Why the investment business is so frustrating

Why the investment business is so frustrating

Wall Street Journal:

BOSTON— Jack Meyer trounced rivals when he ran Harvard University’s endowment in the 1990s. But as a hedge-fund manager, he is struggling.
His Convexity Capital Management LP has lost $1 billion of its clients’ money over the last few years as once reliable options trades backfired. Investors pulled more than $3.5 billion from the bond shop last year, its fifth down year in a row. The firm laid off a tenth of its staff in recent months.

This is one of the most frustrating aspects of the investment management business. Performance does not persist and strategies, upon becoming successful, can often start to fail once enough imitators show up or the market wizens up about someone keeping a big, giant edge to themselves. Almost no one has been able to keep their edge in this game over the years. It's weird that investors expect this kind of persistence from hot managers when they have so many examples in the world outside of finance that demonstrate how unrealistic this sort of thing is.

Let's just mention professional athletes, as an example. For obvious reasons, investing in Kobe or Jeter after 15 years of stellar performance wouldn't make any sense to anyone. Why do we think a fund manager's track record would be any more relevant?

The best managers have been the most adaptable. Warren Buffett went from owning passive stakes in high quality blue chip companies to acquiring them outright (see Burlington Northern Railroad). Then he moved on to becoming a private equity partner in the LBOs of others (see Heinz). Carl Icahn went from options market guru to activist hedge fund. But activism got crowded, so now he's adapted. The new strategy appears to be making friends with the President of the United States and pushing for favorable regulatory changes to enhance the value of public companies he owns (see CVR Energy). Carl and Warren have been finding new edges and opportunities for decades and decades, but they are exceptional.

Not all investors have the capability of adapting their strategies. Most are more likely to stick to what they're doing until it stops working, and then they keep going anyway. You can convince institutional investors that you've made money for that you're only cyclically (temporarily) out of favor for a long time before they give up on you, especially if you're a name brand.

Even if you do attempt to adapt, there's no guarantee it will work. Lots of long-short hedge fund kings have been unable to generate the type of reliable alpha that has been legislated out of existence by the onset of Reg FD (Fair Disclosure). It just took a decade or so for this to become apparent. And in the meantime, their pivots into macro strategies have been mostly disastrous.

When you're looking at the performance record of a firm like Renaissance Technologies, it's tempting to believe that they've built an unstoppable alpha machine that could run itself, it's so consistent. But this is hardly the case. Every day there are hundreds of PhDs and other assorted geniuses showing up to their cabin in the woods to keep coming up with new edges. Because the old ones eventually stop working. There are no alpha machines, there are only tools and systems that may allow them to find alpha somewhere new.

This is not the sort of enterprise in which thousands of professionals and organizations will thrive. There simply isn't enough room. It's a small, rarified world with enormous potential rewards being chased by millions. Maintaining an edge is unrealistic, but finding new edges on a regular basis may be even more unrealistic.

Former Harvard Money Whiz Jack Meyer Tries to Regain Midas Touch (Wall Street Journal)

Bob Askey

Wealthy, retired. Leadership skills, financial skills, advisory skills. Living large, aging gracefully.

7 年

I hope that you outlaw J M DEVASHI from posting his distracting and self-serving Ratan Steel Industries info in your comments section. Your article resonated with me, but that Devashish comment spoiled it.

回复
David Stern, CPA

President & CEO Flex Card LLC

7 年

Joshua - great read. Thanks for posting

回复
J M DEVASHI

OWNER at RATAN STEEL INDUSTRIES

7 年

STAINLESS STEEL TUBES, PIPES - SEAMLESS WELDED, PIPE FITTINGS, SHEETS PLATES, FLATS, RODS, WIRES, STRIPS IN THE GRADE OF 304, 304L, 316, 316L, 316TI, 309, 310 & 410. B. CARBON STEEL SEAMLESS PIPES OF ASTM A -106 GR A, B & C, ASTM A- 333GR, 1 & 6, WITH IBR & NON IBR. C. ALLOY STEEL SEAMLESS PIPES OF ASTM A - 335 GR. P1, P2, P5, P9, P11, P12, P22 P91 ETC. D. PIPE FITTINGS LIKE ELBOW, REDUCER, BEND, STUBEND, TEE FLANGES, NUT, BOLT ETC. E. COPPER, BRASS, ALUMINUM, ZINC, LEAD, MONEL, NICKEL, INCONEL 600 & 800 AND HASTO ALLOYS NAMELY IN ALL FERROUS & NON FERROUS METALS IN ALL SIZES. please refer our above attachment & if you need any further documents or information's, please let us know please consider our request & do the needful with regard J M Devasi (+919619550158) [email protected]

回复
Mark Pink マーク ピンク

Former AI President (TSE:2338) AI 元代表取締役社長 (東証:2338)

7 年

This describes Warren Buffett so well. "He went from owning passive stakes in high quality blue chip companies to acquiring them outright (see Burlington Northern Railroad). Then he moved on to becoming a private equity partner in the LBOs of others (see Heinz). "

回复
Shalabh Raizada

Senior Team Lead with 25 years industry experience 12 yrs in Dot Net.

7 年

bad apple pleasure builder revoluza

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Joshua Brown的更多文章

  • What if your advisor's ideas had never been tested?

    What if your advisor's ideas had never been tested?

    I don't think I would ever invest money with someone who isn't on Twitter. Let me take a step back before you totally…

    15 条评论
  • Investing Doesn't Have to be Completely Unpredictable

    Investing Doesn't Have to be Completely Unpredictable

    The investment management business is unpredictable. Investment results are wildly unpredictable from one year to the…

    1 条评论
  • The Coming Pain and How to Cope

    The Coming Pain and How to Cope

    The market is a hot stove right now, or, at least large cap technology stocks are. Jim Cramer used to use this analogy…

    2 条评论
  • Introducing Blair duQuesnay, the newest advisor at Ritholtz Wealth!

    Introducing Blair duQuesnay, the newest advisor at Ritholtz Wealth!

    Today is a very special day for the firm and I have exciting news – my friend and colleague Blair duQuesnay, has joined…

    4 条评论
  • Now Celebrating Nine Years of a Raging Bull

    Now Celebrating Nine Years of a Raging Bull

    Both earnings and revenue growth have kept pace with the astonishing post-crisis bull market that is today celebrating…

    4 条评论
  • Breaking the Rules

    Breaking the Rules

    1976. Nike founder Phil Knight sits alone watching the start of the Montreal Olympic mens marathon event.

    18 条评论
  • Show me on this chart where that "bond market crisis" happened

    Show me on this chart where that "bond market crisis" happened

    A fun chart I whipped up looking at Treasury bond yields by maturity, just for a frame of reference now that everyone's…

    1 条评论
  • Today we open our new Chicago office!

    Today we open our new Chicago office!

    On behalf of the whole firm, I’m proud to announce the opening of our Chicago office – the new Midwest headquarters of…

    11 条评论
  • Pros vs Amateurs

    Pros vs Amateurs

    How do professional advisors start off 2018 vs amateur advisors who think they’re pros? I can speak to this from…

    9 条评论
  • My Big Takeaway from 2017

    My Big Takeaway from 2017

    I wanted to pull these two slides from our quarterly client call from last night to make a point that I think is often…

    2 条评论

社区洞察