What's the process for a Ph.D. dissertation to be rejected by an Indian university? And how many revision rounds are allowed before final rejection?

What's the process for a Ph.D. dissertation to be rejected by an Indian university? And how many revision rounds are allowed before final rejection?

The process for rejecting a Ph.D. dissertation in an Indian university typically involves several stages:


  • Initial Evaluation ----> Dissertation Evaluation
  • Review and Feedback ----> Feedback could include suggestions for "clarifying arguments" or "expanding research.
  • Revision ----> Revision varies based on feedback.
  • Second Evaluation ----> The revised dissertation is re-evaluated.
  • Final Decision ----> Accepted or rejected.


Initial Evaluation:

The dissertation is submitted to the doctoral committee or board of examiners. They evaluate it based on various criteria such as originality, significance, methodology, clarity of writing, and adherence to academic standards.

Review and Feedback:

The committee provides feedback to the student, pointing out areas(Engineering field, Management field) for improvement or revision. This feedback may include suggestions for additional research, clarification of arguments, or addressing deficiencies in the methodology or Research Data Analysis.

Revision:

The student revises the dissertation based on the feedback received from the committee. This may involve substantial revisions or minor adjustments, depending on the nature of the feedback.

Second Evaluation:

After the revisions are made, the dissertation is resubmitted to the committee for re-evaluation. The committee reviews the revised dissertation to determine if the concerns raised in the initial evaluation have been adequately addressed.

Final Decision:

Based on the second evaluation, the committee makes a final decision on the acceptance or rejection of the dissertation. If the committee is satisfied with the revisions and considers the dissertation to meet the required standards, it may be accepted. However, if the committee still has significant concerns or believes that the dissertation does not meet the necessary criteria, it may be rejected.

As for the number of revision rounds allowed before final rejection, this can vary depending on the policies of the specific university and the discretion of the doctoral committee. Some universities may allow multiple rounds of revisions, while others may have stricter limits. It's essential for students to closely follow the guidance provided by their university and communicate effectively with their supervisory committee throughout the process to ensure that they meet the necessary requirements for acceptance.

We are expertise for publishing articles in international scientific journals, SCI-indexed journals, Scopus indexed journals, IEEExplore, ScienceDirect, SpringerLink, ACM library, etc., Thesis/Dissertation preparation & proofreading, technical and non-technical proof-reading for all kind of research drafts, etc.

We also provide Ph.D. Assistance, Ph.D. Consultancy,Ph.D. Guidance,Ph.D Coaching,Ph.D. Admission,Ph.D. Course, phd help etc

要查看或添加评论,请登录

GoToppr Best phd services的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了