#WednesdayWisdom - Arc Spray vs. Flame Spray:

Thermal spray processes are critical in numerous industries, providing surface enhancements to improve wear resistance, corrosion protection, and thermal barriers. Two popular methods in this domain are Arc Spray and Flame Spray. Both techniques have their own sets of advantages and drawbacks, making them suitable for specific applications. This article will delve into the pros and cons of each method, helping professionals make informed decisions on which process to use.

Metal Spraying | Thermal Spraying Processes | Metallisation

What is Arc Spray? (Video: Arcspray process - Metallisation Ltd)

Arc Spray is a thermal spray process where two consumable wire electrodes are melted by an electric arc. Compressed air is then used to atomize the molten material and propel it onto the substrate. This technique is widely used for applying metallic coatings, especially for corrosion protection and repair of worn-out components.

Pros of Arc Spray

High Efficiency: Arc Spray is known for its high deposition rate, making it an efficient process for large-scale applications.

• Cost-Effective: The process uses relatively inexpensive equipment, materials and running costs, reducing overall operational costs.
• Strong Adhesion: The coatings produced by Arc Spray generally have excellent adhesion properties, ensuring long-lasting performance.
• Versatility: This method can handle a wide range of materials, including metals & alloys, making it highly versatile.
• Low Thermal Input: The process has a low thermal input to the substrate, reducing the risk of distortion or thermal damage.
• Automation – Easier to automate within production environment.

Cons of Arc Spray

• Surface Roughness: The coatings can be relatively rough in compassion to flame spray.
• Limited Material Choices: While versatile, Arc Spray is primarily limited to conductive materials, making it unsuitable for certain applications.
• High Noise Levels: The process can be quite noisy, which may require additional safety measures and protective equipment.

What is Flame Spray? (Video: Flamespray process - Metallisation Ltd)

Flame Spray is another thermal spray process that uses the combustion of a fuel gas and oxygen to melt the coating material, which is then atomised by compressed air and sprayed onto the substrate. This technique is often used for applying coatings of metals and ceramics

Pros of Flame Spray

• Material Flexibility: Flame Spray can be used with a good range of materials, including ceramics, making it ideal for diverse applications.
• Lower Equipment Costs: The equipment for Flame Spray is generally less expensive and simpler to operate compared to other thermal spray processes.
• Portability: Flame Spray equipment is typically portable, making it suitable for field applications and repairs.
• Controlled Coating Thickness: This method allows for precise control over coating thickness, which can be beneficial for specific applications.

Cons of Flame Spray

• Lower Deposition Rate: Compared to Arc Spray, Flame Spray has a slower deposition rate, which can make it less efficient for large-scale applications.
• Higher Thermal Input: The process involves higher heat input to the substrate, increasing the risk of thermal distortion or stress.
• Higher Running Costs: Cost of gases generally are more expensive than solely electric and air of the Arcspray unit
• More Operator Skill Required: The quality of Flame Spray coatings is highly dependent on the operator's skill, leading to more variability in the results. - Training - Metallisation Ltd

Conclusion

Both Arc Spray and Flame Spray offer unique advantages and come with their own sets of challenges. Arc Spray is the preferred choice for applications requiring high efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and strong adhesion, especially with metallic coatings. On the other hand, Flame Spray excels in its material flexibility, portability, and suitability for field repairs.

The choice between these two thermal spray processes should be guided by the specific needs of the application, including the type of material to be coated, the required coating properties, and the operational environment. By carefully weighing the pros and cons of each method, you can optimise the coating processes for the best possible outcomes.

Contact Us - Metallisation Ltd