Why Does AARP Support the Retirement Security Rule?
AARP CEO, Jo Ann Jenkins, at the White House Unveiling of the Retirement Security Rule

Why Does AARP Support the Retirement Security Rule?

In today's Macchia Minute video, I explain why the Retirement Security Rule is misnamed: It doesn't address retirement security. It is difficult for me to understand why AARP, an organization that advocates for people 50 and above, including millions of Americans in retirement, supports a regulation that ignores the financial issues that truly matter to most retirees' retirement security. Rather than back a regulation that will make it more difficult for people to access annuities providing lifetime guaranteed income, including the unmatched benefits of fixed index annuities, I believe AARP should be lobbying for regulations and legislation that promote the wider use of these critically important retirement security products.

Perhaps AARP does not recognize that in retirement it's your income, not your savings, that creates your standard of living. It seems to me if there is any organization in the U.S. that should be more focused on promoting guaranteed income products, it ought to be AARP. But for reasons I cannot explain, AARP has taken the opposite path. Why do you think this is?

#aarp #annuity #insuranceagent #retirement

Borys Senyk, CRPC, RSSA

Financial Literacy Campaigner and Educator | Entrepreneur with World System Builder | Chartered Retirement Planning Counselor | Registered Social Security Analyst

10 个月

AARP presenting this at the Biden WH is like most of their deceptively named actions, ex: “Inflation Reduction”. They are merely falling in line with the Democratic narrative. It’s time or more likely overdue for the (mis)represented people to vigorously express their opposition to this and similar policies.

回复
Jack Towarnicky

HR, Total Rewards, Employee Benefits Subject Matter Expert

10 个月

Once, AARP got sideways with members - Medicare Catastrophic Coverage Act of 1988 (MCCA) - From Heritage: "... During the MCCA debate, there was powerful support for the legislation in Congress (and DC) interest groups ... AARP was perhaps the most prominent player in a drama that included ... senior citizen organizations, consumer groups, medical societies, and even ... the health care industry. ... (DC) health care policy experts were favorable... But ... DC-based groups severely misjudged the reactions of ordinary Americans, including those they claimed to represent. ... AARP staff in particular found itself on the defensive when millions of elderly Americans started complaining bitterly to Members of Congress ... The New Republic's, Phillip Longman noted: "Congress and the AARP have been besieged. The abuse heaped on the AARP by its members this summer has been so unrelenting that its (DC) policy staff - most of them idealistic, liberal-minded baby boomers - have begun to talk back like unrepentant granny-bashers. Some congressional offices ... (received) up to 1000 letters a week ... demanding that the bill should be repealed or its cost should be SHIFTED ONTO SOMEONE ELSE...." (My emphasis, and what ultimately happened).

James Joseph Frazier

Change it works; If it's about Retirement, Business, Insurance Benefits or Taxes & Planning? Ask me Ask Frazier, USA

10 个月

AARP Is a an Insurance Marketing & Distributor Organization, among other things. Look closely at all their revenues and where they come from. They are a glorified Not For Profit that generates hundreds of millions! AARP like the US Chamber, often support things that are pure contradictions, relative to the memberships they serve! Well in My opinion anyway. That said, keep in mind ERISA based pay for play rules & prohibited transactions. This new DOL Fiduciary Rule, simply puts those ERISA Standards on steroids. Add fresh Regulatory oversight courtesy the SEC, agents see another lock down. This one designed like the Pandemic; Do as I say agents & brokers, you can't do, what the big boys do! Thanks DOL, America's retirement wealth is in the hands, of those who serve Wall Street Money! The Golden Goose has laid another Egg, on an expensive fee based platter! Agents & Brokers, Caveat Emptor The simple reality of the whole DOL Wall Street ( SEC] mess is this; It's about retirement account assets, the revenues they generate and the greedy fat cats that own manage & control US Consumer Retirement Wealth. using politics to gain assurances that most of everything money wise stays with the ?? Big Banks!

Byron Kelly, CLTC??. ?? Financial Professional ??

Educator of Tax-Free Wealth, Retirement Income & Legacy Strategies | Certified LTC. Trusted Charitable Advisor. Husband-Father-USN Vet. WFG Agent. Mentor. Coach

10 个月

David, All this to ?? savers to ?? that “they all know” has some serious g-forces coming - it’s cyclical. Strange alliances needs consumers working with head to the plow, not asking a lot of “quality questions”, assuming majority of the risk, being less informed about superior strategies and on autopilot in the market. Let’s see how fiduciary advice worked out in the last major bubble. EVERYONE pay particular attention to all questions and answers throughout. #informed #beinformed #knowbetterdobetter 2008; Roll tape 3 ??: https://youtu.be/nAHgr9dY9BU?si=_i9g9QXcAKYjWB4L

Gary Mettler

The “Annuity Maestro”/Nationally Published Author/Immediate Annuity Agent and Agent Trainer Emails: [email protected] or [email protected]

10 个月

I'm surprised given the AARP is a huge distributor of fixed annuity contracts (SPIAs/MYGAs). There are probably 15 or so carriers at any given time on thier distribution platform on a "pay to play" arrangement. Not sure who would be the "Fiduciary" in this business model. Maybe AARP is ok going to non-qualified contracts only. Any one have some thoughts on all these BTC business models? Sheryl J. Moore (do you know what's the AARP annual $ annuity premium volume?)

要查看或添加评论,请登录

David Macchia的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了