What are the commercial software packages in the market for WESM SIMULATION

What are the commercial software packages in the market for WESM SIMULATION

In the Wholesale Electricity Spot Market (WESM) simulation space, there are several prominent commercial software options designed to assist market participants, regulators, and system operators with bidding strategies, market analysis, and energy system optimization.

Below are some of the main commercial software packages used for WESM simulation:

1. PLEXOS

? Features: o Market Simulation: PLEXOS simulates WESM to forecast prices, optimize generation dispatch, and plan transmission operations. o Optimization: It uses mixed-integer programming (MIP) and linear programming (LP) for precise results in market bidding, generation, and transmission planning. o Unit Commitment and Economic Dispatch: It handles multi-stage optimization for unit commitment, economic dispatch, and production cost modeling. o Renewable Integration: Models renewable energy and storage in various market and grid configurations. o Forecasting: Uses detailed load forecasts and price predictions for spot markets. o Stochastic and Deterministic Analysis: Capable of running both for risk analysis and probabilistic planning.

? Applications: o Price forecasting and market analysis. o Generation and transmission planning. o Bidding strategy optimization for market participants. o Power market regulation and policy planning.

? Price of License: Pricing depends on the scope and scale of the system model. For large utilities or system operators, costs can range from $20,000 to over $100,000 per year. Customization and add-ons will affect the total price.

? Training: Training services are available from PLEXOS and third-party consultants. Training typically costs around $1,500 to $5,000 per participant for basic to advanced training courses.

? Computer Specs: o Processor: Intel Core i7 or better. o RAM: 16 GB minimum (32 GB recommended). o Storage: SSD with at least 500 GB. o OS: Windows 10 64-bit.

2. AURORA

? Features: o Comprehensive Market Simulation: Provides detailed market simulation, from bidding to market clearing, incorporating WESM rules. o Long-Term and Short-Term Forecasting: Supports both long-term investment planning and short-term operational forecasting. o Stochastic Simulation: Models uncertainty in fuel prices, demand, and renewable output. o Transmission Modeling: Can handle detailed transmission analysis, including locational marginal pricing (LMP). o Data Integration: Supports integration with third-party data for fuel prices, demand forecasts, and renewable output.

? Applications: o Market clearing price simulation and analysis. o Generation asset valuation. o WESM bidding strategy development. o Regulatory and policy planning.

? Price of License: AURORA licenses generally start around $30,000 per year and can increase significantly based on the features and the number of users.

? Training: Training programs are available online and in-person, typically priced between $2,000 and $6,000 per participant.

? Computer Specs: o Processor: Intel Core i7 or better. o RAM: 16 GB minimum (32 GB recommended). o Storage: SSD with at least 500 GB. o OS: Windows 10 64-bit.

3. GridSIM

? Features: o Power Market Simulation: Focused on simulating market operations, including bidding, market clearing, and price forecasting for wholesale markets like WESM. o Hydrothermal Coordination: Models hydro and thermal generation to optimize dispatch based on WESM rules. o Multi-Stage Optimization: Optimizes bidding and dispatch for different market timeframes (day-ahead, intraday, real-time). o Price Formation and Forecasting: Detailed modeling of price formation in wholesale electricity markets.

? Applications: o Market participant strategy optimization. o WESM pricing analysis and forecast. o Policy and regulatory impact analysis. o Transmission and generation planning. ?

Price of License: Typically priced between $20,000 and $60,000 per year, depending on the size and complexity of the market model. ? Training: Training costs around $2,000 to $5,000 per participant, with additional charges for advanced features.

? Computer Specs: o Processor: Intel Core i5 or better. o RAM: 16 GB minimum. o Storage: 500 GB SSD. o OS: Windows 10 64-bit.

4. PROMOD IV

? Features: o Integrated Market Simulation: Combines market simulation with unit commitment and dispatch, using detailed operational data from the power market. o LMP Calculation: Calculates locational marginal pricing for detailed transmission and congestion analysis. o Forecasting and Scenario Planning: Supports long-term forecasting and scenario analysis to evaluate various market conditions. o Renewable Integration: Models renewable generation and storage resources, optimizing them in market operations.

? Applications: o WESM and other wholesale market price forecasts. o Congestion analysis and transmission planning. o Regulatory planning and market monitoring. o Generation investment and retirement decisions.

? Price of License: License pricing starts at $25,000 to $50,000 per year, depending on the scale of the simulation. ? Training: PROMOD offers both on-site and online training, usually priced between $2,000 to $4,000 per participant.

? Computer Specs: o Processor: Intel Core i7 or better. o RAM: 16 GB minimum. o Storage: 500 GB SSD. o OS: Windows 10 64-bit.

5. GAMS (General Algebraic Modeling System)

? Features: o Optimization Platform: A flexible optimization software often used for power market simulations, including WESM. o Customizable: Users can create their own market models, including bidding strategies, price forecasts, and unit commitment algorithms. o Stochastic and Deterministic Modeling: Capable of solving both types of problems for market analysis. o Large-Scale Optimization: Suitable for solving large-scale, complex power market models with detailed constraints. o Interface Integration: Supports integration with various data management and visualization tools.

? Applications: o Custom WESM modeling for price forecasting. o Transmission and generation planning. o Policy analysis and strategic market bidding.

? Price of License: Pricing can range from $10,000 to $50,000 based on model complexity and user requirements. ? Training: GAMS offers online and in-person training programs, typically priced between $1,000 to $3,000 per participant.

? Computer Specs: o Processor: Intel Core i7 or better. o RAM: 16 GB minimum. o Storage: 500 GB SSD. o OS: Windows 10 64-bit, macOS, or Linux.

6. iEnergy (RECOMMENDED BY MARCIAL OCAMPO)

? Features: o Market Simulation for WESM: iEnergy specializes in simulating the Philippine WESM, replicating market operations, bidding behavior, and price formation based on actual WESM rules. o Day-Ahead and Real-Time Market Forecasting: It offers both day-ahead and real-time price forecasting capabilities, helping market participants optimize their strategies. o Unit Commitment and Economic Dispatch: Similar to other market simulation software, iEnergy provides detailed unit commitment and dispatch modeling for power generators in WESM. o Transmission and Congestion Management: Provides tools to analyze grid congestion and its impact on locational marginal prices (LMPs). o Integration with Data Sources: iEnergy can integrate with a variety of data sources, including generation, load, and weather data, to improve the accuracy of simulations. o Risk and Scenario Analysis: Models uncertainty in factors like fuel prices and demand, providing detailed risk analysis tools.

? Applications: o Market Participant Bidding Strategy: Market participants use iEnergy to test and optimize their bidding strategies in the WESM. o Price Forecasting and Analysis: WESM stakeholders, including market operators and regulators, use iEnergy for short-term and long-term price forecasting. o Regulatory and Policy Planning: iEnergy is also used to assess the impact of regulatory changes on the market, providing insight into policy planning. o Transmission Planning: Market operators can model transmission constraints and congestion impacts using iEnergy.

? Price of License: o iEnergy license costs vary depending on the user type (market participant, system operator, or regulatory body) and the scale of the system being modeled. o For commercial utilities or market operators, licenses typically start at around $30,000 per year, and can exceed $70,000 depending on customization and add-ons.

? Training: o iEnergy offers tailored training programs for market participants and operators, focusing on both the software functionality and its application to WESM operations. o Costs for training range between $2,000 and $6,000 per participant, depending on the level of training (basic to advanced).

? Computer Specs: o Processor: Intel Core i7 or better. o RAM: 16 GB minimum (32 GB recommended). o Storage: SSD with at least 500 GB. o OS: Windows 10 or later

. Comparison with Other Tools:

1. iEnergy vs PLEXOS: o Market Focus: While PLEXOS is a global tool used in many markets, iEnergy is tailored specifically for WESM, providing highly detailed simulations of WESM-specific rules and conditions. o Price: iEnergy is similar in price to PLEXOS, with license costs ranging from $30,000 to $70,000, but iEnergy's WESM specialization might offer better value for users focused solely on the Philippine market.

2. iEnergy vs AURORA: o WESM Simulation: iEnergy is more focused on WESM, while AURORA is used across a range of wholesale markets globally. iEnergy's detailed WESM integration offers better granularity for Philippine market simulations. o Features: AURORA may offer more flexibility for users interested in multiple markets, but iEnergy’s integration with WESM data sources is superior for Philippine market-specific forecasting.

3. iEnergy vs GridSIM: o Market Specialization: Both iEnergy and GridSIM offer comprehensive market simulations, but iEnergy is more tailored to the WESM, making it more accurate for forecasting and bidding in the Philippines. o Transmission Planning: GridSIM might have a more generalized approach to transmission planning, while iEnergy includes highly specific tools for WESM's transmission pricing and congestion management.

4. iEnergy vs PROMOD IV: o Price: iEnergy is comparably priced to PROMOD, but offers more direct integration with WESM data and market rules, making it preferable for those solely operating in the Philippine market. o Application: PROMOD might be more suited for markets with complex congestion and transmission issues, while iEnergy focuses on delivering accurate market behavior simulations within WESM.

Conclusion: iEnergy is a valuable tool for stakeholders in the Philippine WESM, providing deep integration with market-specific rules and data. Its price and features are competitive with global software like PLEXOS and AURORA but with a focus on the WESM's unique dynamics. For market participants and regulators operating in the WESM, iEnergy offers precise market forecasting, bidding strategy simulation, and transmission analysis tailored to the Philippines' energy market conditions.

HOW ABOUT IEA's MESSENGE IS IT USED IN WESM? IEA's MESSENGER is not commonly used for simulating or analyzing the Wholesale Electricity Spot Market (WESM) in the Philippines. MESSENGER is the International Energy Agency's (IEA) energy system modeling platform designed to assist in evaluating and forecasting the performance of global energy systems, focusing on long-term planning and policy scenarios. It is more of a macroeconomic energy planning tool and does not specialize in the real-time, short-term, market-specific functions required for WESM simulations.

Key Reasons Why MESSENGER is not Used for WESM:

1. Focus on Global Energy Systems: o MESSENGER is used to model large-scale energy systems and global markets, not specific to any one country's spot market. It's primarily for long-term energy planning and evaluating policies across sectors. o WESM requires tools that handle short-term electricity market simulations like bidding strategies, price formation, transmission congestion, and other market behaviors. MESSENGER does not focus on these aspects.

2. Short-Term vs. Long-Term Modeling: o WESM simulation tools (e.g., iEnergy, PLEXOS, AURORA) are designed for real-time and day-ahead forecasting of electricity prices and market conditions. o MESSENGER focuses on long-term scenario analysis and is ideal for national and regional energy policy evaluation rather than dynamic, short-term market simulations needed in WESM.

3. Market-Specific Details:

o WESM simulations require granular details about market rules, bidding behavior, dispatch, transmission constraints, and pricing models, which are specific to the Philippine electricity market. o MESSENGER does not include these detailed market functions, as it is used more for high-level energy demand forecasting, technology adoption trends, and carbon reduction pathways .

Common Applications of MESSENGER: ? Energy Policy Planning: Governments and international organizations use MESSENGER to project energy demand, supply scenarios, and the effects of energy policies. ? Climate Change Scenarios: It is widely used for modeling the impact of energy transitions on carbon emissions and tracking progress toward net-zero goals. ? Global Energy Modeling: Suitable for exploring future energy mixes, fuel use, and the integration of renewable energy in long-term global scenarios.

Conclusion: While MESSENGER is an excellent tool for global, long-term energy policy modeling, it is not suitable for the WESM due to its lack of focus on short-term market operations and the specific rules and dynamics of electricity spot markets. For WESM, dedicated tools like iEnergy, PLEXOS, or AURORA would be more appropriate.

By: MARCIAL OCAMPO

?????? [email protected]

?????? 63-967-3143774 (Globe Mobile, Viber, WhatsApp)