Why Accepting a Counteroffer from Your Current Workplace Might Not Be a Good Idea

Job changes are part of professional growth. However, when you announce your resignation after securing a new position, your current employer might counter with an enticing offer in an attempt to retain you. While it may feel flattering, and even tempting, accepting a counteroffer may not be the best move for your career. Here’s why:

The Root Problem Still Exists

A counteroffer typically addresses salary, but it rarely solves the deeper reasons you considered leaving in the first place. Whether it’s a lack of growth opportunities, dissatisfaction with management, or a stressful work environment, those core issues often remain unchanged. A slight pay increase or new title may temporarily mask the problem, but in the long run, the reasons for your original job search will likely resurface.

False Promises

If the reason for leaving is due to lack of promotion or other factors, these may be countered with a false promise of ‘we were going to promote you in ….’ Or ‘we were actually talking about moving you up next quarter…’ All of these things are ‘maybes’ and nothing is for certain, but just certain enough for you to not accept the offer that is on the table right now. The truth of the matter is, if they were really going to promote you, why haven’t they done it already??

Trust and Loyalty Can Be Compromised

When you hand in your resignation, you've signalled that you're ready to move on. Even if you stay, some managers may view you as less loyal or question your commitment to the company. This can damage the trust in your professional relationship, leading to fewer opportunities for advancement or even exclusion from future strategic discussions.?

Future Job Security Is Questionable

Employees who accept counteroffers may find their job security at risk in the long term. After all, employers now know that you were ready to leave once, and if push comes to shove (e.g., during downsizing), they might prioritise those who appear more loyal. Additionally, your name could be at the top of the list if cost-cutting measures are needed, since they had to stretch to retain you in the first place.

It’s Often a Short-Term Fix

Data shows that many employees who accept counteroffers end up leaving their jobs within six months to a year anyway. The factors that led to the initial dissatisfaction tend to persist, and the excitement of a counteroffer fades quickly. Employees often find themselves once again pursuing new opportunities, but with lost time and potential damage to their reputation.

Your New Employer Might See It Differently

If you accept a counteroffer and turn down the new job, you could burn bridges with the new company that offered you a position. Professional networks are often smaller than they seem, and you may find that the new employer—or others in the industry—may view you as unreliable or indecisive. This could limit your opportunities down the road, especially if you later decide to pursue similar roles within the same network.

You're Just a Short-Term Solution for Your Employer

In some cases, companies extend counteroffers simply to buy time until they find a replacement. While you may think you’re being valued, your employer may only be trying to avoid the immediate hassle of recruiting and training someone new. This could leave you in an uncomfortable situation when they eventually decide to move on without you.

Your Professional Development Could Stagnate

One of the most common reasons people leave jobs is the desire for growth—whether in skills, responsibilities, or leadership. If your current employer only offers a pay increase without addressing your need for professional development, staying could stunt your career growth. A new job often provides fresh challenges, a broader network, and different learning opportunities, which are key to long-term career success.

?

While accepting a counteroffer may seem like a win in the short term, it often leads to longer-term regret. The underlying reasons for wanting to leave remain, and your relationship with your current employer may become strained. Instead of staying in a situation where you were already unsatisfied, it might be wiser to move forward with your new opportunity, where fresh experiences and growth await.