Who Makes the Best Leader: Extroverts or Introverts?

Effective leadership isn’t about fitting a mold—it’s about embracing your strengths. Introverted leaders excel at thoughtful decision-making, deep focus, and active listening, while extroverted leaders bring energy, strong communication, and the ability to inspire teams. ?

?

In the past many leadership experts thought that outstanding leaders needed the qualities of extroverts: charisma, exerting power over others, and dynamic communications. Yet today many of the best leaders are introverts, and people are appreciating their approach to leadership.??

?

This dichotomy raises the question, do extroverts or introverts make the best leaders??

?

Dynamic Leadership of Extroverts?

Extroverts bring energy, charisma, and the ability to inspire and motivate teams. They thrive in social environments and are often more comfortable in the spotlight, making them natural communicators. Among the key strengths of extroverted leaders are these qualities:?

?

1. Inspiring Others: Extroverts can energize their teams with enthusiasm and vision. Their dynamic presence often motivates employees to rally behind a shared goal.?
2. Strong Communication Skills: Extroverted leaders tend to be excellent at expressing ideas and connecting with others, making them effective in driving collaboration and team cohesion.?
3. Adaptability: Extroverts are often quick to engage with new people and ideas, making them well-suited for environments that require flexibility and frequent change.?

?

Despite these strengths, extroverted leaders face challenges. They may overlook quieter voices on their teams or make decisions too quickly without considering all the details. The key for extroverts is learning to pause, listen, and ensure their team members have the space to contribute meaningfully.?

?

As an extrovert myself, I faced this criticism when our general counsel came to my office and told me, “Bill, you are not getting the best out of our team because you are so powerful and persuasive that several people withhold important inputs that need to be heard.” Accepting his criticism, I made a point of holding back on my viewpoints until everyone had expressed their inputs and the group had discussed the issues at hand. Then I offered my conclusions.?

?

The Power of Introverted Leaders?

Introverted leaders often excel in areas that require deep reflection, careful decision-making, and focused attention. These leaders tend to listen more than they speak, allowing them to absorb the insights and concerns of their teams before making decisions. Some of the key strengths of introverted leaders include:?

?

1. Thoughtful Decision-Making: Introverts take time to process information and are less likely to make impulsive decisions. They carefully weigh pros and cons, considering the broader implications before moving forward.?
2. Active Listening: Introverted leaders often listen attentively to the input of their teams. This fosters an inclusive culture where employees feel heard and valued.?
3. Depth of Focus: Introverts are naturally inclined to focus on fewer things at a deeper level, enabling them to lead with clarity and precision.?

?

However, introverts also face certain challenges. They may struggle with the outward demands of leadership, such as public speaking or networking, which can leave their leadership presence underappreciated. Sometimes they are underestimated because people do not believe they will exert power and strong leadership. Overcoming these hurdles often involves learning to balance internal reflection with external communication, ensuring their voice is heard clearly.?

?

Medtronic former CEO Omar Ishrak is an introvert who emerged as an exceptional leader with his strong strategic skills and ability to draw out the best qualities from his teammates, as he honed his public speaking skills to broaden his impact on others.?

?

Finding Balance in Leadership?

The best leaders—introverted or extroverted—understand the importance of self-awareness. Leadership is not about fitting a particular mold but about recognizing your strengths and balancing them with the needs of your team. Today’s best leaders are adopting the qualities that may not come as naturally, such as participative management for extroverts and public speaking for introverts.?

?

If you’re an introverted leader, challenge yourself to speak up when needed, engage with your team in more visible ways, and share your vision confidently. If you’re an extroverted leader, practice the art of listening, allow time for reflection, and encourage quieter team members to share their insights.?

?

Ultimately, great leadership comes from authenticity. Whether you lead with quiet reflection or dynamic energy, embracing your natural strengths while continuing to growth by adopting broader skills will make you a more effective and inspiring leader.?

?

I’m eager to hear how you leverage your leadership strengths. Please share your comments below.?

All the best,??

Bill George