What are you?

IR35 legislation was introduced to address "disguised employment," where workers are classified as contractors to benefit from tax advantages, even though their working conditions resemble regular employment. To comply with IR35, especially in relation to job content and hiring practices, it is essential to distinguish clearly between a contractor and an employee based on specific factors. Here's a breakdown of how to comply with IR35 and why hiring someone on a Fixed-Term Contract (FTC) can be a more prudent and strategic decision.

How to comply with IR35 in terms of job content

1. Clear definition of contractor role vs. employment:

• Control: Contractors should have a high degree of control over how they complete their tasks. They should not be subject to micromanagement or detailed instructions from the hiring company, unlike employees who are typically expected to follow company policies and processes.
• Substitution: Contractors should ideally have the right to send a substitute in their place, as this reinforces the notion that they are providing a service rather than their personal labour.
• Mutuality of obligation (MOO): An important IR35 criterion, MOO refers to whether there is a continuous obligation from the employer to provide work and the contractor to accept it. A contractor should be engaged for specific tasks rather than an ongoing employment relationship where the expectation is that they will continue to work beyond the scope of the contract.
• Financial risk: Contractors usually face financial risk, such as bearing the cost of any errors they make or needing to correct work at their own expense. They may also need to invest in tools, equipment, or training to complete their work.
• Integration: A contractor should not be deeply integrated into the company structure. For instance, they shouldn't appear on the internal staff directory, have the same benefits as employees, or use a company email address in a way that suggests they are part of the core team.

If these elements are clear and adhered to, the role would likely be classified outside IR35.

Why Hiring on a Fixed-Term Contract (FTC) Makes Sense

1. Wider Talent Pool:

• By opting for a Fixed-Term Contract (FTC) rather than a contractor role, you can attract a broader range of candidates. Not every skilled professional is open to working outside IR35, especially those who prefer the stability of employee rights and benefits, like paid leave, pension contributions and job security.
• Contractors operating outside IR35 typically need to manage their own taxes and pensions and this may deter some candidates. FTC roles, which offer tax deductions through PAYE (Pay As You Earn), can be more appealing to professionals who prefer the simplicity and security of having these matters handled by the employer.

2. Compliance and Risk Mitigation:

• IR35 compliance puts a significant burden on hiring managers to ensure the role is genuinely outside IR35. Misclassification could lead to hefty fines, back-taxes, and penalties if HMRC decides the contractor was, in fact, an employee in disguise.
• With an FTC, the company fully complies with employment regulations, removing the risk of IR35 violations altogether. An FTC means that the individual is an employee for the duration of the contract, complete with tax withholding, national insurance contributions (NICs), and auto-enrolment into pension schemes. This also mitigates the future risk of scrutiny or legal issues around employment status.

3. Easier management of talent:

• Contractors, by nature, have more autonomy over their work and how they deliver results. While this independence can be an advantage in some cases, it may not align with business needs that require more day-to-day management and collaboration.
• Hiring an employee on an FTC ensures more control and easier integration into the company culture and processes. FTC employees are likely to be more invested in the success of the company during their term, while contractors are more likely to focus on fulfilling their immediate contract obligations without deeper engagement.

4. Cost vs. long-term value:

• While hiring contractors can save on employment costs (e.g., no pension contributions, no holiday pay, no national insurance contributions), these savings are short-term. Over time, companies may find that they are limiting their talent pool and struggling to retain knowledge or build team cohesion, as contractors come and go quickly.
• FTC hires provide continuity, especially for longer-term projects, and while the company incurs costs like employer NICs and pension contributions, the investment often results in more stability, employee commitment, and retention of organizational knowledge during the project period.

Complying with IR35 requires ensuring the role offered is genuinely one of a contractor: the worker has control over how they do the work, they are not integrated into the organisation, there is no mutual obligation beyond the task at hand, and they take on a level of financial risk. However, while IR35 compliance is possible, it is complex and businesses run the risk of future investigations.

By hiring on a Fixed-Term Contract (FTC) basis, companies can sidestep the intricacies of IR35 while broadening their talent pool, ensuring compliance, and gaining more managerial control over employees. The additional costs associated with hiring employees, such as employer tax and auto-enrolment, are offset by access to a larger, more engaged candidate pool and the long-term benefits of team stability and cohesion.