Why Justin Trudeau’s Departure Was a Mistake for Canada

Justin Trudeau’s decision to step down has left many Canadians grappling with mixed emotions. While it may have been the best choice for him personally, and I get it, the move raises serious questions about Canada’s political future. Here are five reasons why his departure could be considered a significant mistake:

1. A Broken Promise to Supporters

Trudeau’s departure feels like a letdown to those who voted for him, supported his vision, and still believe in his leadership. His supporters rallied behind a leader who promised progressive values and a more inclusive Canada. Stepping down leaves a vacuum that might not be easily filled. For many of us, "There is a sense of lost hope; especially for a group of voters that wanted to see him live out the extension of his father's legacy—the immigrants that make up the fabric of Canada" (female interlocutor).

2. A Legacy of Achievements

While critics are quick to throw stones, they should remember, that they too, live in a glass house. That said, Mr. Trudeau's leadership has brought significant wins for Canada. From negotiating trade agreements like the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) to tackling climate change with a carbon tax, to legalizing recreational cannabis to championing diversity and inclusion, his achievements are undeniable. The U.S.—Canada alliance has never been stronger, and we have Justin Trudeau to thank for it. Few others in Canadian politics have demonstrated the same level of vision and determination.

3. Mistakes Are Part of Leadership

Leaders are not perfect, and Mr. Trudeau is no exception. Every politician makes a few missteps; they are part of the political process and shouldn't overshadow a strong track record. History often remembers leaders for their overall impact, not just their mistakes.

4. Haters Will Always Hate

No leader escapes criticism, especially in an era dominated by polarizing rhetoric. Pundits and polls often reflect biases, and their agendas shouldn’t dictate a leader’s legacy or force them to quit. His staunchest critics, many of whom, have been vocal since day one, will find something to hate no matter what.

5. Fuel for the Trolls

Trudeau’s decision inadvertently gave his detractors, including Trump and the trolls, a platform to gloat. It’s ironic given that Mr. Trudeau's departure had nothing to do with them. The sad part is, America is already taking credit for him stepping down. In fact, he didn’t even mention them in his step-down speech.

In Conclusion

Trudeau’s departure marks the end of an era, leaving Canada at a crossroads. Notwithstanding, the contrast between Canadian and American politics is stark: while Canada faces a leadership shake-up, the U.S. is battling deeper crises, from climate disasters to deep political discord. As America struggles with her own turmoil, the "gulf" of flame in Los Angeles and the "state" of her affairs, Canada needs a leader with a vision that goes beyond the noise of pundits and trolls. Currently, there is no one who can do a better job for Canada than Mr. Trudeau. He had the vision and the chutzpah. Let's see who else is out there.

Maclean’s magazine CBC GlobalNews Group CNN CTV News