instead of saying "You'll never believe what happened next," a title might simply suggest that something unexpected occurred, encouraging viewers to find out more.

This technique can also be applied within the video content itself, with creators introducing small mysteries or cliffhangers throughout the video to maintain viewer engagement.

Leveraging AI Tools for Title Creation

Jake has developed an AI-powered title generator as part of Creator Hooks, designed to help creators quickly generate effective YouTube titles. This tool is based on a database of over a thousand successful titles and allows users to select specific emotional triggers (e.g., curiosity, fear, desire) to craft titles tailored to their content.

The AI analyzes patterns in successful titles and suggests new ones that are likely to perform well based on these proven strategies. This tool helps creators streamline the title creation process, saving time while increasing the likelihood of success.

Sign up here

The Importance of Credibility in Titles

Titles that convey personal experience or authority (e.g., "How I Made $1M in 2024") tend to perform better than more generic "how-to" titles. This is because viewers are more likely to click on content that they perceive as coming from a credible source with real-world experience.

This approach is particularly important in an era where AI-generated content is becoming more prevalent. As viewers become more discerning, authenticity and credibility are increasingly valuable assets for creators.

Evolving Trends in Content and Titles

We are observing a shift in the YouTube landscape towards more authentic and slower-paced content. This trend is reflected in both video editing and title creation, with creators moving away from overly complex or clickbaity tactics in favor of simpler, more genuine approaches.

He suggests that this trend may be driven by a broader cultural desire for realism and authenticity, as viewers become weary of highly polished, artificial content. As a result, titles that reflect this shift toward authenticity are likely to become more effective.

Future Directions for Creator Hooks

Looking ahead, Jake plans to continue refining and expanding the tools offered by Creator Hooks. This includes developing new features for the title generator, such as a Chrome extension that will allow users to generate titles directly from YouTube videos.

While Jake is open to exploring new areas, such as thumbnail text, his primary focus remains on helping creators come up with better ideas and write more effective titles. He believes that by staying focused on this core area, Creator Hooks can provide the most value to its users.

Want to work with me to grow your business?

If you’re a 7-8-figure founder or agency that wants to grow your YouTube channel, membership, and course — I’d love to work with you.

For 6-figure+ founders and channels, join an exclusive group with 5,500,000+ total subscribers.

3) Sponsor our newsletter

Get access to founders, agencies, course creators, community builder and more...