What is Retention? Guide to managing retentions in construction

Retention is a fundamental part of construction contracts, designed to protect project owners while ensuring contractors meet their obligations. Despite its significance, retention can often be a source of confusion and disputes, especially when it comes to releasing withheld funds. This guide breaks down retention, provides practical insights, and shares strategies to manage it efficiently.

What is Retention?

Retention is a financial safeguard in construction contracts where a percentage of a contractor’s payment is withheld until project completion and defect rectification. Typically, 5-10% of the contract value is retained, with funds released in two stages:

Practical Completion: A portion of the retention is released when the project reaches substantial completion.

Defects Liability Period: The remaining amount is released after a specified period, once all defects are addressed.

The primary goal of retention is to encourage high-quality work and ensure any issues are resolved post-completion.

How Retention Works: A Practical Example

Consider a contractor working on a $1,000,000 project with a 5% retention clause. This means $50,000 will be withheld, distributed as follows:

During the project execution phase, $25,000 is held back and released upon practical completion. The remaining $25,000 is then withheld until the defect liability period ends and all necessary repairs are completed. This system ensures accountability and quality throughout the project’s lifecycle.

Key Retention Clauses in Construction Contracts

A well-structured contract is essential in avoiding disputes. Key elements of a retention clause include:

• Retention Percentage: Dictates how much of the contract value is withheld—typically between 5-10%.
• Release Conditions: Specifies when and how retention funds will be paid out. Usually, a portion is released upon practical completion, with the rest following the defects liability period.
• Defects Liability Period: A crucial part of retention management, lasting between 6 to 24 months, ensuring construction defects are addressed before the final payment.
• Retention Cap: Some contracts include a limit to prevent excessive withholding, balancing financial security for the project owner and cash flow stability for the contractor.

Clearly defined retention clauses promote transparency, reduce ambiguity, and build trust between all parties involved in a construction project.

Retention serves different purposes for different stakeholders. For project owners, it provides financial security, ensures work quality, and offers leverage for defect rectification. For contractors, while it guarantees accountability, it can also impact cash flow, making financial planning essential.

Head contractors must also manage retention money properly, ensuring that subcontractors receive their due payments without unnecessary delays.

How to Claim Retention Money

Retention money isn’t automatically released—it must be claimed once all contract conditions are met. The first step is keeping detailed records of completed work, including proof that any defects identified during the defect liability period have been fixed. Without proper documentation, payments can be delayed or disputed.

Once all obligations are fulfilled, contractors should submit a formal request for the release of retention money. Clear communication with the project owner or contract administrator helps prevent delays. Regular follow-ups ensure the request is processed on time and doesn’t get lost in the system.

The Challenges of Retention Management

For contractors and subcontractors, retention money being tied up for extended periods can create significant cash flow issues. Some common problems include:

• Delayed or Non-Payment – Even after meeting contract conditions, some contractors face difficulties retrieving their retention money.
• Disputes Over Defects – Disagreements on defect rectification can lead to further delays in payment.
• Lack of Transparency – Poorly defined contract terms can result in miscommunication and unfair withholding of retention funds.

Best Practices for Managing Retention

To mitigate these risks, contractors must adopt proactive retention management strategies. Here’s how:

1. Clearly Define Retention Terms in Contracts

A well-structured contract reduces ambiguity and helps protect both parties. Retention clauses should specify the percentage to be withheld, conditions for release at each project stage, defect liability period duration (typically 6-24 months), and a retention cap to prevent excessive withholding.

2. Maintain Accurate Documentation

Keeping detailed records is critical to ensuring retention is released on time. Contractors should document completed work and rectified defects with photos and reports, track all progress payments and withheld amounts, and keep copies of all communications regarding retention money.

3. Submit Retention Claims Promptly

Don’t wait until the last minute to claim your retention money. Submit a formal claim as soon as contract conditions are met, communicate proactively with project owners or principal contractors to avoid unnecessary delays, and follow up regularly to ensure timely release of funds.

4. Address Non-Payment Issues Quickly

If retention isn’t released on time, review the contract to confirm all obligations are met, engage in discussions with the project owner to clarify any issues, issue formal notices requesting payment if communication fails, and seek legal advice if disputes persist.

5. Improve Financial Planning

Retention can put a strain on cash flow, so contractors should factor retention into financial planning to avoid liquidity issues, negotiate favorable retention terms where possible, and explore financing options to cover short-term cash flow gaps.

Final Thoughts

Retention is a crucial part of construction contracts, but managing it effectively is key. Contractors who stay informed, maintain documentation, and communicate clearly can avoid disputes and secure timely payments. A proactive approach ensures financial stability and smooth project completion.

Read the full article here.