What is Forfaiting? Part 2
Mark S. Mandula
Chief Learning Officer @ BCR Publishing | Global Finance Expert
Which is better, factoring or forfaiting?
Whether factoring is better than forfaiting or vice versa depends on the specific circumstances and needs of the business. Both factoring and forfaiting have their own advantages and disadvantages, and it is important to consider them before choosing between the two.
Factoring can provide businesses with immediate cash flow, without the need to wait for payment from customers. Factors also assume the responsibility of collecting payments from customers, which can save time and resources for businesses. However, factoring can be more expensive than forfaiting, and factors typically require a certain level of creditworthiness from the customers.
Forfaiting, on the other hand, is a more suitable financing technique for businesses engaged in international trade, particularly when dealing with high-risk customers or countries. Forfaiting can provide businesses with upfront cash, without the need for credit insurance or other forms of security. However, forfaiting typically involves longer-term receivables, and the discount rate may be higher than factoring.
Ultimately, the choice between factoring and forfaiting depends on the specific needs of the business, the creditworthiness of the customers, and the terms of the transactions. It is important to carefully consider the costs, benefits, and risks associated with both financing techniques before making a decision.
What are some of the benefits of forfaiting?
Forfaiting can provide several benefits to businesses engaged in international trade, including:
1.??????Upfront cash flow: Forfaiting provides businesses with immediate cash flow, allowing them to improve their working capital and invest in their operations without waiting for payment from customers.
2.?????Reduced risk: Forfaiting transfers the risk of non-payment from the exporter to the forfaiter, allowing businesses to reduce their credit risk and protect their cash flow.
3.????Improved competitiveness: Forfaiting can help businesses become more competitive by offering customers more flexible payment terms and reducing the time and cost associated with collecting payments.
4.????Access to new markets: Forfaiting can help businesses expand into new markets by providing them with the financial resources they need to take on larger or riskier projects.
5.????No collateral requirement: Forfaiting typically does not require collateral or other forms of security, making it a more flexible financing option for businesses that may not have sufficient assets to pledge as collateral.
6.????Simplified administration: Forfaiting can simplify administration for businesses by reducing the time and cost associated with collecting payments, managing receivables, and handling currency conversions.
In summary, forfaiting can provide businesses engaged in international trade with several benefits, including immediate cash flow, reduced risk, improved competitiveness, access to new markets, no collateral requirement, and simplified administration. Businesses should carefully evaluate the benefits and risks of forfaiting before deciding whether to use this financing technique.
What are the risks associated with forfaiting?
Forfaiting, like any financial transaction, involves risks that businesses need to be aware of before deciding to use this financing technique. The main risks of forfaiting include:
1.??????Credit risk: The biggest risk associated with forfaiting is the risk of non-payment by the importer. If the importer defaults on payment, the forfaiter may seek to recover the amount owed from the exporter. As a result, the exporter should carefully evaluate the creditworthiness of the importer before engaging in a forfaiting transaction.
2.?????Interest rate risk: Forfaiting typically involves long-term receivables, and the discount rate is based on prevailing market interest rates. If interest rates rise significantly during the term of the receivables, the discount rate may not be sufficient to cover the forfaiter's costs, resulting in a loss for the forfaiter.
3.????Foreign exchange risk: Forfaiting involves transactions in foreign currencies, which exposes businesses to foreign exchange risk. Fluctuations in exchange rates can impact the value of the receivables and the amount of cash received by the exporter.
4.????Political risk: Forfaiting often involves transactions with buyers in emerging markets or politically unstable countries, which can expose businesses to political risks such as expropriation, currency controls, or war. Exporters should carefully evaluate the political risk before engaging in a forfaiting transaction.
领英推荐
5.????Legal risk: Forfaiting transactions involve complex legal agreements, which can expose businesses to legal risks if the agreements are not properly drafted or enforced. Businesses should seek legal advice to ensure that the forfaiting transaction is legally enforceable and that they are fully protected.
In summary, forfaiting involves risks that businesses should carefully evaluate before deciding to use this financing technique. It is important to understand the risks involved and to take steps to mitigate them.
What does it cost?
The cost of forfaiting depends on several factors, including the creditworthiness of the importer, the term of the receivables, and prevailing market interest rates. In general, the cost of forfaiting is higher than traditional financing methods, such as bank loans or lines of credit, because it involves the transfer of risk from the exporter to the forfaiter.
The forfaiting cost is typically expressed as a discount rate, which represents the difference between the face value of the receivables and the amount paid upfront by the forfaiter to the exporter. The discount rate can vary widely depending on the specific circumstances of the transaction.
For example, if the exporter sells $100,000 worth of receivables to a forfaiter with a discount rate of 5%, the forfaiter will pay the exporter $95,000 upfront (i.e., $100,000 minus 5%). The forfaiter then assumes the risk of non-payment by the importer and collects the full amount due from the importer when the receivables mature.
The discount rate charged by forfaiters can vary widely depending on the creditworthiness of the importer, the country risk involved, the term of the receivables, and other factors. Typically, longer-term receivables and higher-risk transactions will incur a higher discount rate. It is important for businesses to carefully evaluate the cost of forfaiting before entering into a transaction, and to consider other financing options as well.Top of Form
What kinds of Due Diligence questions should I be asking a forfeiter?
When considering a forfaiter, it is important for businesses to conduct due diligence and ask relevant questions to evaluate the forfaiter's reputation, financial strength, and ability to provide reliable and cost-effective financing. Here are some due diligence questions to consider when evaluating a forfaiter:
1.??????What is your experience with forfaiting, and how many transactions have you completed in the past year?
2.?????What types of transactions do you typically finance, and what is your risk appetite?
3.????What are your underwriting criteria, and how do you evaluate the creditworthiness of the importer?
4.????What is your discount rate, and how is it calculated?
5.????What fees do you charge, and what other costs are associated with the transaction?
6.????What currencies do you accept, and how do you manage foreign exchange risk?
7.????What is your approach to managing legal and regulatory compliance risks, including anti-money laundering and sanctions compliance?
8.????What is your reputation in the market, and can you provide references or case studies of successful transactions?
9.????What is your capacity to manage large or complex transactions, and what is your turnaround time for providing financing?
10. What is your approach to communication and relationship management with clients, and how do you provide ongoing support and advice?
By asking these and other relevant due diligence questions, businesses can gain a better understanding of a forfaiter's capabilities, reputation, and ability to provide reliable and cost-effective financing.