Are We Losing Our Tradition of Compromise?
Courts did exist during the Colonial Era, but attornies at the time were more likely to act as “dealmakers and problem solvers” rather than court lawyers.
How compromise through deal making and problem solving became established as the preferred mode for dispute resolution can be seen in the negotiations leading up to the Declaration of Independence and at the Constitutional Convention. The delegates engaged in a dynamic decision-making process involving listening to all parties’ positions, engaged in caucusing and coalition building, found common ground, compromised, and built consensus. Most importantly, they shared a common attitude that agreement could and should be found.
In her 2016 acceptance speech at the Democratic National Convention, Hillary Clinton gave a colorful description of colonial era dispute resolution:
?“My friends, we’ve come to Philadelphia — the birthplace of our nation — because what happened in this city 240 years ago still has something to teach us today.
“We all know the story.
“But we usually focus on how it turned out — and not enough on how close that story came to never being written at all.
“When representatives from 13 unruly colonies met just down the road from here, some wanted to stick with the King.
领英推荐
“Some wanted to stick it to the king, and go their own way.
“The revolution hung in the balance.
“Then somehow they began listening to each other … compromising … finding common purpose.
“And by the time they left Philadelphia, they had begun to see themselves as one nation.”
In the following decade the colonists again listened, negotiated and through compromising with shared commitment, agreed upon the constitution.? Subsequent U.S. history is one of compromise. Not all compromised agreements were perfect, such as those after the Civil War, but negotiating using compromise became one hallmark of our country that continues to reflect who we are as a nation.
For those who question our willingness to listen in this manner, I hope this example serves as reminder as to how we became a great democracy in the first place.