What is Woke? The Five Types of Woke?
Satyajit Datar
40 year experienced structural engineer, technical director, practice leader, mentor, teacher
March 8, 2024 is International Womens Day.? It is great day for celebrating and supporting women in all ‘walks of life’, worldwide.? Alas, it is also a day and a movement that is seen negatively by some people and labelled ‘woke’.
Over the last few years the use of the word ‘woke’ has become common in ‘Western’ countries such as Australia and the USA, amongst many levels in society, from prominent people such as politicians, business leaders and journalists to common people. I feel that the original meaning of the word has been lost and has been replaced by a ‘catch-all’ derogatory term aimed at marginalising any group that one does not identify with.? This is despite the many changes in the world for the better, that have taken place only because of the courage and persistence of subsets of people, usually minorities, in some cases with the support and empathy of the majority.
It would be a sad day and a major backward step for the world if we reverted to accepting lies, obfuscations and gross generalisations as truth, to prosecute agendae against many minority groups.? That is not to say that all minority groups are righteous and tolerant of others.? There clearly are many exceptions. Nevertheless, we should apply critical thinking and look objectively at the present day and the lessons of history, before being quick to judge whether a policy is good or bad.
When we do look objectively it becomes evident that so much of what we take for granted in the developed world today, could have once been considered ‘woke’. Civilisations have a lot to be thankful for the great ideas and ingenuity that have enabled transformations out of barbarism, poverty and hardships. Going forward, we as professionals in our fields of expertise, have great responsibility to ensure that good design, good policy and good practice is not prevented by egoic identity politics.
What is ‘woke’ though? There appears to be five categories for the meaning of the word ‘woke’.
1.???? The original meaning with a positive connotation - for people who were awake to injustices towards and disadvantages of minority?groups in societies.
2.???? A derogatory term for situations in which the pendulum was believed to be, though not necessarily was, over-corrected, and the (formerly) disadvantaged minority was perceived to have been given an unfair positive advantage, rather than simply a fair and equitable playing field. An example is quotas for reduced barriers to entry based on gender, religion, skin colour, socio-economic disadvantage and so on.? This category of woke, pays no heed to common situations in the world today, in which there are complete barriers to freedom of expression and to employment and career advancement, based on religion or ethnicity, in theocratic and autocratic nations. ? Another example is protective tariffs or subsidies for the benefit of a subset of industries, products or services.? However these are not considered to be woke, if they are considered essential and necessary for national security, economic prosperity or simply applauded based on egoic identities of nationalism.
3.???? A derogatory term for situations in which any attempt at raising the plight or position of any disadvantaged group towards parity (not above parity), is seen as woke. Those seeking equal rights for women to vote, work outside the home, drive a car and many other so-called women’s issues, would be considered ‘woke’. Diversity, equity and inclusion policies in workplaces would be considered ‘woke’. This woke is very selective, depending on one’s egoic identities.? Hence the Australian Football League’s (AFL’s) Indigenous Round and Pride Round are woke, but the spectacularly successful, annual Anzac Day match since 1995 at the MCG is not woke; though each are showing empathy, respect and gratitude towards a minority subset of society who are often “doing it tough”.
4.???? Concepts, beliefs, behaviours and institutions - which today?represent a “majority” position that were (most likely) previously a minority position and are symptomatic of a different set of entrenched beliefs aimed at marginalising a group.? The above women’s issue examples could also be this 4th category. There are many examples of good ideas by design, that were invented or used by a minority group, but are today widely accepted, utilised by the majority and are changes for the better. The mobile phone and smart phone are two prominent examples. In my profession of engineering, equitable access provisions in public spaces comes to mind, such as ramps, escalators and lifts instead of stairs, automatic doors, wheelchair access to public transport and principles of crime prevention through environmental design (CPTED). Numerous labour-saving devices such as home appliances, and widely accepted design inventions such as electricity, refrigeration and air-conditioning, would also fit into this category.
5.???? A 'nonsense woke' category, that is a derogatory term for things that have little to do with the above, but are simply things that some subsets of people do not like, are ignorant of, or choose not to understand about other subsets of people, and label them woke, out of laziness, arrogance or ego. This 5th type of woke is arguably for anything that you choose not to find a better description to defend your dislike of. Professional tennis player Jordan Thompson’s outburst at the Australian Open in January 2024 is an example of this 5th type; Jordan believed that it is woke to permit the disturbance of allowing spectators to move from their seats at the end of each game, instead of every 3 games, as had previously been the rule.? Conversely?one could argue that the tennis?players are the woke ones, who insist on silence during play, unlike most if not all other professional sportspeople in football, rugby, cricket, basketball, netball, hockey, swimming and so on.
Ron de Santis in Florida?last year in the lead up to the USA Republican primaries, had a slogan of “this is where woke comes to die” despite having many ‘woke’ categories of 3, 4 and 5, amongst his constituents and "base" that he was appealing to; despite them being massive beneficiaries of numerous things today that were created for the benefit of a minority; such as women voting, women working outside the home and material benefits such as air conditioning, equitable access provisions such as automatic doors, and many labour saving devices.
Perhaps categories 2 and 3 are the same? However, I believe they are separate and the crux of the matter.? People’s initial reactionary response was due to a perception of unfairness and over-correction.? Type 3 has since morphed into 4 and 5.
Below is a list of a 100 ‘woke’ things; from transformational, large and significant to small and mundane, (in no order) that are mostly type 3, 4 and 5, that people have been benefitting from or accepting willingly for years, centuries/millennia or are relatively new to the world.
I am sure some of the items can be combined or expanded and that you can think of another 100.
Next time you hear someone make a disparaging remark about something being 'woke', listen and then evaluate what they say. What type of 'woke' are they referring to? Does it really stack-up? Hold them to account.
1.???? The invention of the wheel
2.???? Travelling in a car instead of a horse/bullock cart
3.???? Having time off work on weekends
4.???? Having time off work on public holidays, and for annual leave and sick leave
5.???? Women being allowed to vote
6.???? Women having paid work outside the home
7.???? Black or brown skinned people being allowed to vote
8.???? Objection to slavery
9.???? Contraception rights
10.? Abortion rights
11.? Rule-of-law and a judicial system
12.? Free press / Independent media
13.? Workplace health and safety laws
14.? International Womens Day
15.? Valentines Day
16.? Anzac Day and any initiatives to acknowledge and support war veterans
17.? Queen’s/King’s Birthday
18.? National Day / Australia Day
19.? Any religious holiday
20.? Believing or not-believing in an external God
21.? Setting a condition for receiving unconditional love from humans, animals and failing that, from an external God
22.? Going to (or not going to) a church, temple, mandir, mosque …
23.? Believing or not-believing in astrology or similar things
24.? Footballers and cricketers having concussion substitutes on the playing field
25.? Batters in cricket wearing protective equipment such as a helmet, pads and gloves
26.? Sunscreen for your skin
27.? Sunglasses for your eyes
28.? Wet suits for cold water
29.? Stubby holders for cold beer bottles
30.? No smoking inside planes
31.? No smoking in restaurants, bars, and pubs
32.? No smoking in various public places such as offices, railway stations and sports stadia
33.? Wearing seatbelts in cars
34.? Having traffic signals and lane markings on roads
35.? Public roads
36.? Having a “working with children” police clearance for any leadership positions with children
37.? Professional tennis players insisting on silent spectators when playing tennis
38.? Telephones and telegraphs
39.? Mobile phones
40.? Smart phones
41.? Nappies for babies and/or elderly incontinent people
42.? “Total Fire Bans” in hot, dry summers
领英推荐
43.? Seating at stadia instead of standing room only
44.? Public transport – trains, trams, buses, ferries
45.? Public health care
46.? Social security
47.? Public hospitals
48.? Any hospitals
49.? Fire brigades
50.? Ambulances
51.? Houses (as apart from living outside)
52.? Public housing
53.? Public toilets
54.? Clean water and public water supply systems
55.? Public sewerage systems and sanitation
56.? Public electricity services
57.? Public gas services
58.? Public prison (corrective services) systems
59.? Frequent Flyer programs and lounges
60.? Escalators and lifts
61.? Wheelchair access to public transport
62.? Automatic doors
63.? Labour saving devices such as vacuum cleaners, dishwashers, brooms, power tools, air dryers …
64.? Air conditioning
65.? Refrigeration
66.? Hot showers
67.? Shampoo
68.? Soap
69.? Lipstick
70.? Perfume
71.? Jewellery
72.? Toilet seats
73.? Toilet paper
74.? Tissues
75.? Cutlery and crockery
76.? Water fountains in public places
77.? Shade in public places
78.? Public swimming pools
79.? Concessions for the elderly, disabled, pregnant and children and infants
80.? Surf life savers at beaches
81.? Swimming between the flags at beaches
82.? Umbrellas
83.? Scarves, gloves, hats, boots, and coats for cold weather
84.? Hats for sunny, hot weather
85.? Money/Currency instead of pure bartering
86.? Currency exchanges
87.? Passports and visas
88.? Customs and border controls
89.? Progressive taxation (in which the rich pay more)
90.? Unions of any type
91.? Behaviours of common courtesy such as saying “please, thank you, good morning, goodbye, goodnight” and waiting patiently in queues
92.? Behaviours such as accepting the results of fair elections and decisions
93.? Advertising your goods and services for sale
94.? Attention seeking by displaying your name at the top of tall buildings
95.? Attention seeking by graffiti
96.? Attention seeking by writing and commenting on social media posts
97.? Cosmetic surgery and pharmaceuticals
98.? Indoor dining at indoor restaurants (in the days when nobody had heard of it) and outdoor dining at outdoor restaurants (in the days when everybody had forgotten about it)
99.? Barista coffee (in the days when nobody had heard of it - in places like Australia)
100.??????????????? Take-away food (in the days when nobody had heard of it - in places like Australia)
Management Professional
2 天前Good article Satyajit Datar, clarifying and thought provoking. I agree that a good concept seems to have lost its focus and is cutting it's own legs. Need to be aware and listen.
Bridge Engineer | Former Casual Academic Staff and Tutor at Department of Civil Engineering (Structures) and Thai Student Alumni, Monash University | Excellence in Customer Service and Business Management Enthusiast |
11 个月Thanks for your post, Satyajit Datar. Indeed, many things we take for granted today were once exclusively limited to the more privileged class in society!