We need to change the "change failure" narrative
Ron Leeman
I am a "die hard" Change Manager who delivers PRACTICAL, PRAGMATIC, and PERSONAL Change Management training. Contact me now and ask about my course, you won't be disappointed.
The Nature of Failure in Change Projects
Before delving into how Change Managers can mitigate failure, it's crucial to examine what constitutes "failure" in the context of change projects. The definition of success or failure is often subjective and can vary depending on who is assessing the outcome. Traditionally, success has been measured against the achievement of Business Benefits as outlined in the Business Case. However, this approach can be problematic due to the inherent unpredictability of projects.
The Changing Scope and Objectives
Projects rarely go exactly as planned. Changes in scope, unexpected challenges, and shifting priorities often lead to deviations from the original plan. When this happens, the Business Benefits initially outlined in the Business Case may no longer be regarded as being realistic or relevant. Despite these changes, many organizations continue to measure success against these outdated criteria, leading to a perceived "failure" even when significant progress or positive outcomes have been achieved.
Common Causes of Project Failure
Several recurring issues contribute to the high failure rates in change projects:
The Role of Change Managers
Given these challenges, it’s fair to question why organizations continue to employ Change Managers despite the high failure rates. The answer lies in the evolving nature of Change Management as a discipline. Change Managers are not merely project executors; they are facilitators of transformation who navigate complex organizational landscapes, mitigate risks, and align diverse interests toward common goals.
The Value of Change Managers
Strategic Guidance: Change Managers provide strategic oversight, ensuring that the change aligns with the organization's long-term goals and vision:
Recommendations for Change Managers
And now for the important part, to avoid the pitfalls of perceived failure, Change Managers can adopt several known practices that have been proven to work:
领英推荐
So there we have it
Yet more of my musings on one of my "pet subjects".
Do you think we will ever solve the success and failure conundrum and do you think we will ever be able to change the "failure narrative" that so many practitioners really love to use?
If you want my view, it all stems from your brain which is wired for failure so it is a matter of changing mindsets and becoming more positive and more vocal about success.
All the surveys I mentioned earlier seem to target the upper-echelons of organisations who are always wary of gaining an over-optimistic view but very few ask those impacted stakeholders what they think (mentioned above). At the end of the day the are the users and adopters of whatever has been delivered so shouldn't the decision come from them?
DO YOU ASK YOUR STAKEHOLDERS ABOUT SUCCESS AND FAILURE POST PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION?
If you do I would love it if you could share the results with me (if their not confidential) so I can compile a list of results pertaining to different types of implementations to get a realistic view of success or failure.
Below is some feedback from a post-implementation survey I did on a major transformation programme for a large Central Government project some years ago.
NOTE: Those of you who have been through my Driving Change Management course will recognise this as the Usage and Adoption Case Study
I have an idea
Whilst this won't do away with the argument how about a survey to real practitioners (not their C-Suite or Sponsor) ask, anonymously of course, if their latest endeavours are likely to have been successful and to what extent (an estimated % will do as all the others are). Whilst this is not very robust at least it will give us a "rule of thumb" as to what, out there in the big, wide world of honest practitioners is a little nearer the truth.
Helping Leaders Overcome Overwhelm & Procrastination, Build Confidence, Strengthen Focus & Take Decisive Action Under Pressure | Modern Mindset for Performance | Coach & Mentor | Speaker | Leadership Workshops
6 个月Benefit KPI's are almost non- existent as the project team have been moved on. So unless the business team are measuring it won't happen.
Experienced business development professional clinical research Phase I to Phase IV.
6 个月Insightful, informative and useful post. Thanks ??
???? ???? ?? I Publishing you @ Forbes, Yahoo, Vogue, Business Insider And More I Monday To Friday Posting About A New AI Tool I Help You Grow On LinkedIn
6 个月Empirical evidence > myths. Well said!?
Building a start-up fintech in the SRT space | Programme Director | Operations Director | SaaS | Blockchain | Building smarter digital workflows for capital risk management
6 个月Ron Leeman Whatever the numbers, they're not reliable as benefits realisation is rarely measured well if at all. I believe that most initiatives are partially successful, in that they achieve some but not all of the predicted benefits. But many of them take longer and cost more than envisaged. How do you think decision makers may be influenced to measure and report benefits realisation across all initiatives?
Organisational Change Manager
6 个月Ron Leeman great article and an important step towards identifying what constitutes failure of change initiatives. The need for "adaptive success criteria" is spot on. These are often not put in place at the outset, leading to inability of Sponsors to track the progress effectiveness and outcomes of the initiative.