Which Word Do You Recite In The Middle Bracha Of Mussaf Shemona Esrei Of Shabbat?
Today most Nusacha’Ot provide for ????? Why? That was the opinion of the ??? ?????.
The exception today is Chabad which follows the text that was provided in the ???? ????? ????. He was following the opinion of the ????"?.
One of the early Nusacha’Ot to provide for ???? was Nusach Provence:
What is ironic about this difference is that whether you should choose????? or ????, the meaning of the word hardly changes. Professor Moshe Bar Asher in his book: ?????? ???-????? ?????? ???? ??????, ????? ???????? ???????? tells the following:
So why couldn’t everyone agree on which version to recite? It appears that each side found verses from Tanach that supported their position and wanted to convey the meaning of the word as found in the verse from Tanach in his recital of this Bracha. Here are some examples:
Founding Director The Beurei Hatefila Institute | Training Judaic Studies Teachers To Teach Tefila | Provide Sources And Lessons | Encourage The Examination Of How Jews In Prior Generations Prayed
2 个月For anyone else who would like a pdf copy of this article, you can download it from here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wqlY-hyTN93vsTPd0QDKfYOtQoB74eER/view?usp=sharing
Assistant Chaplain at Mozaic Senior Services Bridgeport
2 个月Hi Can you send me this as a PDF? THX!