What the Super Bowl taught us about Performance Max

Super Bowl LIX was a masterclass in strategy.

The Philadelphia Eagles didn’t just rely on talent—they executed a structured, adaptive game plan to shut down the Kansas City Chiefs’ explosive offense in a 40-22 victory.

Defensive coordinator Vic Fangio kept Patrick Mahomes under constant pressure, forcing turnovers and neutralizing key threats. The Eagles didn’t just react—they controlled the game, proving that smart strategy beats raw firepower.

??? Believe it or not: A successful PMax campaign works the same way!

If you let Google’s AI run unchecked, it will chase quick wins (low-margin conversions) instead of long-term profitability—like a defense focusing only on big hits instead of stopping scoring drives. Without a structured, adaptable strategy, you're just reacting instead of winning.

So let's get your strategy checked:

?? The "All-in-One" mistake: PMax as a one-man-show

Google’s default strategy? Throw all your products into one campaign with a single tROAS target.

Sounds simple. Because it is. But that’s pretty much like expecting one star player to carry an entire team, ignoring the rest of the roster.

?? What happens?

• Best-sellers hog the budget → Like a team overfeeding their star wide receiver while ignoring other weapons.
• ROAS looks great, but profits suffer → Think of a star player racking up stats while the team struggles to win games.
• New, seasonal, and high-margin products disappear → Just like a rookie talent sitting on the bench all season because the coach won’t give them minutes.

Example: Running a Sports Retail Store

?? Google sees that $10 headbands convert easily → so it funnels all your budget into them.

?? Meanwhile, $250 basketball shoes (your real profit drivers) never get exposure.

Your campaign’s stat sheet looks great, but your revenue growth stalls—just like a team with a stacked roster on paper that fails to make a deep playoff run.

? Fix It: Build a Balanced Game Plan

1. Create separate campaigns for high-margin, seasonal, and longtail products.
2. Use custom labels to categorize products based on demand & profitability.
3. Analyze performance beyond ROAS—focus on gross profit contribution.

??The "One-Attribute" mistake: An over-simplified play

Some advertisers realize they need structure, so they start segmenting PMax campaigns.

?? But if you only segment by one attribute (like past sales or margins), you’re missing key insights—like a coach who only runs plays based on last week’s highlights, ignoring this week's opponent’s defensive scheme.

• Clicks ≠ sales → A high-margin item getting clicks doesn’t mean it’s converting.
• Past performance ≠ future demand → Just because a product sold well last month doesn’t mean it will this month.
• Ignoring basket effects → PMax doesn’t recognize when a low-margin item leads to a high-margin upsell.

Example: Sports Retail Store

? You separate products by high-, mid-, and low-margin groups.

?? But Google still pours budget into high-volume, low-margin baseball caps, instead of pushing your high-end signed jerseys.

? Fix It: Call smarter plays with multi-dimensional segmentation

1. Combine margin-based segmentation with demand & product lifecycle stage.
2. Group products strategically—high-margin, seasonal, entry-level, & new arrivals.
3. Use audience signals to refine product visibility.

?? The "one-dimensional" mistake: Ignoring seasonality & inventory

Retailers often forget how stock levels and seasonality impact PMax performance.

• Low-stock products → Advertising nearly sold-out items is like the 2022 Denver Broncos, who invested heavily in Russell Wilson but didn’t have the offensive line to protect him.
• Seasonal trends → Google won’t automatically shift spend to products with upcoming demand surges.
• New product launches → If a product has no past sales, PMax won’t prioritize it—unless you intervene.

Example: Sports Retail Store

?? You launch a new Eagles Super Bowl LIX championship jersey, but since it has no past sales, Google won’t push it.

?? Meanwhile, last year’s discounted Chiefs jerseys still eat up ad spend—even though demand is fading.

? Fix It: Make real-time adjustments like a halftime coach

1. Use custom labels for new & seasonal products to influence bidding.
2. Reduce bids on low-stock items to prevent wasted spend.
3. Feed real-time inventory data into Google Ads for smarter budget allocation.

?? The winning playbook: Multi-dimensional segmentation

The best PMax strategies don’t just react to the game; they control it.

Instead of letting Google’s AI play on autopilot, you need to feed it structured insights to guide decision-making.

?? Winning setup for a sports retail store

1. Focus on profitability & demand trends—not just past sales.
2. Run separate campaigns for high-margin, seasonal, & new products.
3. Use custom labels for priority products to prevent budget hogging.
4. Track performance beyond ROAS—adjust based on profit, not just conversions.

?? The result?

Your budget flows to the right products at the right time, driving sustained profitability—just like the New England Patriots’ dynasty under Bill Belichick, where every play was designed for long-term success, not just short-term stats.

?? Key takeaways: How to structure a profitable PMax game plan

?? Forget "set it and forget it." PMax needs guidance, structure, and ongoing optimization.

• Avoid one-size-fits-all campaigns—break out high-margin, seasonal, and longtail products.
• Don’t segment by just one attribute—use a mix of profitability, demand, and product lifecycle.
• Factor in real-time inventory & seasonality—make sure high-priority products get visibility.
• Optimize for profitability—not just ROAS.

PMax can be a game-changer, but only when you control the playbook.

Letting Google handle your ad spend without structure is like giving an AI full control of your Super Bowl offense—it will optimize for easy yards, not the championship win.

?? Want to learn the step-by-step setup for a profitable PMax strategy?

Check out our ultimate PMax optimization playbook:

?? BLOG: THE ULTIMATE PMAX CAMPAIGN OPTIMIZATION GUIDE

?? Enjoyed what you read?

Why not subscribe to the smec Conversion Corner?

Your bi-weekly one-stop-shop for everything performance marketing, Google Ads, PPC and industry insights. Delivered every other Tuesday to your mailbox!

Don't be shy, subscribe now:

?? smec CONVERSION CORNER