Why Great Employees Don't Always Make Great Managers

Promoting top employees to managerial positions can seem like a natural progression, but it often leads to unexpected challenges.?

Understanding why great employees may struggle as managers and how to effectively train them can transform your team and drive long-term business success.

The Misconception About Management

Many business owners assume that an outstanding employee will naturally excel in a managerial role. However, management is a distinct skill that must be learned and practiced. Unfortunately, many businesses lack a structured system to train their managers, opting instead to "wing it."

In this blog, I’ll share strategies to help you develop your employees into effective managers, leading to a more competent and productive team.

The Impact of Untrained Managers

Untrained managers can result in demotivated teams and increased time spent correcting errors. This often leads to higher turnover rates, which can be costly for any business.?

Conversely, well-trained managers can significantly boost team morale and productivity, reducing the need for constant problem-solving and contributing to long-term business growth.

Consider one business owner who promoted her top employee to a managerial role, assuming it was the logical next step. However, team performance quickly declined because, while this employee excelled at managing herself, she had never been taught to manage others.?

By enrolling her in a targeted management training program, she transformed into an effective manager, and her team became more motivated, competent, and productive, thanks to a solid management system.

3 Strategies for Developing Great Managers

• Evaluate Your Own Management Style

First, examine your leadership style. Are you a bottleneck in your business? Constantly stepping in to solve problems yourself can overburden you and stifle your managers' growth.?

Begin delegating responsibilities and empower your managers to make decisions. Provide them with a systematic approach to managing the team. This shift may be challenging initially but is crucial for long-term success.

• Ask Forward-Thinking Questions

When things go wrong, avoid asking “why,” which often leads to excuses and blame. Instead, ask forward-thinking questions like, “What steps can we take to fix this in the next hour?” or “How can we prevent this from happening again?” These questions promote problem-solving, accountability, and productivity.

• Importance of Planning

Without a clear plan, your team lacks direction and purpose. Ensure your managers understand the overall business goals and how their roles contribute to achieving them. Regularly review and adjust these plans as necessary.?

When everyone is aligned, productivity, competency, and morale will soar.

Reaping the Benefits

Focusing on these management skills will transform your business into a well-oiled machine. Your managers and team will become more competent and productive, leading to a thriving business.?

Good managers create happy teams, and happy teams create happy customers, driving your business forward.

Ready to transform your top employees into exceptional managers? Implement these strategies and watch your business thrive.

If these strategies resonate with you and you’re eager to implement them in your business, book a strategy session with me. Let’s determine if our 12-week management master class is right for your business. Click the link below to schedule your call.

Book a Free Strategy Session

Check out our other Business Tips to Work Smarter not Harder