What do I think of CAs?

I am not a CA.

I did not study at an IIT, I am not even an engineer.

?I did not go an IIM, I am not even an MBA.

Which is how I can muster up the courage to say that if there is an island of educational excellence in India it is the CA Institute.?More so than even the IIMs.

World over, India is known for the great crop of students that come out of the IITs and the IIMs. The world needs to know about the great CAs we produce.??

To appreciate why I am putting ICAI above the IIMs, one needs to ask a very basic question. What is a good education? What should a good education deliver?

Over at the IITs and the IIMs, they take in only the best and then work on making them better. But at the ICAI, anybody can get in so long as certain minimum standards are met. But one has to go through the grind to graduate with a degree.?Yes, it is not easy , one has to work hard for it. But anybody can get in, unlike the situation that obtains in an IIT or an IIM.?

At an IIT or an IIM, they take an uncut diamond and turn it into a sparkling one. Over at ICAI, they provide the opportunity to shine even to students who may not have had a great academic run. While at the IIMs, the entrance exam is meant to keep weaklings out, the ICAI uses the exam only to keep the non serious out by keeping the entry?qualification sufficiently low.

But that in no way affects the rigour of the grind they put their students through. Becoming a CA is tough, very tough. Everybody has a fair chance to get in, even those with a poor academic record in the past.?They give you a second chance.?That is what makes ICAI a great institution and socially relevant. Because, in my view, the quality of an educational system is not about how many good people they take and make them better. But how many people they take and make them better.

From the time I founded IRIS, the company of which I am the CEO, I have interviewed hundreds of job seekers from all sorts of backgrounds. The CAs, I have discovered, are in a league of their own, above everyone else.??

Perhaps it is high time they learned to communicate this better.

The author is the Founder & CEO of IRIS Business Services Limited, a global Regtech listed on the BSE, which employs a number of CAs and is looking for many more. Twitter: @iris_swami?

CA Lokendra Shekhawat

Lead - Credit Guarantee & Subsidy Schemes | Financial Analysis, Internal Audits

3 年

Excellent stuff??

回复
Nandita Sampath

Principal Product Manager | Leading Microsoft Applied Skills | Empowering Tech Professionals with Real-World Skill Validation & Career Growth | Advocate for Lifelong Learning & Career Growth

3 年

Love it! The analogy is relevant to my current work too!

回复
Indu Madhavan

Transitioned to Social Impact

3 年

Absolutely agree Swami! The last line is key.. they must learn to communicate it better!

回复
Tijo Joseph

Finance & Operations through Digital transformation

3 年

Swami sir loved your post..one more good thing is the low investment cost for pursuing the course unlike the MBA course..I personally chose CA because apart from nominal registration fees & exam fees there is no course fees as such.. even if you go for coaching classes the cost would be less than 2.5 lacs for the entire course.

回复
Naitik Shah

Investment, WhiteOak Capital | IIM Lucknow (IR 10) | CA | Ex-Deloitte M&A | naitikshah.substack.com

3 年

This message could not have been put across in a better way. Thank you Swaminathan S for putting it out there. Great writing!

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Subramaniam Swaminathan的更多文章

  • A call to the IOC president to preserve the Olympics Spirit

    A call to the IOC president to preserve the Olympics Spirit

    Reproduced hereunder is the letter I sent to the IOC and the Court of Arbitration for Sport. Ref: CAS OG 24/17 Vinesh…

    7 条评论
  • Thank you RBI

    Thank you RBI

    This week we were formally notified that IRIS Business has won a prestigious global award from the highly respected…

    25 条评论
  • If your consulting firm wont make you Partner

    If your consulting firm wont make you Partner

    You are a #director at a consulting firm. You deserve to make partner.

    2 条评论
  • Reimagining HR in a post covid world

    Reimagining HR in a post covid world

    Excerpt from the speech of IRIS Business Services Limited Chairman, Shri Vinod Agarwala at the Company AGM held on…

    1 条评论
  • In gratitude to RBI

    In gratitude to RBI

    On Friday, August 26, IRIS Business Services Limited, the firm of which I am the Founder & CEO will receive an award…

    51 条评论
  • In gratitude to the women @ IRIS

    In gratitude to the women @ IRIS

    Excerpts from the speech delivered by Vinod Agarwala. Chairman, at the AGM of IRIS Business Services Limited held on…

    20 条评论
  • Is data really the new oil?

    Is data really the new oil?

    Data, they will have you believe is the new oil. But is it really? Could it meet the same fate that oil faces…

    2 条评论
  • Who will be the next Wire Card?

    Who will be the next Wire Card?

    For the uninitiated, Wire Card is the biggest scandal to visit the German market in recent times. It is Germany's Enron.

    3 条评论
  • Innovation at the AGM

    Innovation at the AGM

    At the AGM of IRIS Business Services Limited, the firm of which I am the Founder & CEO, we broke new ground. The law…

    2 条评论
  • Thank you Azim Premji for the valuable lesson you taught me

    Thank you Azim Premji for the valuable lesson you taught me

    Azim Premji turned 75 on July 24. Happy birthday, sir.

    6 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了