Who Needs Wal-Mart or Amazon Anymore?
I've seen the future of retailing, and it is odd, exhilarating, and terrifying.
It's a phone call late in the evening from a customer-service representative in China. It's a package that takes just four days to arrive from Suzhou, just west of Shanghai. It's an online catalog stuffed with 700,000 items -- shapeshifting into 27 different languages from Bahasa to Turkish.
This is the world of a company called LightInTheBox, a publicly-traded Beijing-based ecommerce company. While it loses money quite prodigiously, it's doing some pretty notable things, namely putting a competent, professional consumer interface for selling goods directly from China.
When you think about it, both Wal-Mart and Amazon have been that interface for the last decades. But why must that persist?
Why can't Chinese companies themselves take on that role, using Web technology, modern shipping routes, and smartphones to reach directly to consumers in the U.S. and around the world?
These companies still have a long way to go, as I detail in the column linked here:
But this is going to happen, via small players like LightInTheBox and much bigger ones such as Alibaba, whose market cap is just below that of Wal-Mart. It's going to happen with U.S. companies selling into China (although that's a much harder proposition) and even with companies in strange places -- with strange missions -- that haven't even been conceived yet.
Just listen to what the LightIntheBox CFO Robin Lu told me in an interview:
"We are very close to the manufacturers. Any individual consumer, from anywhere in the world, if they order something through our website, they can pick it out from the manufacturer, which means the consumer is more flexible than purchasing from Wal-Mart. You can buy anything you want."
Here are three last things to think about:
1) Brand names still matter. I ordered a jacket from LightInTheBox and it carried what was arguably a "brand name." But it was a fiction, meaning nothing to me nor anyone else. If Chinese companies want to be more directly competitive with other Western brands, they will have to purchase or create brands. My hunch says it's only a matter of time until they buy a big licensing-holding company for just such a play.
2) U.S. companies can use much of this same technology. They just have to get more creative. The most impressive thing I discovered about LightInTheBox is that the company uses the Web to recruit and trains customer-service reps in each of the 27 languages in which it operates. In other words, it likely has Turkish speakers, in Turkey, handling customer queries for a Chinese website, shipping goods to Turkish speakers in Germany.
3) Sales tax abritrage. This is something people don't think about, but these foreign sales don't collect U.S. sales tax. That's a built-in advantage that I suspect will one day become an issue for the U.S. Congress. It's early yet, but keep your eye on it.
As always, I love your feedback, so please leave comments here.
Please read the full, detailed column at the WSJ.
(Image credit: Rob Stinnett/Flickr)
Aluno universitário administração de empresa
9 年pois bem varejo muito concorrido eu sou brasileiro moro aqui desde que nasci nos brasileiro pagamos maior imposto tributário do mundo muito interessante governo americano faz retira imposto importado para fica acessível consumidor local, mais brasil governo pensa no tributo fica pesado no orçamento familiar brasileira isso faz ter descontrole balança entre a demanda e oferta
Business Coach | Marketing Strategy | New & Established Coaches: Elevate Your Impact, Boost Your Income | Build an EXCEPTIONAL Coaching Practice, without being inauthentic or pushy. ✨
9 年Very interesting article Dennis. RE; Your comment on Sales Tax. We saw this issue with Amazon as states and provinces stepped in to legislate and grab their piece. The difference here, with broad implications, is that we are dealing with a closed (Communist) system. What rules will they choose to play by? Another thing that comes to mind is their willingness to learn and be open - open to other cultures and languages.
Owner, The 2431 Group
9 年When you need to try-on clothes or shoes or colors................bricks/mortor still matter alot. Shopping on a CPU is not fun or entertaining yet.
Sales & Business Development Leader
9 年What about the quality standards on items shipped? Do they have to comply with the same regulations as a US company shipping from China?
MD & Business Adviser at Dream & Al-Modina Traders'
9 年The world business is depending day day on e-commerce as is the easiest to the demand of the consumer & the consumer who also now-a-days satisfied better if they are quickly & smoothly served thus Wal-Mart or Amazon does their best & the modern, tasteful, relishing, & sincere customer will choose it the most.