Why Annual Reviews Should Be Abolished?

Annual Reviews Are Corporate Procrastination—If They Worked, We Wouldn’t Need Them Every Year

Let’s be honest: annual performance reviews are a broken, outdated system.

Employees dread them. Managers rush through them. And despite hours of paperwork, meetings, and forced feedback sessions, nothing changes.

If annual reviews were truly effective, companies wouldn’t have to repeat them yearly—because performance issues would already be solved.

Yet, here we are, stuck in an endless cycle of corporate procrastination, pretending that one review a year is enough to drive growth, engagement, and improvement.

It’s not.

And the companies that refuse to admit it are losing their best talent faster than they can schedule their next round of reviews.

The Hidden Damage of Annual Reviews

Most leaders defend performance reviews with the argument that employees need structured feedback.

And they’re right—feedback is critical. But waiting an entire year to give it? That’s leadership negligence.

Here’s what happens in most organizations:

• Feedback is vague and outdated. Employees are judged on projects from months ago, even if they’ve improved since.
• Biases skew the process. Recency bias, favoritism, and manager subjectivity make reviews unfair.
• They encourage mediocrity. Employees focus on hitting safe goals rather than pushing boundaries.
• They kill motivation. Constructive criticism lands better in real time, not six months too late.

And here’s the worst part: most employees don’t even remember their last performance review.

Ask yourself:?

Can you recall every piece of feedback from your last review? Probably not.

So if employees aren’t actively using these reviews to improve, why are we still doing them?

What to Do Instead: The Continuous Feedback Model

If you want to retain top talent and create a high-performance culture, ditch annual reviews and replace them with real-time feedback loops.

Here’s how you can retain top talent:

1. Weekly Micro-Feedback – Instead of a yearly meeting, give short, consistent feedback every week. This keeps employees on track and prevents small mistakes from becoming big problems.
2. Monthly Growth Check-Ins – Focus less on criticism and more on development. Ask: What’s helping you grow? What’s holding you back?
3. 360-Degree Feedback – Encourage peer, manager, and self-evaluation throughout the year. Leaders shouldn’t be the only ones giving feedback.
4. Make Recognition Immediate – Praise should be given as soon as it’s earned, not six months later in a performance review.

Companies that have moved away from annual reviews—like Adobe, Deloitte, and GE—have seen a massive boost in engagement, retention, and productivity.

The results speak for themselves.

Would Your Employees Miss Annual Reviews If You Stopped Them?

Here’s the real test:

• If your company eliminated annual reviews tomorrow, would anyone actually care?
• Would employees demand their yearly feedback session back?
• Or would they feel relieved that they no longer have to sit through a scripted conversation that doesn’t impact their growth?

The best companies already know the answer.

What about yours?

• Are you Keeping the Status Quo or Evolving?
• Are you still relying on performance reviews??
• Or is your company already shifting to a real-time feedback culture?

The answer will prove that annual reviews are a relic of the past. They kill motivation, create unnecessary stress, and fail to drive real improvement.

If you want to build a high-performance team, ditch the outdated review process and replace it with continuous, meaningful feedback.

The Growth Huddle Team

People-First Leadership (PFL) brings a unique approach to leadership that creates win-win solutions.

To experience how the People-First approach can transform your leadership, and increase performance and profits,

Book a Free 30 min 1:1