Why Most of Your Staff Start the Year Looking to Leave

Here's a hard truth that needs to be said: The way most companies handle year-end performance reviews is a masterclass in disengagement. It's no wonder 86% of your staff are starting the year not energized and motivated, but disengaged and eyeing the exit. The fault lies not with them, but with a deeply flawed system and, frankly, leadership that's asleep at the wheel.

The Delusion of High Performance

Let's get real: Many of your staff think they're acing it, but in reality, they're clueless about what true high performance is. Why? Because you, the leaders, haven't set clear goals. It's like throwing someone in the ocean and blaming them for not swimming a perfect stroke. Set clear, achievable goals throughout the year, or stop wondering why your employees are lost in the sea of performance metrics.

The Manager's Myopic Viewpoint

Relying solely on a manager's feedback for performance assessments? That's narrow-minded and outdated. Studies show that manager-only feedback rates employees 14% lower than more rounded peer reviews. If you're still stuck in this echo chamber of managerial perspective, you're not just out of touch; you're part of the problem.

The Ghost Town of Feedback

Here's a brutal reality check: Most managers are failing at giving regular, constructive feedback. It's not rocket science; employees need to know where they stand more than just twice a year. If you're not having these conversations regularly, don't act shocked when your employees feel blindsided and demotivated at year-end.

The Backward Glance That Kills Morale

If your performance reviews are just autopsy reports of what went wrong, congratulations on creating a culture of negativity. Forward-thinking companies focus on future growth and development in their reviews. It's time to stop the backward-looking blame game and start building a path forward.

The Promotion Policy Farce

And let's talk about those laughable promotion policies. You're telling top performers they can't move up because of some arbitrary timeline or quota? That's not just demoralizing; it's absurd. You're essentially punishing your best talent for being too good, too soon. Don't be surprised when they decide to be 'too good' for another employer.

Conclusion

It's high time for a wake-up call. The annual performance review process is broken, and it's driving your best talent away. Fix it by setting clear goals, embracing broader feedback, offering regular constructive criticism, focusing on future growth, and revising your promotion policies. Or keep ignoring these truths at your own peril. Remember, in today’s job market, your top talent has options – and your competitors are just a LinkedIn message away.

Exciting news! My latest book Change Catalysts: Leading Against All Odds is now available globally on Amazon. In a world where approximately 70% of transformations fail, this book is your guide to beating the odds and achieving success. It's packed with strategies, real-life case studies, and essential insights to navigate the complex landscape of change.

Also, explore my other international bestselling books:

• The Employee Handbook: A Practical Guide for Managing Your Career
• The Manager Handbook: A Practical Guide to Managing Your Team
• The Talent Acquisition Handbook: A Practical Guide to Candidate Experience
• The HR Handbook: A Practical Guide to Employee Experience

Check out my podcast, "A Practical Guide to..." available on:

• YouTube
• Spotify
• Apple Podcasts

And don't forget to visit my website at LeeNallalingham.com for hundreds of free articles like this one.

Thanks for your support!