Why I stopped pitching bloggers
Wow. After some blogger backlash from originally posting this, I guess I should just be more clear right off the bat. THIS IS NOT AN ISSUE OF WHETHER OR NOT BLOGGERS SHOULD GET PAID. I BELIEVE MANY SHOULD BE PAID FOR WHAT THEY DO. INSTEAD, THIS IS ABOUT PR CLIENTS NOT SETTING ASIDE AN EXTRA BUDGET TO PAY BLOGGERS ON TOP OF PAYING FOR PR. (I'M SORRY, BUT MOST PEOPLE CANNOT PAY EVERY SINGLE BLOGGER WHO SENDS THEM A MEDIA KIT.) NOTE: I AM A BLOGGER WHO GETS PAID. Now, read on...
When I made the switch from TV to PR, I learned a lot about the blogging world. One thing: Some bloggers don't like to be called bloggers. They prefer "businesswomen." (Yes, I insulted a blogger by calling her a blogger once.) I also learned money could be made in this field. A lot of money. (It's also why I stepped up my blogging game.) Every time I would send something out for a client, the response would be, "Yes, I can post this, but it'll cost you $200," or, "My media kit is attached," or, "Do you work for free, because I don't." That was when I realized if I wanted my client to make it on a blog, I had to pay for it. Well, this is not public relations. This is advertising. Public relations is earned media, like me getting a client on the Rachael Ray Show for free. Advertising is paid media. It's obvious in a magazine or in a commercial, but in a blog it's a sponsored post where the blogger basically pretends to love your product, business, or brand because you are paying her to. This = gray area for both publicists and bloggers.
With that said, I think there are many bloggers who have tons of influence who should be paid. Is a blog that gets 7,000 UVM with a mediocre social media following worth paying $200 for a post? Probably not, but it depends on who the blogs audience is and what audience the client wants. While some blogs are worthy of payment, most are not. I think this is also where a lot of bad bloggers are making good bloggers look bad. Some charge just to charge because they want to make money. Well, you have to give me a reason to pay you. If 100 bloggers are asking to be paid, why should we pay YOU? Today, everyone has a blog and most would not offer any ROI by paying for a post.
Every blogger is different. Some are journalists. Some are brand ambassadors. Some do it for fun. So I shouldn't title this "Why I stopped pitching bloggers" because some would be perfect pitches, but in my experience, most want to get paid and most clients don't set aside an extra budget for advertising. THAT IS WHY I STOPPED PITCHING BLOGGERS. WITHOUT A BUDGET, I CAN'T PAY THEM! Would you rather me pitch you, then tell you I don't have a budget? Probably not.
I did have a budget for bloggers once. One client wanted to be in the "mommy blogs." Well, I pitched them and got HUNDREDS of media kits. This one charges this much, or you can be in this baby guide for this much, this includes this many social media shares, and on and on. After sorting through them all and then handing the findings over to the client, they picked ONE. Obviously, you can't pay everyone who asks. They picked who they thought would give them their best ROI. All the other bloggers weren't too happy with me, but what can a girl do?!
So bloggers, if you are going to be on a database like Cision or Meltwater, do not get upset when a publicists pitches you. While some may have a separate budget for advertising, after paying a monthly PR retainer of thousands, most do not. If you don't like it, you should probably get off a database used by publicists. Keep in mind, if a publicists sends you something you like or in your niche, it could not only serve you as an idea for your next blog, but if you decide to use that pitch, not only is the PR company sharing that post, but so is the client which = more views for you. (And let's be honest, your entire blog should not be one big advertisement either.) And bloggers, one more thing. Don't assume a person has a fat wallet because they are paying for PR. Many times, it's not the case.
Publicists, if a clients goal is to make it on blogs, explain to them eight times out of 10, it is not earned. It is paid. Some do it for free. (I have. If it's for a good cause or fits my niche, why not?!) When I do pitch bloggers, which isn't often (hence what is written above), I make it very clear I am pitching for editorial purposes only and do not have a budget for advertising or sponsored posts (unless I do.) You are doing your client a disservice if you don't tell them blogs are advertisements, not earned media. It is not common knowledge to people not in the "blogsphere."
Finally, I'm ending with what a fellow PR professional posted in a PR group I'm in... which basically sums up this entire post: "Please don't be offended and confuse PR for marketing. PR professionals get paid to garner editoral (not advertorial) placements. Blogging is an amazing way to build a business and I totally respect that some bloggers are trying to make a living, but those should be talking to marketing/ad sales if they want to be paid. If I don't have to pay a Today show producer to consider covering something why would I pay a blogger? That being said, if the client gives me a budget to do marketing/paid sponsored posts, etc, you can bet I'm happy to pay for influential placement."
Department for International Trade - Senior Security Exports Advisor
9 年I've come to this late Christina, but I think I have some insight. As a hobbyist blogger (it's never earned any money other than covering my hosting costs - I have a day job that pays the bills) I took the decision a while back to stop working with PRs altogether, freeing me up to write about what I want whenever I want. Although the PRs that have I dealt with have always been unfailingly professional and friendly, a seasoned blogger understands that the moment they enter into an arrangement to cover 'this product' or 'that event', it puts them under an obligation to act professionally too. Thus the blog becomes another unpaid 'job', and starts to inexorably wear you down - in the end I think my blog was taking up almost as much of my time as my 9 to 5! Seriously researched and well-written blogposts take a lot of time and energy to compile believe me! I've paused my current blog for a while, and I know that the landscape has really changed over the last few years - the vast majority of 'London culture' blogs (my area of interest) have died, largely because people no longer see the benefit of toiling over their own site when they can push out a Facebook update with a few pictures, or a quick tweet. I don't envy the task of PRs these days, not least identifying genuine influencers amongst all the noise.
Founder at KSW Media Group
9 年So much to chew on in this piece. I truly believe there is room for PR and bloggers to do some wonderful things together, but ... it's a new era and thus needs to be approached differently. The standard media pitch doesn't catch a creatives eye the same way a PR person could if they sent me some great photos and 1-3 ideas on how I might want to work their product into my editorial content ... as an editorial feature. The space is changing, and we all have to adapt with it. If you keep trying to jam a square peg into a round hole and it isn't working. Don't quit, zoom out -- broaden your perspective and try something new. Find the hole that works.
Data Scientist with Business Experience in a Variety of Fields
9 年I think you're coming at this from the wrong angle. First note that the Today Show or the Rachael Ray Show can't exist without having stuff to cover. Many blogs can and do exist and do just fine without having your stuff to cover. Secondly, it's about the desirability of your product vs. the effort required. If you ask me (a math blogger) if I want to WRITE ABOUT your product, well, then you get a media kit. I get these requests everyday. If you ask me if I want to LOOK at your product, well, then I'll likely peek. Especially if it has a cool name. If I don't see value in it for me (not for my readers, but for ME), then I won't likely look past that - instead I'll send you a media kit. However, if I peek at your product and think I would enjoy it (for whatever reason), then I'll say "Yes - I'd love to look. Please send me one." After I have a chance to look more deeply (because you sent me one or I liked it so stinkin' much that I went and bought one), I may post a link on social media or use it for something else I'm writing about (and include a link to where to get the product). And every now and then I write about stuff because I just freaking love it. Thus you have EARNED the media with your PR pitch. My sending you a media kit is merely saying, "I'm not that into your product that I would investigate it independently. But if you REALLY want me - specifically ME - to investigate it, I will. But you gotta pay me for my time to do that." And if you don't choose to pay me, that's cool too. I'll move to the next email and you can move to the next blogger. We each have to keep reading and pitching to find the right level of PR/advertisement that works for us.
Photographer, Domain Consultant & Acquisition Investor, WEB/DEV, SEO, PR & Branding: @Photog4Naturals @DigitalREO @SpeakerFriend
9 年Things has truly changed over my 15 plus years. Bloggers are truly being recognized as influencers with brands and have a value service. I'm split on this but do recognized if they are being considered for a pitch they should be paid for their value services. From who, I say it should be from the budgets of the Brands. However, if a PR firms needs to deliver on publicity and the can get it from a blogge, well the may have to folk over some of their pay. IJS! I've been blessed to work directly with brands and PR firms and truly see major changes evolving exactly in concerns of this post and believe both bloggers and PR/Publicist should tread lightly.
Brand Strategist, Business Coach & Content Writer for women professionals & entrepreneurs | brand building + marketing communications + personal development
9 年First of all as a PR rep if you're pitching a blogger for your client it's because [I assume] you have already done your homework and that said blogger can add value to your client. I'm a blogger and content creator who like you, work to feed my family [but for myself]. You as a publicist is being paid nicely by your clients to get them BOTH earned and unearned media - and the SOW comes with a budget to make this happen. In essence you are being paid for your know how, experience and connections... just like brands pay me for my targeted and engaged community of readers and clients that I have built using MY know how, experience and connections. Yes while all platforms just like magazines have varying amount of followers/readership, it is not just how much followers that matter but my ability to get them to act. Isn't that what you are getting paid to do? To create exposure that will lead to your client's ROI - which is ultimately sales? So, if you feel it would be audacious of me to email you requesting your contacts so I can use them to achieve my own bottom line... then it is also audacious of you to think I would just let you use the assets that makes me valuable to you, to achieve your bottom line while you're getting paid and I'm not. So whether a blogger does so as a hobby or professionally, if you're pitching them in the first place, then it's because they have a handle on an audience that you need to tap into and can produce the desired results for your clients.