When the Bull Run Ends: Planning for a Changing Economic Cycle

For a while, many private clubs have enjoyed the benefits of membership waitlists and a robust economic cycle. For some, however, financial worries are on the horizon, and clubs must prepare for the possibility that this prosperity may not last. Clubs can navigate these changes with strategic planning, which will help maintain their appeal even when waitlists dwindle.

Understanding the Member

Members of private clubs spend substantial amounts annually, ranging from $5,000 to $20,000+ on dining, events, lessons, merchandise, tournaments, junior member activities and other amenities, in addition to the membership dues. This spending is crucial for a club's financial health, but dependence on this spending can become a vulnerability when economic conditions change.

Clubs often face challenges in encouraging members to use their facilities regularly. Busy lifestyles, competing interests, and a lack of engagement can all contribute to a lack of use. Additionally, geographic location and the quality of amenities play a crucial role in whether members choose to spend their leisure time at the club.

External factors such as economic downturns, changes in personal financial situations, and shifting priorities can prompt members to resign. Moreover, the rise of alternative recreational options and evolving social preferences can lure members away. Clubs must stay attuned to these trends to retain their membership base.

In a changing economy, attracting new members becomes increasingly challenging. Prospective members may prioritize financial security over luxury spending, and clubs might face stiff competition from other leisure activities. Clubs need to differentiate themselves and offer unique value propositions to potential members.

Here are some solutions for common obstacles clubs can face when the economy changes.

??

Member Feedback Program: Regularly survey members to understand barriers to usage and preferences.

• Timeline: Start planning immediately; rollout within one month; gather initial data in three months. Metrics: Response rates to surveys, common themes in feedback and changes in member usage patterns post-implementation.
• Data Analysis and Tracking: Implement a system to track member spending habits and identify trends. Timeline: Begin planning immediately; rollout within three months; initial results in six months. Metrics: Monitor spending categories (dining, events, amenities), frequency of club usage, and changes in spending patterns.

Enhanced Programming: Develop a diverse and personalized calendar of events and activities that cater to various interests and foster a sense of community. Regularly survey members to understand their preferences and tailor offerings accordingly. A robust calendar can boost member participation.

• Timeline: Begin planning within one month; roll out new programs in three months; expect participation growth in six months. It takes time to build habits and popular programs. Metrics: Attendance numbers, member engagement levels, event satisfaction ratings.

Personalized Offers: Use spending data to create customized offers and promotions tailored to member preferences.

• Timeline: Plan within one month; rollout in two months; expect results within four to six months. Metrics: Track redemption rates of offers, increased spending in targeted categories, and overall member satisfaction.

Membership Value Communication: Clearly communicate the value and benefits of membership through regular newsletters, social media, text messages and updates.

• Timeline: Start planning within one month; rollout in two months; monitor engagement within four to six months.
• Metrics: Open rates, click-throughs, member feedback, and changes in member retention rates. Track and measure to see member behavior changes.

Referral Incentive Programs: Encourage current members to refer friends and family. Offering incentives for successful referrals can be an effective way to grow the membership base organically.

• Timeline: Plan within one month; roll out in two months; see results in three to six months. Metrics: Number of referrals, conversion rates of referred members, overall membership growth.

Flexible Membership Options: Introduce varied membership tiers (not membership discounts) and payment plans to accommodate different financial situations. Offering trial memberships or seasonal packages can attract new members who might be hesitant to commit long-term during uncertain economic times.

• Timeline: Plan within two months; rollout within four months; see results in six to nine months.
• Metrics: Uptake of new membership tiers, feedback from trial members, conversion rates to full membership.

Investment in Amenities and Services: Continually invest in and upgrade club amenities to ensure they remain attractive. Incorporate wellness programs, modernize fitness facilities, and enhance dining options to meet current trends and member expectations.

• Timeline: Begin planning immediately; phased rollout over six months to a year; expect impact in 12-18 months.
• Metrics: Member satisfaction surveys, usage rates of new amenities, and overall membership retention rates.

Financial Planning and Reserves: Build financial reserves during prosperous times to cushion the impact of economic downturns. Developing a long-term financial plan that includes potential economic scenarios can help clubs remain resilient.

• Timeline: Begin planning immediately; ongoing process.
• Metrics: Financial health indicators, reserve fund growth, budgeting and forecasting, ability to withstand economic fluctuations.

Exit Interviews: Conduct exit interviews with resigning members to understand their reasons and address common issues.

• Timeline: Plan and implement within one month; ongoing process.
• Metrics: Common reasons for resignation, changes in resignation rates, implementation of suggested improvements.

?

Verifying ROI

To verify the return on investment (ROI) of these solutions, clubs should focus on several key metrics:

• Financial Performance: Track revenue growth, cost savings, and overall profitability.
• Member Engagement: Monitor participation rates, satisfaction levels, and feedback.
• Membership Metrics: Analyze new member acquisition rates, retention rates, and reasons for resignations.
• Program Effectiveness: Evaluate the success of specific programs and initiatives through targeted surveys and usage data.

?

By systematically implementing and tracking these strategies, clubs can navigate economic changes effectively and ensure sustained success even when the bull run ends.

?