Why Leaders Need to Embrace Smart Failures

Join 7,129+ other CEOs, Founders and Entrepreneurs . Every week, I share actionable ideas and frameworks to help you unlock outsized growth for yourself, your teams, and your business. Don't forget to follow me or my page for more insights every day.

In my experience working with CEOs across various industries, I've observed a concerning trend - many leaders are unintentionally fostering cultures of silence within their organisations.

A Harvard Business Review study revealed a startling statistic – a staggering 85% of employees withhold their ideas due to fear of ridicule or punishment. This is a massive missed opportunity.

Think about it. If your team is constantly worried about being shut down, how likely are they to bring you their most innovative ideas? How comfortable will they feel taking calculated risks that could lead to breakthroughs?

The answer is clear. Fear stifles creativity and innovation. It prevents your organisation from reaching its full potential.

But what's the alternative? I want to propose a different approach, one that prioritises psychological safety.

The Cornerstone of High-Performing Teams

Psychological safety, pioneered by Harvard professor Amy Edmondson, refers to an environment where employees feel safe to take risks, share ideas, and admit mistakes without fear of negative consequences. It's about creating a space where open communication, healthy debate, and learning from failures are encouraged.

This might seem counterintuitive. Shouldn't we be striving for perfection? Don't we want a culture of high achievement? Absolutely. But achieving excellence requires a willingness to experiment, push boundaries, and, yes, even fail sometimes.

Here's the distinction. Psychological safety doesn't mean condoning recklessness or incompetence. It's about fostering an environment where calculated risks are encouraged, and mistakes are seen as learning opportunities, not reasons for blame.

The benefits of psychological safety are numerous. Studies have shown that teams with high psychological safety experience:

• Increased innovation and creativity
• Improved problem-solving abilities
• Stronger collaboration and teamwork
• Enhanced employee engagement and morale
• Increased productivity and performance

So, how do we create this kind of environment? Here are some practical steps leaders can take:

• Reward Experimentation, Not Just Success.?We often celebrate success stories, but what about the attempts that didn't quite hit the mark? Start recognising and rewarding "smart failures" – those calculated risks that didn't pay off in the end but generated valuable learnings. This sends a clear message that experimentation and exploration are valued.
• Embrace Open Communication.?Make it clear that open communication is a two-way street. Encourage employees to ask questions, share their ideas, and voice concerns. Actively listen to their input and be open to feedback, even when it's critical.
• Focus on Solutions, Not Blame.?Let's face it, mistakes happen. The important thing is how we respond to them. When things go wrong, shift the focus away from assigning blame and towards finding solutions together. Use the opportunity to learn from the mistake and prevent it from happening again.
• Lead by Example.?Leaders set the tone for the entire organisation. Be a role model for psychological safety by demonstrating your own willingness to admit mistakes, take risks, and learn from setbacks.
• Create Safe Spaces for Sharing.?Consider implementing anonymous suggestion boxes or surveys to allow employees to share ideas and concerns without fear of repercussions. Hold regular team meetings where open discussion is encouraged, and establish ground rules for respectful communication.

Building psychological safety takes time and effort. It's about establishing trust with your team. Here's how:

• Be Consistent.?Your words and actions must be aligned. Employees will quickly pick up on the disconnect if you say you value open communication but then shut down dissenting voices.
• Be Transparent.?Share information openly with your team, even when it's not easy news. Transparency builds trust and demonstrates that you respect them enough to keep them informed.
• Be Approachable.?Make yourself available to your team. Hold regular office hours, encourage open-door policies, and actively seek out their feedback.
• Show Appreciation.?Recognise and appreciate your team's contributions, both big and small. This creates a positive and supportive work environment where people feel valued.

Companies that foster psychological safety will be better positioned to attract and retain top talent, solve complex problems, and seize new opportunities.

Beyond the Numbers: A Human Story

Let me share a real-world example. I once worked with a tech startup client whose CEO had a very hierarchical leadership style. Employees were hesitant to share ideas for fear of being ridiculed. This resulted in a stifled work environment and a lack of innovation. We helped the CEO implement strategies to build psychological safety. He started by holding regular team meetings where open discussion was encouraged. He also made it a point to recognise and reward "smart failures." The impact was significant. Employees became more engaged, creativity soared, and the company developed a new product that became a success story.

This is just one example, but it highlights the transformative power of psychological safety. It's not just about numbers and statistics - it's about creating a work environment where people feel valued, empowered, and inspired to do their best work.

Moving Forward

Leaders have a responsibility to create an environment where their teams can thrive. By prioritising psychological safety, you can unlock the full potential of your workforce and drive your organisation towards long-term success. Here are some questions to consider as you move forward:

• How can I create a more open and trusting environment for my team?
• What steps can I take to encourage healthy debate and risk-taking?
• How can I better recognise and reward "smart failures"?

By taking action on these questions, you can start building a culture of psychological safety within your organisation. Remember, it's not about creating a utopia. It's about creating an environment where people feel comfortable being themselves, learn from their mistakes, and are empowered to contribute their best ideas. IMO this is the foundation for a truly high-performing team.