Why “Just do it”, just doesn’t do it anymore; Autonomy and the workplace

Growing or even just staying competitive, businesses must create environments that encourage proactive behaviour among employees. Proactive employees drive innovation and efficiency, helping companies adapt quickly to market changes and emerging opportunities.. Let's delve deeper into how businesses can cultivate a culture that encourages and thrives on proactive behaviors.

?

What Kills Autonomy in the Workplace?

?

Here are the pervasive factors that I’ve observed while in business and while consulting to business which can erode this autonomy, leading to a suppressed and unproductive work environment.

Micromanagement represses; When managers closely monitor and control every aspect of how experienced and motivated employees perform their tasks, it sends a loud message of distrust and lack of confidence, repressing autonomy. This approach demoralizes most skilled and motivated staff despite being necessary when they are new. And is leads to decreased initiative and reluctance to propose innovative solutions as the employees become experienced. I have experience of an operations manager who insists on approving every minor task in a project, from email drafts to meeting agendas, for staff who are two or three years into the role. This not only impedes the workflow within the office, delays decision-making, but also discourages team members from using their judgment or skills to solve most problems efficiently.

Rigid Policy and Procedure stifles; While structure is necessary for any organization, overly rigid policies and procedures can significantly restrict employee autonomy. When workers are bound by strict guidelines that dictate every action (with sanctions for not following such policies), there is little room for creativity or adaptation to new challenges. For instance, another organisation I know has a fixed procedure for handling external consultants that requires multiple layers of approvals before any action can be taken, despite the fact that there has been a six-year relationship established. Such rigidity can prevent employees from addressing issues promptly and can deter them from coming up with or implementing innovative solutions that might better serve the company and its clients.

Insufficient Resource chokes; Autonomy is also undermined when employees do not have access to the necessary resources, such as information, tools, or managerial support. This lack of support can make employees feel helpless and less likely to take the initiative. Consider a scenario in which support staff are given the freedom to design a new approach but are not provided with adequate access to clients to ensure the appropriate outcomes and quick agreement on design. The desire and ability to innovate and execute projects is compromised, leading to frustration and a potential failure to meet client goals.

Intolerance smothers; a leader’s intolerance of genuine mistakes can kill employee autonomy by creating a fear-based environment on inertia. When employees are penalized for well-meant failure, especially those that stem from genuine innovation, it discourages others from trying out new approaches. A sales team that is discouraged from deviating from traditional B2B sales process, even if a more personalized approach would be more effective in certain circumstances. Such a culture stifles experimentation and learning, which are critical components of growth and improvement.

Bureaucracy oppresses; by making excessive difficulties for employees to implement changes or take swift action. Examples can include extensive paperwork (especially unnecessary legalese, unnecessary meetings, in the name of inclusion and collaboration or convoluted hierarchical approval processes that delay action. For instance, if a client manager identifies a quicker method for processing customer orders for existing clients who need speedy delivery but must go through several levels of management for approval, dims the potential for rapid innovation and improvement is lost.

Each of these factors not only kills autonomy but also impacts overall employee morale and productivity.

?

What are the Foundations of Proactivity

?Creating a proactive workplace begins with establishing the right preconditions. These foundational elements set the stage for employees to feel empowered and motivated to take initiative.

Mutual trust between managers and employees is essential for overcoming challenges to autonomy in the workplace. Trust enables managers to feel confident in delegating responsibilities and empowers employees to act independently without fear of undue criticism or failure.

The first step in building this trust hinges on both the managers and the subordinates mutual perception of ability the workplace. Employees need to trust that their managers are capable and have the organizational skills necessary to lead and have that personal concerns are considered, while managers must believe that their employees have the skills and competence to handle tasks effectively. When both parties feel confident in each other's abilities, autonomy naturally increases, allowing for more creativity and innovation.?

To build trust in subordinates, a manager must also demonstrate integrity, which involves consistency, fairness, and transparency in actions and decisions. Integrity assures employees that their manager's actions align with their words and the values of the organization, creating a safe and predictable environment. For example, a boss who consistently acknowledges the contributions of team members and gives credit where it’s due fosters a sense of fairness and respect. This encourages employees to engage more openly and take initiatives, knowing that their efforts will be recognized and valued fairly.

Benevolence, showing genuine concern for the welfare of subordinates and for the organisation and its outcomes, is the third pillar. This aspect of trust can be nurtured by being approachable, actively listening to employee concerns, and supporting their professional growth. A manager who invests time in understanding the career aspirations of their team members and provides opportunities for them to develop necessary skills not only builds trust but also motivates employees to contribute proactively to the organization. The subordinate must also convey through their actions that they understand and appreciate the vision and values of the organisation and are aligned with agreed outcomes. Such a supportive environment encourages risk-taking and autonomy because employees feel secure that their boss will support them, even when mistakes are made, viewing them as opportunities for learning rather than occasions for reprimand.

?

Next stage in building proactivity - beyond Trust

1. Autonomy: Empowering employees with the freedom to dictate their workflow and make decisions can lead to significant improvements in creativity and engagement. It's important to trust that your team members know how to manage their responsibilities and to give them the space to prove it. When given the ability to make choices I have seen experienced if junior support staff rise to the occasion to make thoughtful and essential decisions quickly.

2. Responsibility: When individuals are made to feel accountable not just for completing tasks but also for the outcomes, they are propelled to exceed expectations. This sense of responsibility can drive employees to seek solutions proactively rather than waiting for direction.

3. Self-Efficacy: Confidence in one's ability to effect change is critical. Through ongoing training and positive reinforcement, businesses can foster a sense of competence among their staff. When employees believe in their capabilities, they are more likely to undertake challenging tasks and commit to seeing them through successfully.

?

Proactive Behaviours to recognize and reward

With the right foundations in place, fostering specific proactive behaviors becomes the next step. These behaviors are the building blocks of a dynamic and adaptive workforce.

- Personal Initiative: Encourage your employees to not just do their jobs but to look for ways to do them better. This means going beyond their formal roles and responsibilities to improve the business. Leadership should regularly communicate that initiative is valued and provide platforms for sharing innovative ideas.

- Voice: Develop mechanisms for employees to safely and constructively express their ideas and concerns. This could be through regular feedback sessions, suggestion boxes, or open forums. Ensuring that these voices are heard and acknowledged will reinforce a culture of openness and mutual respect.

- Initiating: Recognize and reward those who proactively address issues and spearhead new initiatives. This reinforces a culture where taking action is appreciated and celebrated. It also sets a precedent for other employees to follow.

?

Sustained Impact on Organizational Outcomes

The ultimate goal of encouraging proactivity is to enhance organizational outcomes; autonomy significantly contributes to;

- Innovation: Proactive behaviours lead to the generation of new ideas, which can translate into innovative products, services, or processes. Innovation keeps businesses competitive and can lead to market leadership.

- Outcome Performance: With employees actively seeking to improve their performance and contribute to organizational goals, overall outcome related job performance metrics tend to rise (rather than process related input metrics). Managers should aim to objectively measure these improvements through both observation and performance reviews and customer engagement.

?- Job Satisfaction & Commitment: Employees who feel they can impact their work environment and are encouraged to be proactive generally report higher job satisfaction. This, in turn, increases their commitment to the company, reducing turnover rates and fostering a loyal workforce.

?

?Conclusion

Fostering a proactive workplace is about more than just encouraging employees to take initiative; it's about creating an ecosystem that supports and rewards such behaviors. This white paper outlines a framework that business leaders can adapt to cultivate a proactive culture within their organizations.? Let's not just manage our teams—let's inspire and empower them to take charge and innovate. What are your experiences with fostering proactivity in your organization? Share your stories and insights in the comments below to further this discussion.

Les Buckley; August 2024?

---

Sources:

Mayer, R.C., Davis, J.H., & Schoorman, F.D. (1995). An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust.?Academy of Management Review, 20(3), 709-734?

Pink, D., (2009) Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us

Thomas, J. P.. Whitman, D. S. & Viswesvaran, C. (2010). Employee proactivity in organizations: A comparative meta-analysis of emergent proactive constructs. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology. 83(2).

Tornau, K., & Frese, M. (2013). Construct clean-up in proactivity research: A meta-analysis on the nomological net of work-related proactivity concepts and their incremental validities. Applied Psychology. 62(1), 44-96.