Where have all the brave creatives gone?
Robyn Young
Founder, Brand Strategist, and Creative Partner // If you can't out-spend the competition, you've got to out-brand them.
I've noticed a trend happening. Not just here on LinkedIn, but in conversations with (and commentary from) other strategists, brand marketers, designers, copywriters, agency owners, and clients alike. At first, I thought it was just me. But after extensive observation, I can say with certainty, it isn't just me.
We're starved for originality.
Wading through an endless barrage of unprecedented life events has made us individually numb, yet as a society increasingly discerning. The way the majority will 'dissect and reject' anything that has even the slightest whiff of edginess, and regularly praise mediocre work has relegated us to this insipid dystopia - chasing a mirage of societal acceptance.
Too many brands have been playing it safe.
Because, God forbid your work piss off the collective audience with a polarizing message lest your company's stock price dip down half a percent. You'd be out of a job. In this economy? No thank you. It's much easier to just follow what everyone else in the category is doing.
Make no mistake, most creatives are reluctant participants.?
This extends beyond the marketing world too. When was the last time you saw a new film with truly phenomenal writing and thought, "That quote will stay with me"? Or an iconic ad that you know you'll be talking about for years to come? Or a piece of modern art that you swore reached in and found a part of your soul you didn't know existed??When was the last time you laughed so hard, you nearly peed your pants?
I see it on the faces of fellow creative sufferers (when I do get to be in person with them), and in between the lines of their thoughtfully crafted LinkedIn rants too.?The need to constantly chase views and attention is killing both their spirits and their work.
In one recent post from Leigh (Citarella) Mosley asking why nothing feels 'cool' anymore, brand strategist Ravi Jayanath summed it up perfectly, commenting...
"We've rounded the edges off of society with algorithms."
领英推荐
We've lost our sharp edges because what makes things feel 'cool' - while highly subjective - comes down to what viscerally feels bold and different. Something that surprises you. It's hard to be surprised anymore when you have an assembly line pumping out same-same ideas to appease the masses, perpetuated by an increasing reliance on AI, and manufactured to serve the master algorithm.
We're rewarded for playing to the crowd.
We're so focused on what converts that we've forgotten how to be original. It feels safer (and smarter) to be aggressively formulaic. You can feed your family and pay your mortgage on formulaic. Maybe you're not thriving, but at least you're not starving either.?
Everything is an iteration of something else now. Perhaps because everything is expected to be faster, cheaper and proven before starting - which is hardly a recipe for originality. Clients love the idea of putting out bold work, but are rarely prepared to accept the implications of doing so. We count ourselves lucky when a few brave souls are up to the challenge.
Meeting the speed of culture often feels like jumping on a bullet train for most creative departments.
And the bigger the brand, the more red tape you need to go through, and the less willing to take risks with rare, audacious ideas that need time to breath before they produce results. To make truly original work also means we'd have to let go of testing ideas in a Petri dish. Let go of what panders to the masses, and lean into the kind of rare confidence and integrity that comes with letting great work (and great brands) be the goal.?In other words, make intention, not attention, be the goal. (thank you, Oana Leonte ?? ).
So, where have all the brave creatives gone?
The answer is clear. They're right in front of you. Just waiting for someone to release the shackles and grant them the freedom (and bandwidth) to take risks, try something new, be bold, and do what they were trained - and in most cases (unfortunately) untrained - to do. Without feeling that their jobs are on the line if the risks don't pay off. They need to be reminded how to mine original ideas again. How to use their intuition and humanity to connect with other humans again. And how to reflect that in their work.
If you need help to get the ball rolling for your creative team, DM me.
Creatives, if you've made it this far into my rant, I implore you, take more digital detoxes. Get out, and find something (anything) that makes you feel more like a human again. And when you find these things, share them with the rest of us - not because you need to hit your weekly LI posting quota, but because they are genuinely worth talking about.?
Personal branding that drives success—transforming business owners and executives into recognized, authentic stand-out experts with lasting impact. Personal Brand Strategist & Photographer.
3 个月I feel sometimes that I spend more time figuring out “how to make it work” than actually doing the thing that I really want/think/love. Maybe it’s time to really do.
Brand Marketing Consultant & Freelance Strategist
3 个月SUCH a ?? quote: "We've rounded the edges off of society with algorithms." I love that. Luckily, there is so much soul-stirring inspiration to be had outside the world of marketing. We have the tough job of ensuring fear, and algorithm-led clients that inspiring or entertaining consumers is key to also informing them.
Brand Strategy & Marketing – SaaS, Sports, Auto, QSR, CPG
3 个月??????
Creative Strategist // X-LEGO, Ikea, King // LEGO? SERIOUS PLAY? method facilitator
3 个月Great article !! Great points ! As a creative I really relate to everything you said ?? When you work in large organisation nobody wants to take risks and they want to please the masses! And I am a strong believer that “ if nobody hates it nobody really loves it “ . Now the buzz is to be “data driven “ which is another way to stop risk taking and so creativity Everything now looks the same . Ads are the same , brands look the same , fashion looks the same … everything is beige and so boring ! I now took a career break a sort of “digital detox” and cycled from Sweden to Italy to reset my creativity …let’s see where this will take me next Thanks for the great article one again ??
Group Creative Director at Hudson Rouge
3 个月Testing, data, analytics, algorithms, best practices, and their ilk make for formulaic work. The best work almost always tests the worst. Because it has a point of view. And all of the above require that it doesn't.