Why benchmarking may have you come up short in driving business improvement

?

Companies rely on benchmarking to gain insights, identify best practices, set performance goals, drive improvement, and stay competitive. As consultants, many of our clients request for benchmarking to assess their performance compared to peers or other facilities, with the aim of setting targets for their team. While we support the idea of setting challenging targets, we propose a shift in focus from top-down benchmarking efforts to more comprehensive bottom-up studies and analysis as the most effective path to achieve significant business improvements.

What are the pitfalls of benchmarking?

Level of Benchmarking Insights

Granular benchmarks can make it harder to ensure a fair apples-to-apples comparison.

For instance, analyzing sales prices or margins on comparable products can yield valuable benchmarks, but attempting to compare operational efficiency or processing speed can become problematic due to inherent differences in businesses.

Acquiring Quality Data

?Obtaining benchmarking data often proves challenging and may require extensive manipulation. This not only affects the reliability of the data, but also the quality of decisions that can be based on it and the time required to make it usable.

?Interpreting Data in Context

?Rarely do two operations align perfectly due to differences in equipment, products, processes, and operations. This makes it challenging to draw meaningful comparisons between businesses, even within the same organization. We’ve worked with fortune 500 companies who have struggled to derive accurate insights from internal benchmarking efforts, despite copious amounts of data and standardized reporting.

?Data Relevance and Timing

The timing and context of benchmarking data are crucial for making informed decisions. It's essential to consider the circumstances under which you're being benchmarked, accounting for market disruptions like recent COVID protocols and labour shortages. Without this contextual understanding, comparisons may not be truly meaningful.

Answers “What” but not “How”

While benchmarking can highlight areas where your organization falls short, it doesn't offer guidance on how to improve. It lacks the necessary depth to pinpoint relevant solutions or prioritize them for your specific business needs.

Looking Backwards, Not Forward

Benchmarking inherently relies on historical data, which can lead to shortsighted strategic decisions. Businesses may prioritize emulating competitors or adopting trendy technologies without fully aligning them with their objectives or market conditions. Additionally, when using benchmarks to set targets, projecting future trends becomes essential to remain competitive.

Misses your Competitive Advantage

Continuously comparing your metrics to competitors’ may overlook your unique competitive advantages. While understanding your performance benchmarks is valuable, leveraging your strengths can have a more significant impact and help you avoid unnecessary expenses and efforts. Further, if you are a leader in a particular area, benchmarking may not reveal untapped opportunities, potentially diverting attention from resolving inherent business issues and hindering your company's full potential.

?

Advantages of Bottom Up: Why we don’t rely on benchmarks to drive performance gains.

Comparison with the Ideal World

Benchmarking typically stops at comparing your performance to industry averages or competitors, leaving a gap between your current state and the ideal world of possibilities. In contrast, a bottom-up evaluation measures against perfection, leaving no room for bias or unexplored opportunities. By setting the bar at 100%, you unearth hidden potential within common areas of lost performance.

Detailed Understanding of the Business

Bottom-up analysis takes you on a deep dive into every nook and cranny of your business processes. This level of scrutiny provides an intimate understanding of your entire production system, allowing you to pinpoint specific bottlenecks, inefficiencies, or areas ripe for improvement. It's like having a magnifying glass for your operations.

Incremental Gains, Cumulative Impact

The meticulous nature of bottom-up studies often reveals opportunities for quick, incremental improvements throughout your organization. Addressing smaller inefficiencies may seem minor, but these changes can accumulate over time, resulting in a substantial overall performance boost. Moreover, the step-by-step approach ensures that improvements can be seamlessly integrated into your workflow, avoiding disruptions.

Enhanced Employee Engagement

Engaging employees in the bottom-up evaluation process fosters a culture of continuous improvement. Frontline workers, who are often the ones most familiar with day-to-day operations, can contribute their valuable insights. Involving your team in solutions from the outset not only improves quality and sustainability but also instills a sense of ownership in the improvement process.

Streamlined Problem Solving:

A crucial step in both bottom-up analysis and problem-solving is developing a detailed understanding of the issues at hand. By adopting a bottom-up approach, you effectively combine these steps. The in-depth problem understanding is already in place, and in many cases, solutions can be swiftly implemented, reducing the lag between identifying issues and resolving them.

The choice between benchmarking and bottom-up analysis represents a critical crossroads for organizations seeking to thrive in today's dynamic business environment. While benchmarking serves as a valuable tool, relying solely on it may leave businesses short of realizing their true potential. Bottom-up analysis - with its detailed scrutiny, employee engagement, and incremental gains - offers a pathway to sustainable improvement. It's a journey that empowers businesses to not only stay competitive but to chart their own course towards excellence. In a world where adaptability and innovation are paramount, embracing the power of bottom-up analysis becomes a strategic imperative for long-term success.

Isaac is a consulting firm that helps organizations save money and achieve their operational goals. Our approach is designed to deliver tangible, long-lasting results through providing actionable insights that produce results in a matter of a few months.?

If you are interested in learning more about the types of problems we tackle with our clients, get in touch with us .? We’ve completed hundreds of projects with our unique approached tailored to the specific needs of our clients.