We wargamed everything except the Kamikaze... or the enemy's transition from offense to defense will produce incredible innovation...

Kamikaze's, Baka Bombs, and Cherry Blossoms

                       Flowers of the special attack are falling

                          When the spring is leaving

                          Gone with the Spring

                          Are young boys like cherry blossoms

                          Leaving cherry trees only with leaves.[1]

           

           Leading up to the planning for the defense of Okinawa, the Japanese began recognizing the materiel superiority of the Americans and acknowledging their lack of materiel support and control of the air and sea domains. The Japanese still owned a battle-tested land army made up of 5,000,000 veterans.[2] Along with this human capability, the Japanese refused to concede their perceived spiritual preeminence, the source of the perceived superiority of the Japanese soldier compared to his American counterpart. Thus, the Japanese channeled their Bushido warrior code and spirit of self-sacrifice into using individuals to operate platforms, planes, rockets, boats, and individual swimmers, while they preserved their large land formations for attrition of American forces. 

           In October of 1944, the Japanese commander of the First Air Fleet in the Philippines, Vice Admiral Taijiro Onishi, organized a special attack unit (tokkotai) consisting of young men willing to fly their airplanes into American ships.[3] The results indicated that this was an effective method due to a small number of Kamikaze planes inflicting almost as much damage on the American fleet as Admiral Kurita's fleet in the biggest naval battle in history.[4] A few months later, as the American fleet supported the fight on Iwo Jima, small groups of Kamikaze pilots sank an escort carrier and severely damaged the carrier Saratoga.

           These attacks led Admiral Toyoda, who commanded all Japanese air forces in the East China Sea, to concentrate large numbers of airframes on Kyushu and Formosa to converge on the U.S. Military forces around Okinawa.[5] This convergence of assets led to massed waves of kamikaze attacks. The first of these waves struck on April 6 and inflicted a "distressing amount of damage."[6] A chart constructed to depict these attacks[7] showed the non-linear operational area of Okinawa. The Japanese attacked U.S. Navy ships in all cardinal directions in the island's littorals and near sub-objectives on the smaller islands that orbit Okinawa.

           The number of aircraft used dramatically increased the probability of a ship getting hit during the Battle for Okinawa. After-action reports showed that some ships were attacked by up to 50-planes, with as many as nine hits reported.[8] This accuracy was due to the projectiles guided by human pilots rather than simply dropping inert torpedoes or bombs. With the losses of experienced pilots in the Battle of the Leyte Gulf and other engagements, the Japanese found that even inexperienced pilots were able "to make corrections and to take evasive actions – feats which no ordinary bomb can perform."[9]

           Unique to the Okinawa operation, the Japanese designed an air weapon specifically for suicide pilots, a piloted rocket bomb.[10] The Baka had a 2400-pound warhead and an airspeed indicator calibrated for 600 knots; therefore, the Baka was both deadly and capable of high speeds. Its range was only 30-35 miles; however, it moved to its objective attached to the fuselage of bigger planes called Betty's.[11] Reports from Okinawa indicated that a puff of brown smoke usually presaged its release from its escort. The Baka often appeared invisible, except for the brown smoke trailing it to its target.

           The Japanese use of suicide tactics in the air gave them numerous advantages. First, the Japanese doubled their operational reach in which they could target ships and ground-based supply and command nodes because there was no return flight. Second, the guided nature of the planes and Baka bombs allowed the Japanese to possess a guided missile capability before the technology existed to enable it. Thus, their sense of morality in the war gave them an edge in developing asymmetries to combat American materiel dominance. Third, they could use less-skilled flyers, particularly in some training aircraft, while saving more experienced flyers for the piloted missiles. This matching of pilots to equipment was necessary because of the loss of experienced aviators; thus, the quality of equipment and personnel should be aligned since there was not enough quality in either materiel or airmen.

           Japanese leaders also sought to inflict further damage on the American landing forces through piloted suicide boats and torpedoes, suicide swimmers, and lunge mines used against tanks by individual soldiers. The captured narrative from a talk given to Japanese Soldiers that were part of a suicide unit for use against tanks gives a new direction for self-sacrifice. "It is imperative that all troops have a thorough understanding of tactics of a suicidal nature, with each man destroying a plane, ship or tank to smash the enemy who depends on materiel superiority."[12] American momentum produced a significant change in Japanese posture in the Central Pacific Theater and manifested in Okinawa. Japanese military leadership expended human-delivered bombs against materiel targets. Still, they preserved their infantry formations for a war of attrition, anchored in one of the most formidable defense arrays in history.


[1] Hara, Japanese Destroyer Captain, 259; Russell Spurr, A Glorious Way to Die: The Kamikaze Mission of the Battleship Yamato, April 1945 (New York: Newmarket Press, 1981), 109.

 

[2] Craig L. Symonds, World War II at Sea: A Global History. Oxford University Press, 2018, 618.

 

[3] Craig L. Symonds, World War II at Sea, 619.

 

[4] Ibid., 587, 619. 

 

[5] Morrison, Victory in the Pacific, 181.

 

[6] Ibid., 181.

 

[7] Ibid., 183.

 

[8] CINCPAC-CINCPOA Bulletin 126-45, 4.

 

[9] Ibid., 3.

 

[10] Ibid., 13.

 

[11] Ibid. 

 

[12] CINCPAC-CINCPOA Bulletin 126-45, 36.

 

Lou Coatney

Historian, Game and Model Designer, Retired Librarian

1 年

Good report, Stephen. At Okinawa, more of our Navy personnel were killed (4907) than Army (4675), although the Marines lost 2,938 killed as well. In the Wiki article about the battle is this: "Japanese use of children." According to the Okinawa Prefecture, 1/3 of Okinawan civilians - hyped up and fearful by Bushido war propaganda - died in the battle. 1/3 of Japan's population would have been 24 million men, women, and children, certainly including the Emperor and his family. Our death ratio on Iwo Jima had been 1:3, and if there were 5 million Japanese combat troops awaiting us on the Home Islands, 1 million United Nations sailors, soldiers, and airmen dead - let alone prisoners who were to be massacred the moment we set foot on them - was probable ... contrary to what Skates and some other academics try to claim. I've read only 2 million were first-rate Japanese troops, but it was second rate Japanese personnel who fought the Battle of Manila so savagely, brutalizing and murdering Filipino innocents in the process. The atom bombs averted a real holocaust. A caption from the Wiki article."HMS?Formidable on fire after a kamikaze attack on May 4. The ship was out of action for *fifty minutes.*" !! Armored flight deck! ??

回复
Christopher Neff

Retired - Retired (Uniformed service (USN), Private Sector, GS Civil Servant (USMC)

1 年

concur - I have often repeated the phase - "you want a good lesson ... read an OLD book". The corollary to that axiom would be "you want a good idea talk to someone who is OLD - Been there - Done that". I had the privilege of working for LtGen John Toolan during my final years as a "civilian Marine". "In 2003, Toolan served as the Chief of Staff for?1st Marine Division?during the?march to Baghdad?as part of the Iraq War, serving under Major General?James Mattis. In 2004, he commanded?1st Marine Regiment?during the?First Battle of Fallujah." In the Book FIASCO - Toolan's success as he transitioned the battle to peace and stability was based on building a trust and partnership with the local population, a lesson of success from Vietnam. When his unit turned over the peacekeeping mission to a U.S. Army unit their CO decided to "Make Big Body" and abandon the partnership, Mattis called Toolan to prepare to redeploy the 1st MARINES because peace was being lost in Fallujah. When Toolan asked the General for a date, Mattis said November 10th, ... he was off by one day. - vrckn

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Stephen N.的更多文章

  • Part 1. Musicians of Mars: A Symphony of Deceit

    Part 1. Musicians of Mars: A Symphony of Deceit

    The United States Army frequently channels the thinking of one of its most famous World War II Generals, George S…

  • Why Polymaths?

    Why Polymaths?

    Why have great people done everything? This question plagued me throughout my life. I love to read.

    1 条评论
  • Policy Shaping Civilian-Military Interactions: Churchill's Example

    Policy Shaping Civilian-Military Interactions: Churchill's Example

    Strategy is an instrument of policy. Its requirements are subservient to the decisions made by civilian leaders.

    3 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了