Why Good Leaders Think Like Chess Players: Science-Backed Lessons for Better Decision-Making
Dr Elizabeth King
Helping leaders, teams and organizations perform in uncertainty.
“It’s your move.” The words echo not just in chess, but in boardrooms, crisis meetings, and strategy sessions. As leaders, we are constantly staring at the board, trying to read the patterns, anticipate the next move, and make decisions with limited time and imperfect information. Some decisions call for bold, instinctive action. Others require calm, deliberate thought. The trick is knowing which is which.
Why Good Leaders Think Like Chess Players: Science-Backed Lessons for Better Decision-Making
In leadership, as in chess, every move matters. It’s not just about reacting to what’s in front of you—it’s about anticipating what lies ahead. Great chess players don’t just make the best individual moves; they think several steps beyond, balancing instinct with calculated strategy. The same is true for successful leaders. Knowing when to trust your intuition and when to slow down for deep analysis is the difference between an impulsive gamble and a winning strategy.
Scholarship reveals that great decision-making is a skill that leaders can develop by mastering this balance. Let’s explore the lessons leaders can take from the chessboard and apply to their own decision-making journeys.
1. Expertise Amplifies Decision-Making Power—But Only With the Right Conditions
In chess, expertise allows players to see patterns, predict outcomes, and quickly assess risks. Research shows that experienced decision-makers often outperform novices because their mental framework helps them spot opportunities faster (Van Der Maas & Wagenmakers, 2005). But even grandmasters aren’t immune to mistakes. Under time pressure, decision quality can drop, especially when complex or unfamiliar challenges arise (Travassos et al., 2013).
Lesson for leaders: Expertise is valuable, but even the most experienced leaders need time to assess complex situations. Rushing through major decisions can lead to errors, even if you have a wealth of experience. Give your team the space to analyze before making key moves.
2. Intuition Isn’t Always the Villain
A chess master can often make the right move without thinking for long. This is the power of intuition which is instinct that is honed through years of experience. Intuition can backfire if it’s applied to unfamiliar situations or when it isn’t grounded in knowledge. However, studies show that intuition works best when combined with prior experience and is especially helpful when cognitive resources are stretched (Betsch, 2008).
Lesson for leaders: Trust your instincts when facing problems, you’ve encountered before but be cautious with high-stakes or unfamiliar challenges. In these cases, slow down and rely on strategic analysis. Intuition is like a powerful opening gambit—it works when played at the right moment but overusing it can lead to defeat.
3. A Good Decision Doesn’t Always Mean a Good Outcome
Even the most calculated moves in chess can fail when an opponent makes an unexpected response. Similarly, in leadership, a good decision process doesn’t always guarantee the desired result. External factors—timing, market shifts, or unforeseen challenges—can derail even the most well-thought-out plans. Despite that, research suggests that process-driven decision-making leads to better long-term success, even when short-term outcomes are unpredictable (Lee & Coricelli, 2020).
Lesson for leaders: Don’t judge decisions solely by their immediate results. Instead, focus on whether the decision was made with diligence, collaboration, and foresight. Like a well-planned chess strategy, your process should be robust enough to adapt when the unexpected happens.
4. Short-Term and Long-Term Thinking Must Coexist
Great chess players know that winning requires both tactical brilliance and long-term vision. Sacrificing a piece now may lead to victory later. Leaders face similar challenges when balancing short-term operational needs with long-term strategic goals. As Kahneman (2011) highlights, intuitive decisions are useful for quick wins, but long-term success depends on deliberate, strategic thinking.
Lesson for leaders: Distinguish between tactical decisions that require quick action and strategic decisions that demand careful analysis. Encourage your team to handle short-term challenges efficiently, but ensure long-term decisions are approached with deep consideration. A winning leader, like a grandmaster, knows when to be bold and when to be cautious.
Lead Like a Chess Master
Leadership is about playing the game well enough to recover from mistakes and seize opportunities. The best chess players don’t win by always making flawless moves. They win by recognizing when to switch between instinctive action and strategic planning. They understand that the board is constantly changing and adapt accordingly.
As a leader, you face the same challenge.
So, the next time you’re making a decision, picture yourself at the chessboard. Trust your experience when the pattern is clear. But when the stakes are high or the situation is new, pause, take a step back, and think several moves ahead.
Reflecting on Your Next Move. If you’re looking to sharpen your decision-making skills or want to explore tools to balance intuition and strategy, feel free to visit drlizking.com, where you’ll find a range of resources to help you on this path.
And if you’d like personalized guidance, I’d be happy to connect and support you. Don’t hesitate to reach out—we can explore how to make your next big move a winning one.
References?