Why modern companies think about doughnuts and lungs
NASA’s Earth Observatory: https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/147840/snow-free-glaciers-in-winter

Why modern companies think about doughnuts and lungs

The concept of cause and effect is one of the earliest concepts we learn: touch the kettle, suffer an owie. Bother Mom when she's on a video call, earn a hard stare. Annoy the god Vulcan, get buried for centuries under an angry pyroclastic flow.

But the world is so much more complex and interrelated. Even when we try to do the "right thing," results can veer disastrously away from what was intended.

For example, introducing maternity leave can seem like exactly the right thing a progressive business (in the U.S.) or government (rest of the world) should do. Yet, a 2018 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology found that a one year maternity leave actually harmed women's careers (spoiler alert: paternal leave is the solution)*.

The mad pace of technology - and frankly, some thoughtless self-importance - is particularly troublesome. As WSJ wrote a year ago about the congestion-increasing effects of ride hailing firms: "The reversal of ride-hailing from would-be traffic hero to congestion villain is the sort of unintended consequence that has become a recurring feature of Silicon Valley disruption."

We desperately need to move away from one-dimensional cause-effect thinking and approach business to a more systems-thinking approach.

This is what a modern company does.

From/To

When we think of how a company moves through time and space, we often think in terms of "people, process, technology," a term that Harold Leavitt, one of the early researchers on the discipline of management, coined in 1964**.

people process technology

The idea was that you needed to address all three to achieve operational efficiency and manage change in an organisation.

At the time, technology was considered the set of tools people used: they were usually discrete tools fashioned for specific purposes. Processes describe how something gets done. They existed to reinforce uniformity and consistency. And of course, people were the ones using the tools, and going through the processes. They were the units of production.

Soon after, more really smart people formulated ways to approach business strategy, with constructs such as the GE/McKinsey Nine-Block and Porter's Five Forces Model.

strategy, people, process, technology

These helped orient the three legs of the PPT stool to a particular set of goals, usually having to do with dominating a particular market.

So far, so familiar, right?

But this is classic cause-effect thinking confined to a narrow set of outcomes.

When you think of what companies must navigate these days, from the delicacy of managing social media influencers to the increased supply-chain scrutiny of how goods are made, it becomes clear a more holistic approach is needed. Specifically:

  • Technology is no longer merely a discrete set of foundational tools, often maintained by a cadre of specialists, but present and pervasive throughout all facets of the organisation. This is acutely felt as many of us all wrestle daily with remote working tools.
  • Processes can no longer mandate uniformity and consistency: their evolved role is to imbue an organisation with adaptability and flexibility, to make it resilient in the face of unexpected change.
  • People are no longer units of production - most of that work has been automated - but catalysts of creativity, able to think of new and better ways of doing things. (Though it seems daringly revolutionary now, companies like John Lewis and Bob's Red Mill have long shared profits with all employees, not just senior executives. Jamie Mitchell argues persuasively for the concept of intentional contribution in his article on building progressive businesses.)
  • Strategy must expand beyond the narrow view of the market into the broader ecosystem, both in the literal sense of ecological impact and in the conceptual sense of operating within a larger society whose members (Tik-tok influencers?) may form an opinion independently of a company's direct efforts. Strategy thus moves from long-term planning into a more iterative and opportunistic form that affords quick pivots. Kate Raworth's Doughnut Economics is an excellent economic framework for companies to expand strategy thinking beyond markets.

The idea is that because everything exists in an interdependent state, the aim of fulfilling wants is often at odd with the resources of the planet. As with attention, we exist in a finite, perpetually recycling state.

42

On top of the operational and strategy work, a modern company deliberately and thoughtfully crafts a culture that it wants to have. Most large companies that came of age in the 1900s basically reflected the culture of their leader, whether that was Herb Kelleher at Southwest Airlines or Albert Dunlap, better known as Chainsaw Al.

But the modern company stops and thinks. It looks at history. It looks at psychology and sociology. Sometimes, this results in a deliberate Lord of the Flies approach, and you get Travis Kalanick's Uber. Done right, though, shaping a deliberate culture, one that is diverse and inclusive, yields abundant dividends, including the financial kinds.

If companies can think of themselves as part of a vast, beautiful, and complex organic structure, it then begs the question of, why are we here?

A modern company ponders its purpose. It's gone beyond signing Business Roundtable statements and is contemplating (or has attained) B-Corp status. It knows implicitly that employee experience is the top driver of customer experience. It seizes on the outsized impact that business has in a capitalist world, and acts as a force for good for society and the planet.

Modern business

So, um, what's that about lungs?

As Brooke Jarvis wrote in the New Yorker article, "What happens when you breathe," our lungs are "open, like a wound, to the outside world." Our air is a communal space, one that is at once highly personal and global. Your exhalation is my inhalation.

Our breath is also intimately connected to the world, part of the water cycle: when you blow on a window pane, the water in that condensate may have dribbled, on its way from glacier to sea, past a snow leopard.

Businesses, one of the most powerful forces in the world today, are inextricably intertwined in this system. The problems of the world are the problems of a business. A modern company doesn't just understand that, it actively—joyfully, even—works to heal, renew, and secure our shared future.

---------

* When fathers took parental leave, outcomes improved for society overall, not just for women. Win-win.

** The paper, entitled "Applied Organization Change in Industry," originally posited four areas but has since been condensed into three.

(Thanks to Simon Erdmann and Jamie Mitchell for helping refine the thinking that went into this piece.)

Ingrid Hesser

C-level Executive - Communications - Sustainable Development. Expert in connecting Individual, technology and change.

3 å¹´

Just like humans being strongest when daring to show vulnerability are companies when daring to stop the “back to growth”-mantra and refocus on a B-corp approach. So many thoughts @Irene. Sorry but I have to admit I am deeply concerned for the slow pace and dragged feet.

Love this Irene.. Thanks for sharing!

Charlotte Aspeheim Schmidt

Content and communications expert with focus on IT transformational topics; Passionate about story telling and show production

4 å¹´

Thank you! I had to read it a couple of times and let it sink it. "The problems of the world are the problems of a business." Babies, companies, humans, forrests - let's try take to take it all into consideration.

Jamie Mitchell

Chairman, NED, Advisor | serial-CEO and founder

4 å¹´

This is a brilliant and insightful article, bringing together in one simple framework all the positive changes we are seeing inside progressive businesses today. I’ve already borrowed this framework (badly I’m afraid) for a pre-recorded speech I’m giving to a charities conference on purpose-driven collaborations. Thanks Irene.

Great, thought provoking article!

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Irene Sandler的更多文章

  • On a scale of 1 to 10, how would you rate this article?

    On a scale of 1 to 10, how would you rate this article?

    We've recently moved house. And along with a move comes a flurry of services, like broadband installation, washing…

    13 条评论
  • A shot on goal: the Super League's cautionary tale for corporations

    A shot on goal: the Super League's cautionary tale for corporations

    The spectacular demise of the so-called Super League in a span of 48 hours is more than just a story of the little guys…

    7 条评论
  • 2021 Will Not Save Us

    2021 Will Not Save Us

    We humans love our milestones, our round numbers. A tenth wedding anniversary seems more worth celebrating than an…

    12 条评论
  • Have we hit "Peak Global"? A peek ahead.

    Have we hit "Peak Global"? A peek ahead.

    The universe may be expanding, but Earth isn’t. Between air travel, fiber optics, and the Internet, the world has been…

    5 条评论
  • The Seven Stages of Remote Working

    The Seven Stages of Remote Working

    Trending on Twitter is the remark that Shakespeare wrote King Lear while self-quarantined during the plague in 1606. No…

    2 条评论
  • Going slow in the digital age

    Going slow in the digital age

    If there's one thing that characterizes our modern life, it's speed. Our default is "faster is better," from browser…

    1 条评论
  • A Purpose-Driven Corporation Begins with Purpose-Driven People

    A Purpose-Driven Corporation Begins with Purpose-Driven People

    For Chinese New Year last year, I wrote about five work resolutions, mostly because I’m terrible at keeping personal…

    2 条评论
  • The Illusion of the Separation of Business and State

    The Illusion of the Separation of Business and State

    One of the best part of the holidays is taking the time to rifle through old-ish issues of magazines that have gathered…

    1 条评论
  • Delicate (re)cycle: tough times for the sharing economy

    Delicate (re)cycle: tough times for the sharing economy

    Alas, all honeymoons come to an end. And so it seems to be for Sharing Economy 1.

    2 条评论
  • The Internet of Sustainable Things

    The Internet of Sustainable Things

    Well, I’ll be. The Internet of Things (IoT) is all grown up now and entering the Plateau of Productivity, for those of…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了