Why grammar pedants hate me

Why grammar pedants hate me

I have many thoughts about grammar. Most of them conflict each other.

You see, I can't stand this little thing in grammar known as prescriptivism. It's the idea that there's only one correct and proper way to use language, and that this way is superior to every other form, simply because it was likely carved in some dull as fuck rock or something ages and ages ago by someone with a better education/upbringing/right to an opinion than you.

"I think you'll find that your usage of the phrase in that context isn't the correct or proper form of blah blah blah..."

You read that in a really smug voice, didn't you? Great, so you know who I'm talking about.

Whilst I admit that I get really uncomfortably irked by what I would personally define as poor grammar, what truly pisses me off more is when people consistently and publicly call out somebody else's language use, and do so purely to exert some kind of authority over them in humiliating fashion. You may know them as grammar pedants. I call them patronising arseholes.

There's absolutely nothing wrong with wanting a great standard of grammar - and I really wish everyone had one - but there's a time and a place for campaigning, and there has to be a purpose.

The time. The time to raise issue is not when someone has clearly put some thought into structuring a piece or a post that will share value through its content or promote discussion in its quest for information. The grammar used to structure such a piece will always be secondary to this, at best - in my opinion.

The place. If you can call someone out on what you view as a grammatical error in front of anyone else present in the realm of communication, you can just as easily do it in private. Believe me, it will get you a much better response, and that person is more likely to want to listen to you/read your thoughts. Also, nobody else will think you're being a dick in the process.

The purpose. To 'pick up' on someone's grammar, spelling and punctuation, you really need to have a word with yourself and think if it's going to serve a purpose. I mean, did the issue really mean that you couldn't understand the point being made? Be decent for a minute and have a think if what you're about to type/say is genuinely going to help that person with something in the long-run. For example, are they using completely the wrong word and it may therefore lead to embarrassment for them in another situation to the point where you genuinely want help them? Or does the comment you're about to make simply just help to promote you?

I love it when I find someone in my life who loves and respects language as much as I do, but whilst those fabulous people love and respect things like grammar, spelling and punctuation, they also love and respect the fact that language is beautiful and creative. They love that it's part of a personal style and they respect that it has an evolution. You can love and respect grammar without going all Glenn Close Fatal Attraction on it, is what I'm saying here.

If you believe you're a grammar pedant who would enjoy a conversation or a glass of wine with me despite everything I've said so far, then to my mind, you're not a grammar pedant, and I say rid yourself of that association. Grammar pedants, for me, are those who wade in on the work of others; usually in public and from a lofty position. They give people like me a bad name. I don't want to be associated with them, because I don't want people hating me (more than they already do for my content).

Like a lot of copywriters, I'm a big fan of 'writing like you speak'. In an increasingly technological world, where your online customer service is Betty by name and Bot by nature, I can't help thinking that people would have a better bond with their clients, customers and colleagues if they just spoke to them like real humans. I do believe in standards and that the basics of grammar should be used so that we can come away from laziness and a lack of professional standing, but when you pick up on a point that only the true grammar pedants would know/give a present tense shit about, then really, it doesn't matter. If you're going to force me into giving an example here, then active/passive voice, split infinitives, and not ending with a preposition can bugger off. If you don't know what I'm talking about - good, you don't need to.

To sum up this particular blog, I'll say this. If you can structure a grammatically accurate sentence, and would like everybody to know about it, but you can't structure an opinion that gets involved with the point of what someone else has written in the first place, you're a bit of a tool. Full stop.

And, if you hate me for my use/abuse of grammar, or you hate me because I've called you out in this blog, find me another grammar pedant who agrees with each and every one of your points.

You'll fail. Those fuckers agree with nobody.

Language Timothy...

回复
Darren Ledger

International Executive Search Partner ★ Talent Acquisition Specialist ★ MENA Specialist★ Making the Impossible Possible

5 年

When I read that statement in a smug voice the image of Jacob Rees-Mogg leapt to mind. I wholeheartedly agree with everything you have written here. What particularly irks me personally is when the mistake is obviously or very probably an error or oversight caused as a result of someone responding or writing whilst using a phone or tablet and probably on the move. We've all fired off a comment, a post or similar whilst crammed in a tube train in rush hour. The physical effort of actually completing the task is draining, then having some wanker comment that your you're is incorrect and that they're infuriated by your 'their' is fucking soul-destroying!I'm fascinated by the amazing fact that the human mind can literally read entire paragraphs missing 80%+ of the text, upside down, back to front and whilst stood on your head underwater viewing it through a snorkel yet some people can't interpret the accidental application of a word or phrase without digging around for an incontinence pants to contain their self-pitying piss. ?

Kelly Mitchell (BA HONS. QTS)

I help overworked professionals with busy schedules to take care of their health in a simple, fast & cost effective way

5 年

I swear I make up more words than the politicians make up policies... I’m a grammar correctives dream... ????♀?

??????? ????

Depersonalized consciousness playing the human game | Strategist | Management Consultant

5 年

Victor Hallock I have a recommendation for you

回复
??????? ????

Depersonalized consciousness playing the human game | Strategist | Management Consultant

5 年

I feel like the most important is the flow of thought throughout the piece and to the reader. If your grammer is tight, but no one is feeling it , you fail by default

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Jo Watson (CMgr MCMI)的更多文章

  • All t*ts & ?s

    All t*ts & ?s

    Alternative title - Sorted in 60?: Tits in a Minute. You might be forced to read on for some context, here, as this…

    15 条评论
  • Is it time to shelve World Book Day?

    Is it time to shelve World Book Day?

    Are you even the parent of a primary school-aged child if you haven't ripped your hair out this week and/or had a…

    96 条评论
  • "I'm leaving you."

    "I'm leaving you."

    "I'm leaving you." Yep.

    28 条评论
  • When you don't fit in... on LinkedIn

    When you don't fit in... on LinkedIn

    There's no mistaking that when it comes to bringing me business, LinkedIn most definitely serves its purpose for me…

    54 条评论
  • I couldn't help but wonder... where all of Carrie Bradshaw's money and free time were coming from

    I couldn't help but wonder... where all of Carrie Bradshaw's money and free time were coming from

    As I sat in my borderline-need-of-a-wash dressing gown, and pondered the choice of either Super Noodles or a packet of…

    51 条评论
  • 9 rules for inviting me to your networking event

    9 rules for inviting me to your networking event

    Since setting up Mighty Networkers last year as a way to support people to get their networking actually working for…

    42 条评论
  • 9 rules for inviting me to your networking event

    9 rules for inviting me to your networking event

    Since setting up Mighty Networkers last year as a way to support people to get their networking actually working for…

    44 条评论
  • 2024: The Year of the Shitgibbon

    2024: The Year of the Shitgibbon

    I have zero authority or backing to make the following claim, but seeing as such a situation hinders precisely no…

    13 条评论
  • Child's Play Tuesdays: Showy Has A Shelf-Life

    Child's Play Tuesdays: Showy Has A Shelf-Life

    I’m worried about this chapter coming across in a way that implies I have any idea whatsoever about what kids want and…

  • Child's Play Tuesdays: No Return On Investment

    Child's Play Tuesdays: No Return On Investment

    You give everything, they take everything. “That’s kids for you!”, as my dad always says when I’m having a little moan…

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了